Ash dieback and collapse at Gordale Scar leave council with big bill

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A YORKSHIRE Dales council is facing having to set a parish precept for the first time in years after a large rockfall at Gordale Scar forced the closure of the footpath and left it with 'exceptional costs'.

The rockfall, in late September and following heavy rain, happened at night, when no one was visiting the hugely popular scar, says Kirkby Malham Parish Council, which owns the land.

Parish councillor, David Howlett, said: "Very fortunately this happened at night when no one was visiting Gordale, and nobody was injured. If it had happened a few hours later there could have been multiple casualties and potentially fatalities."

An inspection of the rockface using a drone has led the council to believe tree roots from ash trees and a yew tree growing in crevices in the limestone may have been a factor.

The public path was closed for an initial 21 days by the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority, extended for a further 21 days and now for six months more to give the council time to consider what action to take.

The footpath through the ravine has been closed for six months (Image: Lesley Tate)

While rockfalls at Gordale are a natural phenomenon and are nothing new, with 'beware of rock falls' signs already installed in the area, the recent one is much more serious, says the council.

Cllr Howlett said: "A tree survey for the council identified that sadly many of the ash trees on council land were either dying or dead due to the ash dieback fungus. Due to their location near footpaths and in the plantation at Malham these posed a risk to members of the public and either must be felled or made into monoliths. This work will take place over the next few months."

The council is now faced with having to set a parish precept in the first time for many years to cover the cost of removing and replanting the trees.

A team from the British Mountaineering Council (BMC) has carried out an inspection of the rockface free of charge for the council and removed a large number of loose rocks. The parish council has also contracted a forestry firm to remove the trees.

As Gordale is a Site of of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI), the parish council has undertaken a Habitat Regulation Assessment in close consultation with Natural England. HRAs are used to determine whether planned work will have a significant impact on protected features.

The parish council receives income from visitors parking on the road, from toilets and from occasional filming at Gordale and at Malham Cove, which it also owns, but expects it will have to set a parish precept, as part of next year's council tax.

Gordale Scar (Image: KMPC)

Cllr Howlett said: "This income and the careful management of the council finances have meant there has not been a parish precept for many years.

"However, the exceptional costs for tree felling and rockfall means we are having to consider a precept to our council rates. We will discuss the need to charge a precept at next two meetings of the council. All residents are welcome to attend council meetings."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos