Match reports RSS Feed


Match report: Barrow 0, York City 0

Andre Boucaud fires just wide of the Barrow goal. Picture: Gordon Clayton Andre Boucaud fires just wide of the Barrow goal. Picture: Gordon Clayton

JASON WALKER was once so popular at Holker Street that, before Saturday’s game, when the Barrow mascots were asked which player they wanted to walk out with, one of them apparently asked for the former Bluebird.

But this was no happy homecoming.

Six minutes into injury time, the 27-year-old departed down the tunnel to a chorus of boos – shown a straight red card by referee Karl Evans for a tackle in midfield on James Owen.

At first glance, it looked a bad challenge and it soon got worse for City. Evans hoisted red again almost immediately after, somehow singling Andre Boucaud out for punishment following a melee which had greeted Walker’s misdemeanour.

With both now set to be absent, possible appeals notwithstanding, the duo will leave a significant hole in Mills’ plans should bans follow.

It was an unseemly end to a match which had not seen a card of any colour until the start of stoppage time.

Wrexham and Fleetwood are among the Blue Square Bet big-hitters who have been downed in Cumbria and Barrow went into the game having scored in all of their previous matches this season.

Apart from a couple of half chances for former York youngster Adam Boyes, however, and a magnificent first-half save from Michael Ingham, the home side were largely blunted by a City defence which has rediscovered the art of the clean sheet.

Indeed, after quelling an early Barrow surge at the start of each half, it was the Minstermen – adapting to a tricky surface – who played the better football.

Having come so close to scalping Rotherham in the FA Cup last week, Barrow stormed out of the blocks.

In the fourth minute, Boyes nicked the ball off Jamal Fyfield’s foot in the right channel and surged into the box. Rather than shoot from a wide position, he elected to cut back inside and that gave the City centre-half the chance to recover and redeem himself with a timely tackle.

Boyes went even closer four minutes later, his header from Gavin Skelton’s left-wing cross pointed back across Ingham and kissing the edge of a post.

The match was into double figures before City enjoyed any real possession but Matty Blair was lively and Scott Kerr became an increasingly important presence in the middle of the park – disrupting play and calmly distributing.

Even so, Ingham needed to be at his brilliant best to prevent Richie Baker giving the home side the lead on 18 minutes.

Twenty yards out, the midfielder curled a free-kick over the wall and, as it dipped towards the ’keeper’s top right corner, Ingham somehow got across to tip it over the bar.

City got more on the ball and, with Kerr pulling the strings, James Meredith twice got behind the Barrow back four but, despite looking ever more comfortable, it wasn’t until the start of the second half that York fashioned their first real chance.

It came almost straight from the kick-off, Chambers’ cross from the right falling to Walker 12 yards out, but Danny Hurst was equal to the header.

Back came Barrow, Andy Cook’s bullet shot from 25 yards leaving Ingham scrambling.

But City again imposed themselves and were aggrieved not to be in front on 64 minutes.

Blair’s high cross from the right was met by Walker and he planted a firm header goalwards.

Hurst got both hands up to parry away but the ball fell to Chambers who fired it back in. It struck defender Paul Smith on the line and deflected away with a box full of York players appealing he had cleared with his hands.

Referee Evans, stoking the controversy which would erupt later, waved away the protests.

Hurst then had to be at full flight to tip Walker’s 25-yard free kick over the bar and, from the resulting corner, the City marksman connected with Danny Pilkington’s cross on the edge of the box only to see it dribble to the grateful Barrow custodian.

York continued to search for the breakthrough and Chambers chipped a shot over the bar after Jon Challinor took a defender out of the game with a sideways run across the box.

Baker flashed one wide of the left hand post as regulation time wound down in a rare Barrow assault but, with six minutes of stoppage-time scheduled, there was still hope Mills’ men could find a way through.

Walker’s sending-off ended any chance of that and, when Boucaud was also dismissed, nine men City were happy the whistle went almost straight after.

Match facts

York City: Michael Ingham 7, Jon Challinor 7, Chris Smith 7, Jamal Fyfield 6, James Meredith 7, Andre Boucaud 7, Scott Kerr 8, Paddy McLaughlin 6, Matty Blair 7, Jason Walker 6, Ashley Chambers 7.

Subs: Danny Pilkington (for McLaughlin 59), 6; David McGurk (Smith 65), 6; Daniel Parslow (Chambers 90). Not used: Jamie Reed, Adriano Moké.

Key: 10 – Faultless; 9 – Outstanding; 8 – Excellent; 7 – Good; 6 – Average; 5 – Below par; 4 – Poor; 3 – Dud; 2 – Hopeless; 1 – Retire.

City’s star man: Scott Kerr – calm, assured and City’s best in possession. Cleverly found time and space.

Barrow: Danny Hurst, Phil Bolland, Danny Hone, Gavin Skelton, Paul Rutherford, Richie Baker, James Owen, Paul Smith, Jack Mackreth (Dominic Rowe 86), Andy Cook (Louis Almond 78), Adam Boyes. Subs not used: Shaun Pearson, Kelvin Lomax, Andy Ferrell.

Booked: Owen 90+1. Sent off: Walker 90+5, Boucaud 90+6.

Shots on target: Barrow 4, York 5.

Shots off target: Barrow 2, York 1.

Corners: Barrow 2, York 2.

Offsides: Barrow 0, York 4.

Fouls conceded: Barrow 11, York 15.

Referee: Karl Evans (Lancashire). Rating: Had handled things well until controversial handball decision. Stoppage time got out of hand.

Attendance: 2,190 (365 City fans).

Moment of the match: Ingham’s first half tip over the bar, at full-stretch, from Baker’s free-kick was first rate.

Head to head - Jason Walker v Adam Boyes

Billed as the match-up between the two prolific strikers – both turning out against their former clubs – neither got on the scoresheet.

Boyes started faster and might have done better with early chances but Walker grew into the game and was the greater threat in the second half.

The former Barrow player came deep to get the ball in the opening half, as he was well marshalled by Danny Hone, but clever movement after the break brought chances. The sending-off was not the way he would want to remember his return.

Comments(8)

Sir Alex says...
10:40am Mon 21 Nov 11

Seen the footage on YCTV.

Couldn't believe the Walker sending off it was barely a foul and he was disorientated anyway from the poor challenge he had just received.

As for Boucs, presumably it was for putting his arms out to defend himself while walking backwards to avoid the oncoming four thugs from Barrow who looked like they were going to thump him. Self defence and provoked.

Deffo handball on the line but ref unsighted unfortunately.

The Legend Of Keith says...
11:06am Mon 21 Nov 11

I have to agree with Sir Alex. Having seen the highlights on YCTV it looks like Walker made no contact with the man and Bouc's was defending himself in the face of a mob of angry Barrow players. I hope that Mills appeals both cards as we should have a good chance of over turning them.

Add the hand ball incident into the mix and you'll find a hat trick of pretty bad refereeing decisions.

There is a fine line between automatic promotion and the lottery of the play-offs and more often than not, a referee will be the drawer of that line.

JamesHinch says...
11:20am Mon 21 Nov 11

Agree 100%.

Surely walking backwards should be enough to avoid the oncoming Barrow players but they kept going forward towards him - its a natural reaction to put your arms out to protect yourself - I would. The aggression was from Barrow 'players' not Boucs.

The Walker incident was just nothing.

clarkers says...
11:41am Mon 21 Nov 11

To be honest it was one of many bad decisions the ref made in that game. Im just glad the two red cards were in the last minute as it didn't cost us a point but why either were sent off is beyond me.

RooBeck says...
11:43am Mon 21 Nov 11

Agree with the above ; GM needs to lodge appeals with the FA for both of these incidents, even though the powers that be will always try to back match officials and are not too interested in any justice towards the club/players concerned. BUT, looking at these, then, surely there must be a very good chance of over-turning what were reactionary decisions by some sub-standard refereeing. What was the outcome of GM's post-match discussion with the ref and match assessor? Did they give any indication that these were poor decisions and hint at them been open to a challenge?! From what was said on the match commentary and the posts on here, this official needs to go back to Sunday League matches and start again and to have been scored 1 out of 10 for Saturday's performance!!

OLD - HEAD says...
11:52am Mon 21 Nov 11

Lets be honest a point at Barrow is a decent result. Its no use anybody saying "if only we had been awarded a penalty", for these things happen in football. If we do miss out at the end of the season, then it wont be down to the draw at Barrow. The reason we are not up there now alongside Wrexham and Fleetwood is down to defeats by AFC Telford, Alfreton and Tamworth. Consistency will achieve York City a play-off position, but it will take something really special to actually win the league. That is where Fleetwoods financial clout gives them a considerable advantage over us. They have assembled the strongest squad in the league, and will not be weakened who ever is missing. Even when the prolific Jamie Vardy was suspended they still had Mangham, Vierra and of course Brodie to step in. Moneybags Crawley ruined the Conference as a level playing field last season, and Fleetwood are threatening to do the same this season. Citys best route could be via the play-offs, dont forget AFC Wimbledon did it last year without spending a fortune.

yorko66 says...
1:03pm Mon 21 Nov 11

Just watched the sendings off. I thought the Barrow players challenge was worse than walker who actually missed and did not seem to make any contact. Boucs unfortunately had his hands in three different players faces. I know he was going backwards and protecting himself but i dont think the FA will see it that way. An appeal will this time not come out in our favour. The Ref was on the wrong side of the Walker incident and the player made the most out of it (hes starring on corrie next week hes such a good performer). The hand ball was a deffo pen it was a bad afternoon at the office and time to move on. Reedy will score a hat trick at FG. If of course he is picked.

alimount says...
1:23pm Mon 21 Nov 11

Having seen the same footage on YCTV I think both reds were justified. Obviously, the footage doesn't show what wasn't given by the ref but you can't grab players by the neck and expect to get away with it. Walker had been fouled but it was silly to lunge in with a minute to go.
Clearly the ref was poor as he missed the clear superman on the line from a Barrow player.
Anyways, not a bad point and Walker having 3 games off to get fully fit. 3 games we should be winning without the need of both players in truth.

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree