Concern over shortage of respite care in York

Sally Hutchinson

Sally Hutchinson

First published in News
Last updated

PRESSURE on some unpaid carers looking after elderly people or those with disabilities is "tangible" in York, a city charity has said.

Sally Hutchinson, chief executive of Age UK York, said the charity is struggling to meet the demand for its services with its 50+ advice and information service experiencing its "busiest quarter ever", with many people looking for help with respite or care for people with dementia.

Mrs Hutchinson expressed concern about the lack of availability of quality respite beds in reaction to the Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt's assertion that there are too many care homes people would not be happy to send their relatives to. He said there should be an "Ofsted-style" regime whereby care homes need to shape up or close.

Mrs Hutchinson said: "I agree whole heartedly there should be tough regulation of quality in establishments where we expect people we care about should be looked after properly.

"However, I'm very concerned about the diminishing number of residential nursing and respite beds across the country, I would hope that the threat of rigorous inspections does not accelerate this."

Mr Hunt's comments came as the country's chief inspector of social care said that every week examples of "truly awful care" are brought to light.

Andrea Sutcliffe condemned the abuse and neglect that was still occurring and pledged to crack down on unacceptable care provided in some organisations.

Giving his reaction, Bob Towner, chair of York Older Peoples Assembly, said: "There have been care homes in York to have fallen below the standards anyone would expect. I agree inspections should be more rigorous.

"We need a greater direction of resources to support people living at home if they want to. We have a situation where care homes are full up because it's easier to plonk people there."

He said the nature of care homes needed to change with emphasis on specialist environments for people with dementia.

Inspectors have raised concerns with a number of York homes in recent months. The Press has reported this week how five members of staff at Minster Grange in Haxby Road have been fired after a whistleblower had raised concerns about the care of residents.

A CQC report into Moorlands home at Strensall - part of Mimosa Health Care Group, which went into administration in March - found it did not have enough qualified, skilled and experienced staff on duty to meet people's needs.

In November, we reported how Meadowbeck care home in Osbaldwick and St Catherine’s Care Home in Shipton-by-Beningborough were made subject to enforcement action and Birchlands Care Home in Haxby, and The Lodge residential care home in Heslington were flagged up as needing to improve by Care Quality Commission (CQC) inspectors.

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:17am Fri 18 Jul 14

asd says...

Unfortunately because a lot of care homes are privately run and owned by big companies well, lets put it this way; why would any minister want to tighten regulations when either their family members or mates are on the board of these companies making nice profits. Adding regulation would mean less profit and that's all these company and ministers are bothered about. Respite is a joke for people who have family members who have disabilities I know because my son is disabled and gets 1 day respite a fortnight and I am a lucky one.
Unfortunately because a lot of care homes are privately run and owned by big companies well, lets put it this way; why would any minister want to tighten regulations when either their family members or mates are on the board of these companies making nice profits. Adding regulation would mean less profit and that's all these company and ministers are bothered about. Respite is a joke for people who have family members who have disabilities I know because my son is disabled and gets 1 day respite a fortnight and I am a lucky one. asd
  • Score: 3

9:26am Fri 18 Jul 14

CaroleBaines says...

asd wrote:
Unfortunately because a lot of care homes are privately run and owned by big companies well, lets put it this way; why would any minister want to tighten regulations when either their family members or mates are on the board of these companies making nice profits. Adding regulation would mean less profit and that's all these company and ministers are bothered about. Respite is a joke for people who have family members who have disabilities I know because my son is disabled and gets 1 day respite a fortnight and I am a lucky one.
Respite for children is actually very good in York compared to most places of similar size. Its care once the disabled person reaches adulthood that is the issue here. Relations of mine have a severely disabled son and the Glen in York is an absolute life saver. When they were looking to move elsewhere for work, they were shocked at the lack of provision.
Sympathies with asd (above) it must be really tough and one day a fortnight isn't much, but that is a nationwide scandal and York is actually better than most places, even though that still isn't enough imho.
[quote][p][bold]asd[/bold] wrote: Unfortunately because a lot of care homes are privately run and owned by big companies well, lets put it this way; why would any minister want to tighten regulations when either their family members or mates are on the board of these companies making nice profits. Adding regulation would mean less profit and that's all these company and ministers are bothered about. Respite is a joke for people who have family members who have disabilities I know because my son is disabled and gets 1 day respite a fortnight and I am a lucky one.[/p][/quote]Respite for children is actually very good in York compared to most places of similar size. Its care once the disabled person reaches adulthood that is the issue here. Relations of mine have a severely disabled son and the Glen in York is an absolute life saver. When they were looking to move elsewhere for work, they were shocked at the lack of provision. Sympathies with asd (above) it must be really tough and one day a fortnight isn't much, but that is a nationwide scandal and York is actually better than most places, even though that still isn't enough imho. CaroleBaines
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree