Animals on Trial: Justice Gone Too Far?
Animals are obviously quite different to human beings.
They simply do not possess the same understanding that human beings do or operate by the same systems, including a coherent understanding on human law & order.
Seems simple right?
But there was a time when this wasn’t common knowledge.
In medieval Europe especially, there was a time where animals could be tried as criminals.
Animals were accused of serious offences, and even formal legal trials were held!
In one particular case, the Autun Rat Trials, a group of rats was blamed for destroying crops in the town of Autun, France.
The authorities had brought this to a church court instead of exterminating them, and the rats were formally summoned to address their charges!
They were even given a divorce lawyer, who genuinely argued that the summoning order had not been properly delivered to all of the rats, and that it was unsafe for them to attend court because of predators such as cats.
The court actually took these arguments seriously, and delayed the case.
This reflected how people of the time understood justice and order.
Everything in the world was a part of a moral system that required controlling, even outside of humanity.
Today, animals are not considered responsible for crimes as they cannot understand morality in the fashion that humans do.
Therefore, in the modern days, responsibility usually falls on the owner.
However, they can still be involved in legal decisions.
Courts have the power to decide what happens to a dangerous animal after an incident, but the focus always comes back to humans handling, rather than the animal itself.
It’s interesting to observe how legal progression has changed, and shows that ideas of justice and fairness are always prone to change and are never set in stone.