2 North Yorkshire restaurants crowned among the UK's best

Find out what the AA experts said about these restaurants in York and Goathland <i>(Image: Tripadvisor)</i>
Find out what the AA experts said about these restaurants in York and Goathland (Image: Tripadvisor)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Two North Yorkshire restaurants have been crowned among the best in the UK, following their recent success at the 2025 AA Hospitality Awards.

Melton's in Scarcroft Road in York and The Homestead Kitchen situated in the village of Goathland near Whitby, are among the eateries awarded new 3 AA Rosettes.

It comes as the brightest in British hospitality came together earlier this week at JW Marriott Grosvenor House for the prestigious event, recognised as the “gold standard of excellence” within the hospitality industry.

Organised by AA Hotel & Hospitality Services (and hosted by Vernon Kay), the awards shone a spotlight on the country’s most “exceptional” hotels, restaurants, spas, inns, and B&Bs, as well as the inspiring people behind them.

Awards were presented across 18 categories, including AA Chefs’ Chef of the Year, AA Sustainable Award, AA Spa Hotel of the Year and, brand new for 2025, the AA Rising Star Award.

Take a look at all the winners at the 2025 AA Hospitality Awards online.

What did the AA experts say about Melton’s and The Homestead Kitchen?

Melton’s, said to be an “intimate and friendly” place to dine, was opened by chef Michael Hjort and wife Lucy in 1990.

For the best part of four decades, it has remained one of the cathedral city’s “notable” restaurants, with a “cosy bistro-style look and feel”.

The AA experts explained: “Smiley and informal staff have a low-key style, but they are knowledgeable and passionate about the dishes. 

“Generous and refined, the modern British menu changes seasonally, although a few time-honoured staples stay on the menu to keep the regulars satisfied.”

Just some of the menu highlights include a starter of Orkney scallop served with sand carrot, Vadouvan, sea buckthorn and cashew, or garden pea and Iberico ham tartlet, Burford Brown egg yolk and vin jaune.

The AA inspector's review added: “Regional ingredients get regular star billing on the menu, with a trio of Yorkshire lamb – breast, loin and tongue – making an appearance in a well-considered and perfectly balanced main course with turnip, little gem lettuce, alliums and Madeira. Or, perhaps, a piece of super fresh ‘east coast’ cod with courgette, mussels and smoked pike roe will float your boat.”

Those with a sweet tooth might want to try the “immaculate and well risen” raspberry soufflé paired with woodruff ice cream, or in the warmer months, the “summery” Yorkshire strawberries with lemon verbena, elderflower and doughnuts.

Melton’s, which currently has a 4.8/5 rating on Tripadvisor based on more than 1,200 reviews, also offers an “interesting” wine list, that is “carefully” curated by the restaurant’s owners, such as “eclectic” choices from Lebanon, Japan and of course, Yorkshire.

Looking for a new restaurant to try near Whitby?(Image: Tripadvisor)

Meanwhile, family-run restaurant The Homestead Kitchen, set within the North Yorkshire Moors, is described as having “rustic-chic farmhouse decor and a relaxed and unpretentious ambience."

It also boasts "confident cooking that showcases a real taste of the region, including seasonal produce from the family’s kitchen garden”.

The AA experts continued: “Start with tartare of wild North York moors roe deer, truffled carrot juice and Henderson's relish mayonnaise and move on to North Sea cod poached in brown butter with Whitby lobster sauce, confit fennel and garlic mayonnaise.

“Leave room for the hot chocolate tart, black cherry sauce and garden meadowsweet ice cream.”

Someone who recently returned to the Goathland restaurant wrote in a review on Tripadvisor: “Our second visit, this time for Sunday lunch - 2 years after our first visit. Homestead is going from strength to strength, wonderful ingredients (many home grown), extremely well cook and excellent service.


Recommended reading:


“Being in Goathland the setting is beautiful, but the highlight is the food, that is wonderful, not pretentious but wonderfully presented and delicious. Definitely worth booking and making a detour for.”

Another praised: “This was our first visit to The Homestead Kitchen, after a recommendation and it was wonderful. The service was exemplary and the food delightful, we will definitely be visiting again. Thank you to all involved.”

Is Melton’s or The Homestead Kitchen one of your favourite restaurants to go to in North Yorkshire? Let us know in the comments below.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos