Former carriageworks employee believes asbestos killed more than official figures show

York Press: Former  carriageworks employee Paul Cooper in front of the Holgate  memorial to the  former workers killed by asbestos in York Former carriageworks employee Paul Cooper in front of the Holgate memorial to the former workers killed by asbestos in York

IT is already thought to have claimed more than 140 lives – but now a campaigner has claimed the true death toll from York’s asbestos timebomb may be even higher.

Paul Cooper, a former York Carriageworks employee and trade unionist who now plays a leading role in the York Asbestos Support Group, has written to York Central MP Hugh Bayley to raise his concerns.

He said that as well as causing mesothelioma, he believed asbestos probably led to cancers in many other parts of the body, including the stomach and the testicles.

He said World Health Organisation research had raised such concerns. Mr Cooper said: “I have, on some occasions, tried to argue for further investigations into the deaths of my colleagues where I felt asbestos might be the cause, both with the consultants and the coroner, Donald Coverdale, sadly to no avail in most cases.”

Mr Bayley has written to Geoffrey Podger, chief executive of the Health and Safety Executive, saying 141 former railway carriage builders in his constituency had died as a result of mesothelioma, contracted through working with asbestos at the factory in Holgate Road.

He said Mr Cooper was concerned many more may have been killed through lung, laryngeal and ovarian cancers, as well as possibly cancer of the pharynx, stomach and gastrointestinal cancers.

Mr Podger replied, saying HSE statistics included estimates of the number of other types of cancer caused by asbestos in addition to mesothelioma, which included lung, stomach and laryngeal cancer.

“HSE has been open and clear about the fact that these cancers are the legacy of past industrial use of asbestos exposure,” he said.

York Coroner Donald Coverdale said he had been aware of Mr Cooper’s views for many years, and said he had to comply with the law in carrying out his statutory duties.

“If a death is reported to me and there is no reason to believe it is unnatural or merits any further inquiry, I am not able to commission a post-mortem examination but am legally obliged to authorise registration of the death without further ado,” he said.

He said that if a post-mortem examination clearly dictated a natural cause of death, he had no jurisdiction to pursue further inquiries, but if it were a case of industrial disease or otherwise unnatural, he would hold an inquest.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:26am Fri 12 Apr 13

greaves11 says...

many of my work mates died of cancer we worked on the roof of the carriage works in the district engineers dept. when we took glass out on the roofs above the asbestos we were covered in it, a firm from armly was sripping coaches of asbestos and it was everyware..
many of my work mates died of cancer we worked on the roof of the carriage works in the district engineers dept. when we took glass out on the roofs above the asbestos we were covered in it, a firm from armly was sripping coaches of asbestos and it was everyware.. greaves11
  • Score: 0

10:04am Fri 12 Apr 13

roskoboskovic says...

thanks to mr cooper many families of railwaymen who died of mesothelioma got their deserved compensation buy by god it had to be fought for.the employers and specialists/consulta
nts at york hospital did all they could to deny the disease in many sufferers and it was only guts and determination that won the day.i fear many more will succumb to this awful disease in the years to come.
thanks to mr cooper many families of railwaymen who died of mesothelioma got their deserved compensation buy by god it had to be fought for.the employers and specialists/consulta nts at york hospital did all they could to deny the disease in many sufferers and it was only guts and determination that won the day.i fear many more will succumb to this awful disease in the years to come. roskoboskovic
  • Score: 1

1:24pm Fri 12 Apr 13

Pedro says...

I have had contact with the stuff myself. I went to school with it hanging out of the side of classroom ceiling and then pulling buildings down which may well have contained it. People simply didn't know about the danger. There is no blame attached to management or other party. It is killing them as well. I never worked at the carriage works and I am glad I never did, but you can't say for certain every case came from there just because you worked there. The worst of it is that people have to "prove" where they got the spore from to gain compensation. How can anybody know? It could have been from a crumbling public building or blown from a tip?
I have had contact with the stuff myself. I went to school with it hanging out of the side of classroom ceiling and then pulling buildings down which may well have contained it. People simply didn't know about the danger. There is no blame attached to management or other party. It is killing them as well. I never worked at the carriage works and I am glad I never did, but you can't say for certain every case came from there just because you worked there. The worst of it is that people have to "prove" where they got the spore from to gain compensation. How can anybody know? It could have been from a crumbling public building or blown from a tip? Pedro
  • Score: -1

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree