Letters RSS Feed


Badger cull not the answer

BADGERS have long been protected by the law but now their future is under threat.

Badgers are known to carry tuberculosis and the Government is considering a massive cull in order to prevent the spread of the disease to cattle.

The problem is that the latest scientific studies show that culling can make the problem worse as infected badgers tend to move into cleared areas. Culling can cost around three times more than the cost to farmers of dealing with infected herds. In Ireland, where culling has taken place for more than 20 years, the incidence of tuberculosis in cattle is twice as high as in the UK.

Scientists have been working on a vaccine for cattle and badgers and these should be available within a few years, so there is even less reason to start culling badgers now. Please write to your MP and ask them to keep full protection for badgers and give support to finding other ways of preventing the spread of tuberculosis.

Guy Wallbanks, Co-ordinator, York and Ryedale Friends of the Earth, Kingsway West, York.

Comments(3)

nowthen says...
3:33pm Tue 22 Feb 11

Quite apart from the financial aspect ( £80 million of taxpayers money paid as compensation to affected farmers ) there is a moral one ; is it ok to have an overpopulation of sick and diseased badgers ? wouldn't a smaller population of healthy badgers be preferable ? Is it ok for people who work and find recreation in the countryside to run the increasing risk of TB infection from badger contaminated grassland ? Is it ok to let the badger population increase exponentially without control until diseases caused by stress and overcrowding limit it ?

Duck in the hedge says...
12:36pm Wed 23 Feb 11

Guy Wallbanks has done his homework on this, and I agree with his logical conclusion.
STOP THE BADGER CULL, NOW !

Blake 2pi says...
2:20am Thu 24 Feb 11

In 2007 the cull was rules as not an option because of financial constraints and the perturbation effect. However, in the four years since then the perturbation effect died down, wheras the benefits in the culling area remained. Meaning that the economic and scientific case has changed in favour of a cull. That's how science works, it evolves over time, it doesn't stop at a time most convenient to a certain viewpoint.

The vaccine should not be seen as an absolute solution. Research is ongoing to see if it can make a meaningful impact and by that I mean culling thousands of badgers for post mortem examination. Current Defra modelling estimates puts their effectiveness in this order;
Vaccine and cull
Cull
Vaccine

Whatever path is taken badgers will die. So lets not let emotion rule this debate, this is about an infectious disease that hasn't been taken seriously in this country for too long.

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree