A North Yorkshire community shocked by the murder of its postmistress prayed for her family and friends and those seeking her killer.

As villagers in Melsonby near Richmond headed for Sunday service in their parish church, they passed police tape cordoning off the village shop and post office where former York and Eggborough resident Diana Garbutt was murdered early on Tuesday morning.

Inside St James Church, the Rev Stan Howarth comforted parishioners.

“Across the world there will be people today remembering in their prayers this community,” he said. “And among the shock, grief and bewilderment at this event let us remember them and be thankful for their prayers.

“Lots of expressions of emotion have been felt these past few days. “Particularly, at the core, for Diana and her family. There have been thoughts of anger and distress – we cannot understand why this should come here into this community.

“The events that took place, as they unfold, people will continue to talk about for a long time to come. It is fixed in the memory. Already some of the intensity is dropping, but still the memory, the hurt, the anguish will remain here for a long, long time to come.

“We pray for all those who have come into this community in the past days. We pray for the work of the police force and those who support them. We pray for this community and for the family and friends of Diana.”

A service of remembrance was held for Mrs Garbutt, pictured, on Wednesday evening. A condolence book was opened and more than 100 people came to reflect, pray and light candles. More than 80 entries have been left in the book so far. One reads: “So tragic. My deepest sympathy.” Another says: “I’m so very sad for you Robin. She was a good woman and liked by everyone. Take care. Our thoughts are with you,” and another: “One of this world’s very special people. We will miss you so much xx.”

Some struggled to put into words how they felt with one writing: “Words cannot express,” and another simply putting “?”.