I STRONGLY disagree with PR Wiley's interpretation of Coun Andy D'Agorne's behaviour at the beech trees on Connaught Court in Fulford (Letters, September 30).

Like myself, Coun D'Agorne found himself in the green movement because he cares about people and the environment we all share. Long before his election by the citizens of Fishergate, Andy was passionate about what is now termed "sustainable development" and was trying hard to promote social justice and live a lower-impact lifestyle.

He felt that by being elected, he could help steer this city towards a more sustainable path to the future - and indeed he has contributed to the debate and cast his vote on the committees he attends.

However, when the planning process fails by not taking local people's views into account and by nodding again in the direction of over-development and profit-making, it is entirely right to make one's feelings known and demonstrate.

I have huge respect for Belinda, Rosemary, Denise, Andy and the others who had the courage to do what they did. As they all practised "non-violent direct action" no police officers faced resistance or got hurt.

As for the trees, it is very common for mature specimens to host a range of "diseases". These are just natural fungi and invertebrates. Trees with unsafe limbs can be pruned or pollarded at the correct time of year to extend their life and keep their benefit for humankind.

These trees were felled for profit.

John Cosslam,

Garden House,

Hull Road,

York.

Updated: 11:25 Wednesday, October 06, 2004