MATTHEW Laverack accuses “faceless critics” at York Civic Trust of “unwarranted condemnation” of a planning proposal (Letters, May 4).

We are not invisible: a brief visit to our website will reveal the names of all our board, committee chairs and staff.

We are a membership charity of around 1,000 ordinary citizens who elect our board.

An application form is available on the website: we would be delighted to have Matthew on board.

We want new developments to create a better city, and we try to provide thoughtful and constructive responses within the planning process.

There is nothing invisible about this: we are an active participant in shaping York’s future.

As far as the former fire station site is concerned, we are delighted our earlier suggestions have resulted in the retention of the Trinity Chapel façade. But, like many organisations and individuals who have commented, we still think York deserves better.

We believe that the new buildings are too high, the massing is too great, and the design quality could be improved, particularly on the river frontage.

The decision rests with the city planning committee and they have recommended approval. We can all judge the results when the scheme is built.

Andrew Scott, Chair, York Civic Trust