AS readers will know, the old weeping ash tree in King's Square has now been removed. To the untrained eye the tree looked in good condition. However, when the tree climber attached his rope to the tree, it swayed precariously due to internal decay and we found there was only an inch or so of sound wood holding the tree upright.

This was the main reason I condemned it as a threat to the public.

I would like to think its replacement will survive into the next Millennium. There are a number of practical considerations governing the kind of tree we can choose.

There is not enough space to plant a large new tree and the site is not suitable for a large canopied spreading tree such as an oak. The need for low maintenance and management costs also rules out trees needing regular pruning and training, so I am looking for a small to medium-sized, attractive, reasonably upright variety which does not need regular attention.

Harvey Lowson,

Arboricultural Officer,

City of York Council.

...THE interest shown by readers in the fate of the King's Square weeping ash is commendable.

York has a tremendous treescape which not only beautifies the city but provides a healthy environment for all of us.

But trees have to be managed not only for their own sake but also for the human beings that inhabit the same environment.

The structural decay of the ash left the council with only one solution, however regrettable, and that was, to take it down in the interests of public safety.

The York Tree Warden Group, a voluntary body started last year, is working with the council to preserve and enhance York's trees and will be making suggestions on a replacement tree for King's Square.

We would welcome suggestions from readers for a suitable replacement - and for those really concerned about York and its trees, come and join us!

N B Fowles,

Clifton Community Tree Warden,

Avenue Terrace, Clifton, York.