Do you agree with the Press' York City player ratings?

Arthur Read produced another impressive performance as he scored his first goal for York City at Barnet. <i>(Image: Tom Poole)</i>
Arthur Read produced another impressive performance as he scored his first goal for York City at Barnet. (Image: Tom Poole)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

YORK City were embroiled in refereeing controversy after a 3-1 defeat at Barnet.

Picking up an array of yellow cards and two red cards, York found themselves in an uphill battle but were ultimately beaten by Barnet.

The Press’ Gabriel Ramsey was at the Hive on Tuesday evening and provides the match stats and his player ratings.

PLAYER RATINGS

Alfie McNally - 7

McNally was facing one of the league’s hottest strikers and did a solid job. He made some big stops at times, but was beaten three times by three good finishes.

Joe Felix –  7

Felix looked to make things happen on the right and created a couple of opportunities. He was unlucky to not get an assist for an early Ollie Pearce chance, but did set-up Read’s goal – even if he didn’t mean to!

Ryan Fallowfield - 6

Against a direct and strong Barnet side, it was a hard challenge for Fallowfield. He lost his man on the first goal and was ultimately punished, before being brought off in the second-half.

Zak Johnson – 7

It was a typical Johnson performance, sweeping up at the back and winning his aerial duels in a very physical and direct game. He was a calm head in an otherwise feisty fixture.

Mark Kitching – 6.5

Kitching had some good moments, but was also beaten on a few occasions down his side. He worked hard and delivered a few good crosses too.

Harry Boyes – 6.5

Similarly, Boyes looked to make things happen down the left but didn’t have the effect he wanted. He worked relentlessly though and rarely shows any sign of fatigue. Some smart link-up play too.

Alex Hunt – 6.5

Hunt has been in excellent form lately, but faded after an early change for City. He was asked to play further forward and it didn’t quite work, with the ball often skidding away from him or quicker pressure seeing him lose the ball. He still worked incredibly hard.

Hiram Boateng – 5

Ultimately, a red card means a bad rating. But Boateng had been solid up until his sending off, and was perfect for the physical sort of game that City found themselves in. The red card decision was a baffling one, but he sadly made it a much harder night for his teammates.

Joe Grey – 6.5

Grey was back in the squad and brought good energy, but didn’t get many opportunities to have an impact. He pressed well and had some nice first time passes.

Ollie Banks – N/A

Banks wasn’t on the pitch long enough to really get a rating. His night was ended early through a concussion.

Ollie Pearce – 6.5

In a physical contest, it’s hard for Pearce to do much as City’s lone strike. But he worked hard, pressed relentlessly and caused headaches for the Barnet backline. He was clearly frustrated by a shoddy refereeing performance.

Substitutions:

Arthur Read – 8

Another good performance from Read, who will surely start at Grimsby. He got stuck in, fought for every loose ball and put his body on the line. What a goal too, a delicate yet unstoppable finish that was just another example of his quality.

Josh Stones – 6.5

Stones fought hard and challenged for the aerial balls, but often found himself chasing down overhit passes down the channel. He didn’t get a chance to score.

Morgan Williams – 6.5

Williams came in for minutes after a spell out injured and looked comfortable. He battled for the ball and looked good with it at this feet. His deflection also led to the third goal, but there's not much else he could do about it.

Jeff King – 6.5

King didn’t do much of note after coming on but worked hard.

Frankie Maguire – 6.5

Maguire had a few moments of real quality, but only saw the ball a few times. He pressed really well from the front.

MAN OF THE MATCH

Arthur Read. Battled incredibly hard, gave his all and scores a sublime goal.

TEAM NEWS

Scott Lindsey named three changes after Saturday’s 2-0 win over Port Vale.

Hiram Boateng made his first start of the season and replaced Arthur Read in midfield.

Joe Grey and Joe Felix also came back into the side, with the former returning from a calf injury, to replace Frankie Maguire and Jack Hunt.

REFEREE: Ben Toner

BOOKINGS: Hunt (City), Maskell (Barnet), Kanu (Barnet), Pearce (City), Lindsey (City), King (City), Reeves (Barnet), Kitching (City), Williams (City)

RED CARDS: Boateng (City)

ATTENDANCE: 3,198 (1,009 from City)

SHOTS ON TARGET: Barnet 6, City 2

SHOTS OFF TARGET: Barnet 11, City 6

CORNERS: Barnet 4, City 4

OFFSIDES: Barnet 5, City 4

FOULS: Barnet 14, City 12

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos