Should referees do post-match media? Here's what we think

York City found themselves involved in refereeing controversy on Tuesday night after racking up the cards against Barnet. <i>(Image: Tom Poole)</i>
York City found themselves involved in refereeing controversy on Tuesday night after racking up the cards against Barnet. (Image: Tom Poole)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

THIS is the next edition of our Ramsey Rambles column for subscribers of The Press and Gazette & Herald.

York City were embroiled in refereeing controversy on Tuesday night, and is it really right that it will now all just be swept under the rug?

York have had their fair share of good and bad referees over the years, as every club has, and sometimes it really is just a roll of a dice over what sort of official turns up.

They say the best refereeing performances are ones where you don’t even notice the ref, but sadly on Tuesday night, that wasn’t the case.

A total of 14 cards were dished out across the City and Barnet team at the Hive, with both bosses also being shown yellows, before an eventual red to Scott Lindsey.

You’d like to think that if both dugouts are clearly aggrieved to the point of receiving a booking each, that both teams have a right to answers.

But referee Ben Toner didn’t shy away or cool down the feisty temperatures, showing as many as seven cards after both bosses had been booked.

It’s fair to say the referee lost control of that game.

It’s not an easy job being a referee or a linesman, in fact it’s one of football’s most thankless jobs that you rarely see praise for.

The old saying of “who would want to be a referee” has never been more true, particularly as we appear to see controversy across the Football League every weekend.

But what more can be done to support these officials?

A referee at League Two level must officiate at a grassroots level, at county levels and then National League levels to earn a place in the Football League, but even then they need to go through training courses set out by the PGMOL.

You could argue that it’s a sufficient level of experience and training required, yet there is still controversy most weeks.

If you ever tune in to one of my live blogs for each City game, you’ll know that I do a bit of a deep dive onto whoever is officiating the match.

More often than not, the number of cards is baffling.

Toner, who officiated City’s game on Tuesday night, has now shown a gobsmacking 50 yellows and four reds in just 10 matches this season.

He’s averaging almost six cards per game!

So with all the training and experience he has, having first refereed at National League North level back in 2011, what more can be done?

I’ve always been a firm believer that a referee should be put up for a post-match interview.

The Premier League players called for it in 2022, but it makes a lot of sense.

For someone to have such a dominant role in a match, and that’s realistically any match in the world at any level, there needs to be some form of accountability.

We see academy players come through and undergo media training, so it can’t be too hard to put match officials through the same programme.

In today’s media too, it’s quickly becoming the norm for interviews to be hashed out constantly.

Pre-match with a manager and a player, half-time interviews during televised Premier League matches, post-match with the manager and another player or two.

In fact, I think I write up more interviews than I do any other form of content, and that’s just from covering City where we don’t even get a player after the match some weeks!

Referees could come and speak to the media, explain their decisions, and potentially come out of a game with less controversy and more understanding.

Sure, it wouldn’t always go that way.

If City had been in Barnet’s position on Tuesday, any discussion of poor refereeing would have faded already.

But City now have to go to Grimsby without a key player in Hiram Boateng, and without their head coach Scott Lindsey.

What more can be done?

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos