News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


KitKat row over Nestlé's use of Fairtrade chocolate stamp

Nestlé has hit back over claims  consumers were being misled by Fairtrade KitKats Nestlé has hit back over claims consumers were being misled by Fairtrade KitKats

YORK confectionery giant Nestlé has hit back at criticism of its Fairtrade KitKats.

The company was hailed last December by the Archbishop of York, Dr John Sentamu, and the Fairtrade Foundation when it announced that its four finger KitKats were to become Fairtrade.

David Rennie, managing director of Nestlé Confectionery, said more than 6,000 farmers on the Ivory Coast would benefit from the move.

But a national newspaper claimed yesterday that while KitKats might have the Fairtrade stamp, experts had claimed that chocolate from different sources was mixed up in the supply chain before the bars were produced.

It claimed this meant there was no sure way of telling that the bar bought by a person contained Fairtrade cocoa, bought for a fair price from poor farmers, and consumers were being misled.

But a Nestlé spokesman insisted the company worked to Fairtrade’s standards. “When you buy a Fair-trade KitKat you can be sure it directly benefits Fairtrade cocoa farmers,” he said.

“We have a huge £65 million investment programme to help farmers increase their income, improve education and healthcare and plant 12 million new cocoa trees over the next ten years.

“It’s fantastic that KitKat Four Finger is Fairtrade – an important part of our overall programme. With Fairtrade, we’ve developed a direct relationship with the Kavokiva co-op in the Cote d’Ivoire, one of the poorest countries in the world.”

The row comes days after a report from a free-market thinktank claimed that multinational companies such as Nestlé did more for developing-world coffee farmers than the Fairtrade Foundation.

Describing Fairtrade as costly, opaque and substantially unproven, the 130-page report commissioned by the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) said Fairtrade requirements on farmers might well reflect the subjective views of western consumers and not the real needs of poor producers.

But the Fairtrade Foundation said the report was a “flawed, partial analysis,” adding it was wrong to suggest Fairtrade did not offer a long-term strategy for development.

Comments(12)

AdmiralNN says...
9:10am Thu 11 Nov 10

Its all a load of BS, yes the cocoa may be fair trade but what about all the palm oil that Nestle use in their products. Anything but fair. Its pure deception.

metsa says...
9:21am Thu 11 Nov 10

I'm no fan of Nestle and I agree that their use of the Fairtrade notion whilst simultaneously using palm oil and other non-Fairtrade stuff is hardly consistent. However, it's also worth pointing out (as the The Press probably ought to have) is that the Institute of Economic Affairs is a leading hard right free market think tank- which might contextualise their views somewhat

yorkma says...
10:30am Thu 11 Nov 10

Nestle does not process it's own cocoa. They get their supplies at York from Cargill cocoa who are situated on the Wiggington Road side of the site. So they need asking about it. Huge American privately owned company, who have been accused of destroying the rainforest in their quest for worldwide food domination. Heavily into oils, meat etc etc

Civil War II says...
10:36am Thu 11 Nov 10

Don't buy corporate products if you want to save the planet and indigenous people, but you'll also be in a minority who don't make any difference in real terms. Man exploits resources till they run out, man exploits man hence slavery and dictatorships, just live with it.

West says...
11:44am Thu 11 Nov 10

I see Nestle have been in bed with the York Press again this week! Can we not go one week without a free advert for the Robert Mugabe, baby killing ,Nestle???

http://www.corporate
watch.org.uk/?lid=24
0

What Neslte are really about :

UNETHICAL MARKETING OF ARTIFICIAL BABYMILK :
Since 1977 (with a break from 1984-1988), Nestlé has been the subject of an international boycott for its dubious marketing strategies. The World Health Organisation (WHO) estimates that 1.5 million infants die each year because of inappropriate feeding...

EXPLOITING FARMERS
In 2001, Nestlé faced criticism for buying cocoa from the Ivory Coast and Ghana, which may have been produced using child slaves. According to an investigative report by the BBC, hundreds of thousands of children in Mali, Burkina Faso and Togo were being purchased from their destitute parents and shipped to the Ivory Coast, to be sold as slaves to cocoa farms.

UNION BUSTING
There have been several examples of Nestlé being involved in denying workers their right to collectively bargain. In Colombia, where trade unionists have been consistently targeted by right-wing paramilitiaries, eight Nestlé employees affiliated with the Food and Drink Workers Union SINALTRAINAL have been assassinated.

PROMOTION OF GM FOODS
More recently, Nestlé has been under attack for its enthusiasm for GM foods.

THE ETHIOPIA SCANDAL
Just before Christmas 2002, Oxfam revealed that Nestlé was demanding millions of dollars in compensation from Ethiopia – precisely when the country was in the midst of an extreme drought that put over 11 million people at risk for starvation.

ILLEGAL EXTRACTION OF GROUNDWATER
Nestlé production of mineral water involves the abuse of vulnerable water resources. In the Serra da Mantiqueira region of Brazil, home to the “circuit of waters” park whose groundwater has a high mineral content and medicinal properties, over-pumping has resulted in depletion and long-term damage.

PYRES OF BURNING ANIMALS
Nestlé has recently been exposed regarding its part in persuading the British government not to vaccinate livestock during the Foot and Mouth disease crisis. The then Chief Executive of Nestlé UK, Peter Blackburn, who is also president of the Food and Drink Federation, lobbied the government, which was apparently about to introduce a vaccination programme, and, along with the National Farmers' Union, who also opposed vaccination, managed to force a complete turnaround in policy .

FRAUDULENT LABELING
In November 2002, police ordered Nestlé Colombia to decommission 200 tons of imported powdered milk. The milk had come from Uruguay under the brand name Conaprole, but the sacks had been repackaged with labels stating they had come from a local Nestlé factory, and stamped with false production dates of 20th September and 6th October 2002. The real production dates were between August 2001 and February 2002.A month later another 120 tons with similarly false country of origin and production dates were discovered, pointing to systematic fraud.

THE LIST GOES ON & ON & ON & ON..........

West says...
11:46am Thu 11 Nov 10

btw it shoudl read Mugabe fans, not just Mugabe. As Nestle buy much of their produce from a Mugabe owned farm.

Overproof says...
12:17pm Thu 11 Nov 10

Boycott Nestle,

Here is the Kit-Kat video that Nestle tried to ban

http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?v=cLtfzPz1c
0E

TooRelaxed says...
12:59pm Thu 11 Nov 10

This article was generated by a press release from Nestle.
Quite why they feel the need to use this local paper to defend themselves against claims made in a national is unclear. Why not answer their detractors directly?

Kingnuts says...
3:36pm Thu 11 Nov 10

Fairtrade is a load of rubbish anyway. Companies only go along with it so they can appear to look good. Companies like Nestle are in it for one thing, money. Its a dog eat dog world.

GoodDoc says...
3:58pm Thu 11 Nov 10

Love it! People are paroodying themselves again in their comments on here.

Garrowby Turnoff says...
7:05pm Thu 11 Nov 10

West wrote:
btw it shoudl read Mugabe fans, not just Mugabe. As Nestle buy much of their produce from a Mugabe owned farm.
E-ba-gum!
.
Judge for yourselves @ www.greenpalm.org

EndofTether says...
11:43pm Thu 11 Nov 10

http://www.express.c

o.uk/posts/view/2109

41/Muslim-protesters

-burn-poppies-as-Bri

tain-remembers-war-h

eroes

This is clearly not relevant to the topic but I did not want to degrade any story linked remembrance day. But.. why is this story being buried, surely it is a crime that our flag can be burnt, not only on such a poignant day, but any day? Why is this blatant disrespect of our country allowed to continue?

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree