The Importance of Student Debate
Debate in Colleges and Schools, is a great chance to grow and enhance a wider skill set, explore a good career path and boost your confidence before going out into life after college.
Debate is a form of expression of different societal viewpoints and a great way to enhance your range of persuasive language.
The debate team at Franklin Sixth Form College is particularly an incredible thing to see and an excellent example.
Debate at Franklin, as Roy Horobin emphasises, is an extremely motivating and compelling pursuit.
Roy Horobin, a teacher at Franklin who runs Debate Club, said, “I’m enthusiastic about debate because I think it’s fun to do and I think that a lot of people have a fear of debate, but they do get used to it, I saw this in our annual debate competition. We had ten teams two teams from Tollbar, two teams from King Edwards and we had six teams from Franklin, and I really saw some people enjoying it. Our final motion was ‘this house believes Father Christmas is not real’ and the side arguing against the motion that ‘Father Christmas is real’ won the debate.”
Debate massively encourages students at Franklin to come up with new, inventive and persuasive arguments that gets them thinking critically.
The skill is often so brilliant that the house with the most unconvincing motion can win, which is very intriguing.
As mentioned, the competition (which gives students the fantastic opportunity to put their skill set into action) takes place annually with various other Sixth Forms and Colleges getting involved.
Roy explains that it was “tremendous,” in terms of the inventiveness and the fun which people were applying to it, while also explaining that there is a serious side to debate that prepares students for the communication they’re going to have to do after their time at Franklin.
Stressing the importance of this, he added that, “virtually everybody’s going to have to do some form of public speaking, some form of presentation – which is public speaking – and I don’t think in British education we prepare people enough for it.”
Something he is particularly interested in solving, is narrowing the gap between state schools and independent schools.
Roy continued by saying, “Independent schools, where students pay to go to, they do a lot of this, and you can really see the confidence they have; so, what I want is for our students, who are just as good, to have that confidence to be involved.”
Franklin has it's upcoming Oxford school’s competition in February, where they will be going up against independent schools which Roy describes as a “great opportunity” to put that theory to the test.
The Franklin Debate PPD takes place last period on a Wednesday, which in the last week of college before the new year, brought a very interesting debate to the table.
The argument was ‘Should you be expected to spend Christmas with people you don’t like/that annoy you.’
The house against the motion started the argument off strongly.
A student talked about their experience with coming out to their family as part of the LGBTQ+ community, which ended up with hateful comments made towards them; their argument was that 21% of victims didn’t tell anyone about the hate and that Christmas is supposed to be a time of joy. They argued, “why should I spend what’s supposed to be the happiest time of the year with people who don’t think I should have rights.”
Whereas the house for the motion, explained that between family there can often be irrational hatred, often caused by difference in personality and that people should show respect and not spark conflicts.
The opposing team bounced back by asking how that counteracts with their argument; the house for, continued by suggesting that ‘dislike’ and ‘annoyed’ refers to more minor things.
With a fantastically structured debate and strong elaborated argument, the house arguing why you should not have to spend Christmas this way, won.
What would your argument be?
Fellow student, Oscar Grzeminski, talked a bit about why he personally finds debate so intriguing.
“I love to hear other people’s views that I might’ve not previously thought about. It’s a really open space, everyone can share their opinions without being judged for it, which I think is a really wonderful thing because, we’re in a democratic country, so hearing other people’s points of views is probably the most valuable thing we can see. I also really like critically thinking about current events, which again I think is really important.”
As mentioned by Oscar, it’s such an enjoyable thing to be a part of for many people and a way to express societal opinions and expand on people’s viewpoints; while having this fun, a large skill set is being developed alongside it, which Roy explains thoroughly.
He said, “Employers ask about soft skills,” includes teamwork, problem solving communication, and listening skills which he believes (in particular) are underrated.
You are given a motion which you have around twenty minutes to prepare for and you’ve got to work out how you’re going to do it, effectively putting the soft skills into play - which Roy explained employers are stressing they want young people to possess.
He finished off by saying, “what employers are after is skills. They’re after people who can present, listen, work in a team, speak up and so it’s great for that.”
Franklin’s team is a great example of the importance of debate for students.
It’s something every school should hold as an opportunity to ready students for wider public interaction.
If it’s not already a current option at your local college/school, why not suggest it for the benefit of the pupils?
If you’re a student, you can make suggestions to teachers or even students who have authority, that will take action to spread the impact of debate.