York City deservedly beaten 3-1 by Barnet in top of table clash

York City were deservedly beaten 3-1 in their top of the table clash at Barnet. <i>(Image: Tom Poole)</i>
York City were deservedly beaten 3-1 in their top of the table clash at Barnet. (Image: Tom Poole)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A LACKLUSTRE York City were deservedly beaten 3-1 in their top of the table clash at Barnet.

Adam Hinshelwood’s side simply never turned up at The Hive and were made to pay by a Bees side who showed just why they are the National League leaders.

City could not match their hosts’ intensity, speed or energy, and were lucky to see only Adebola Oluwo’s 16th-minute goal separate the sides at the break.

Hinshelwood turned to his bench to introduce Josh Stones just past the half-hour, and Lenell John-Lewis at half time, but neither offered a much-needed spark.

It was all too easy for Lee Ndlovu to add Barnet’s second six minutes into the second half, and skipper Anthony Hartigan made it three from a free kick on the left wing shortly after.

Things threatened to worsen still for York, who were indebted to Harrison Male for the scoreline not widening further in the closing stages.

It was almost ironic when Malachi Fagan-Walcott did bundle the ball home in injury time, a just reward for the incredible 1,185 travelling fans who had made the 400-mile round trip to the capital.

However, City will know there is a lot to fix up ahead of next weekend’s derby at home to Halifax Town.

Hinshelwood named an unchanged squad from Saturday’s win at Ebbsfleet, with Pearce again given the nod over Stones up front.

Barnet meanwhile made three changes from their victory against Solihull Moors, with Ndlovu and Joe Grimwood returning to the side, and goalkeeper Toby Savin making his debut after joining on loan from Shrewsbury Town ahead of kick-off.

Rhys Browne was a late change to the starting line-up, replacing Mark Shelton following the warm-up.

City looked to get themselves ahead from the kick-off as Tyrese Sinclair raced onto a long ball over the top, but he was flagged offside as Savin raced out of his goal to clear.

That though was about as good as it got in a first half in which they were completely outmuscled and outclassed across the pitch.

City failed to register a shot on target and were incredibly fortunate not to trail by more than one goal at the break, such was Barnet’s sheer dominance.

A trio of corners inside as many minutes set the tone for the Bees, who saw Ryan Glover head their opening effort of the match narrowly wide on five minutes.

Only Browne knows how he did not put the Bees ahead just past the 10-minute mark as after Male had raced out of his goal prematurely, he somehow slotted wide of the empty net, when many fans, and even the scoreboard, believed he had put his side in front.

Barnet continued to apply the pressure, seeing two corners cleared before finally finding the opening goal in the 16th minute.

A long throw was flicked onto Oluwo, who toe poked the ball past Male from close range to see the hosts deservedly break the deadlock.

York needed a response but showed little sign of formulating one. They soon lost possession from a throw-in level with their own box, before Batty, under no pressure, sent a pass into the main stand.

Sinclair and Pearce threatened to offer a glimmer of hope on the half-hour after a series of neat passes inside the box, but the final pass was overhit and Savin was able to clear.

Needing something to change, Hinshelwood introduced Stones for Batty 13 minutes before the break, and initially he brought a physicality that saw things begin to look up for the Minstermen.

However, Barnet remained on top, and City needed two Callum Howe blocks to ensure they only went in 1-0 down at the break.

City won the reverse fixture by the same scoreline in October but had a night to forget at The Hive.City won the reverse fixture by the same scoreline in October but had a night to forget at The Hive. (Image: Tom Poole) Buoyed by the introduction of John-Lewis, York came out better in the second half, with the experienced striker inches away from latching onto Pearce’s dangerous cross from the right wing within seconds of the restart.

However, they soon settled back into the all too familiar lull of the first half.

Howe cleared an overhead kick off the line before Felix did just enough to see the ball out for a goal kick after a throw-in had been flicked on to the far post.

Barnet deservedly found a second in the 51st minute, Glover releasing Ndlovu into acres of space on the left wing before he cut inside and slotted the ball under Male into the bottom right-hand corner.

Consecutive free-kicks inside the attacking half then weren’t heeded, and after City had given away a third in as many minutes level with their box, Hartigan’s set-piece evaded everyone and flew into the back of the net as the hosts’ clinical start to the half continued.

Male was called into action again five minutes later after Ndlovu had somehow found space to square the ball for the onrushing Callum Stead, diving down well to his left to palm the shot away.

Hartigan forced Male into a reaction save before Browne tried his luck after weaving past three defenders, only to win a corner the visitors then cleared.

It was not until the 76th minute that the Minstermen began to test Savin, who punched an Alex Hunt free kick clear with Stones lurking.

Stones came close to adding his name to the scoresheet again with eight minutes left to play but came up short as he looked to pounce on a loose back pass that had left the debutant goalkeeper scrambling.

City thought they had scored a consolation as the game ticked into injury time after Stones’ pull-back found Pearce, but the division’s top scorer saw his close-range effort come back off the inside of the post and along the goal line before being cleared.

A goal did however come their way a minute later, Fagan-Walcott bundling the ball into the back of the net to finally give the travelling supporters something to cheer about.

Barnet did not give up in their pursuit of a fourth goal but thankfully for City it was not forthcoming, as a dismal night in the capital finally came to an end.

BARNET: Savin, Ndlovu (Clifford 81), Stead, Kanu, Glover (Brunt 84), Hartigan, Browne (Telford 89), Oluwo, Grimwood (Cropper 67), Tavares, Kenlock.

UNUSED SUBSTITUTES: Bellagambi, Coker, Okimo.

GOALS: Oluwo (16), Ndlovu (51), Hartigan (58)

YELLOW CARDS: Kanu, Glover, Tavares, Kenlock

YORK CITY: Male, Howe, Sinclair (Luamba 66), Hunt, Pearce, Nathaniel-George (John-Lewis 45), Armstrong, Batty (Stones 32), John, Felix, Fagan-Walcott.

UNUSED SUBSTITUTES: Watson, Fallowfield, Richardson, Aguiar.

GOALS: Fagan-Walcott (90+1)

YELLOW CARDS: Nathaniel-George, Felix

HALF TIME: 1-0

YORK’S STAR MAN: The fans. They travelled in phenomenal numbers for a Tuesday night in London and deserved more from their side against the league leaders.

ATTENDANCE: 4,050 (1,185)

REFEREE: Robert Massey-Ellis

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos