MARKETING bosses have admitted they were "naive" when they first suggested demolishing the broken fountain in York's Parliament Street, but say it is hindering their plans for the area.

The future of the fountain, which has not worked since 2012, was discussed at a City of York Council meeting on Wednesday.

Steve Brown, the managing director of Make It York, told the meeting the organisation was "probably a bit young and naive when we first approached" the idea of demolishing the fountain. The proposals last year were opposed by many and hundreds signed a petition saying it should be kept.

But Mr Brown said: "It is our view that a redundant fountain is not helping what we are trying to do in Parliament Street.

"If the opportunity arose where the fountain could be moved that would give us a better space and flexibility to arrange what we're trying to organise. A second alternative is to have a really fantastic fountain or piece of art in that space."

The decision was referred to the council and on Wednesday the learning and culture committee discussed it.

Green councillor Dave Taylor said the fountain was "not an attractive edifice at all", but said: "In the ideal world most of us would like to see some sort of fountain in York city centre".

Coun Taylor suggested advertising hoarding could be built around the base of the fountain as a better way to promote events in the city centre, as was seen during last year's comedy festival.

In a statement issued before the meeting, Mr Brown said: "The decision around the future for York Fountain rests with City of York Council and what’s important going forward is that progress is made on this.

"Whether the fountain is removed, repaired or replaced we’re keen to ensure that it doesn’t remain in its current state of disrepair.

"We’ve made our view clear that our preferred option would be to see this space freed up to better facilitate events and festivals. However, we will fully support the decision that is made."

Councillor Janet Looker said the fountain no longer performed a purpose and "isn't really ornamental". She said it was time for the council to "bite the bullet" and said: "We should really do something about it."