FROM the air it appeared as though a whole new town had sprung up on York's Knavesmire, as thousands of motorcaravanners flocked to the city.

But a row was simmering under the surface of this spectacuular scene, as some residents voiced concerns about the vast numbers of vehicles attending the three-day Northern Motorcaravan Show.

An estimated 4,000 caravans were on-site, with an additional 12,000 day visitors, who all packed up and filed out yesterday.

Tractors were out in force to ensure the heavy rain at the start of the three-day Northern Motorcaravan Show did not leave vehicles stuck in the mud.

Organisers who hailed the showpiece a resounding success have already earmarked a return date for September 2006.

Post-show talks will assess the highs and lows to guide future plans, while city transport chiefs intend to discuss parking and traffic issues with police.

Some residents despaired when day visitors parked on the grassy verge in front of their homes in Knavesmire Crescent, triggering concerns about the large numbers involved.

But Amanda Nightingale, show marketing manager, said the event was no bigger than recent years and brought many benefits to the city.

"Despite the weather and mud, everyone had a fantastic time. It brings a lot of people to York. We run bus services into town so people will have been spending their money locally. People criticise events and complain about traffic, but the show does bring money to the area."

Entertainment included comedian Brian Conley and live music, while business was brisk at more than 200 trade stands.

Motorists were dogged by tailbacks, despite efforts to ease traffic flow.

But a council spokeswoman said: "The new traffic system for managing arrivals worked very well. Holding areas had to be created by the organisers while they processed drivers.

"There was some minor difficulty with A64 traffic, but nothing like in previous years."

Updated: 10:49 Tuesday, September 20, 2005