Virgin's bid for the East Coast Main Line franchise included a flamboyant gesture of the kind we have come to expect from Richard Branson. He wants to run Europe's fastest trains on a parallel track.

Leaving aside the huge practical obstacles - what would Virgin do with all those houses next to the railway embankment? - there is another good reason for treating this plan with a pinch of scepticism: Virgin rail's track record. Its West Coast line service is poor, expensive and unpopular.

Meanwhile GNER, though not perfect, has established a fast and efficient service between Edinburgh and London. The company has also pledged to keep its headquarters, and 300 jobs, in York. Its bosses know it takes more than a flamboyant gesture to run a railway.

see NEWS 'Virgin plans 205mph trains to York'

2000 Newsquest (York) Ltd

- A Gannett Company

Converted for the new archive on 30 June 2000. Some images and formatting may have been lost in the conversion.