Hole in the Wall - story behind the name of this York pub

5
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Hole in the Wall - the story behind the name of this York pub by IVAN MARTIN

THERE are many instances were a public house has changed its name.

A new owner, a new monarch, a national event or to erase a bad reputation, all justified a name change.

But sometimes the ‘new’ name has a story of its own - The Hole in the Wall in High Petergate is such a case.

If you venture into the Minster and reach the North Aisle of the Nave, mid-way along the aisle you will find a large wooden door securely locked.

Hole in the Wall Pub in High Petergate, York. Picture Frank Dwyer.

From the outside there is no opening in the Nave wall for the door, just a masonry outline showing where the opening used to be.

In 1154, Archbishop Roger directed that a chapel be built adjoining the North wall of the Nave.

This new two-storey chapel was to be known as the Collegiate Chapel of St. Sepulchre.

Its main access being from the Nave was only to be used for the conducting of Mass for the souls of the departed.

When built, a gatehouse and arched entrance was added to the western end to form the ‘Archbishop’s Gateway’, thus securing access to the Archbishop’s Palace, then in Dean’s Park.

The Reformation, declared in 1534, established the Protestant faith in England. This required new worship practices to be separate from the Roman Catholic faith.

Outside Nave of Minster showing blocked door. Photo by Ivan Martin

Not only required services altered, but statues, wall paintings and decoration in places of worship were all eliminated to conform with the new doctrine.

Consequently the role and need for the Collegiate Chapel came to an end, with the chapel being dissolved from use in 1548 and partially demolished.

The remains of the former chapel and gatehouse were subsequently leased to layman George Webster in 1550. Access from the Minster Nave closed.

The Archbishops moved to Bishopthorpe, so the chapel and gatehouse took on non-secular roles.

A painting by James Malton c.1794 shows the buildings in a dilapidated state but with no indication of how they were being used.

At the beginning of the 19th century, the Minster authorities decided to remove all the buildings that joined or were close to the Minster. This resulted in the unimpeded views we enjoy today.

High Petergate in about 1905. A man holds a horse by its harness. Mastermans' Butchers, on the right of the image, has the royal coat of arms, proclaiming the somewhat dubious assertion that it was patronised by Queen Victoria. Picture: Explore York

When the former chapel and gatehouse’s turn came to be demolished in 1816 it had become known as the ‘Hole in the Wall’ public house.

How long the buildings had been a public house is not known, but the name is thought to be a flippant reference to the new entrance required with the closure of the original Nave door.


Recommended reading:


But the did the buildings hide a sinister secret?

In 1847, an excavation of the site by John Browne, revealed the foundations of the former chapel and gatehouse had a large basement cellar complex. Within the complex the remains of metal fittings consistent with those used in medieval prison cells were found. Did the chapel and gatehouse, to be later a public house, have prison cells in their cellars, and were they used? We will never know.

Hole in The Wall in York in 1999. Photo - York Press

But what of the current ‘Hole in the Wall’?

According to the late Hugh Murray’s book on the public houses of York, the High Petergate building was once Wolstenholme’s Dram Shop then Haigh’s Vaults then Petergate Wine and Spirit and Bar then The Board before becoming the Hole in the Wall.

After a change in ownership and a new facade; it was re-opened to the public with its ‘new’ name on December 9, 1981. Today the hostelry continues its tradition to give a warm welcome, deliver fine food and gracious hospitality, as it has done for many years.

But its new adopted name, revived after 165 years, has its own, far older story, originating just a short distance away.

Ivan Martin is the vice-president of the Yorkshire Architectural and York Archaeological Society (YAYAS) and former city, Minster and Mansion House guide

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos