Match report: York City 0, Oldham Athletic 2

York City’s Michael  Coulson, left, shoots for goal  in the friendly defeat against Oldham Athletic York City’s Michael Coulson, left, shoots for goal in the friendly defeat against Oldham Athletic

AN important lesson should be imprinted in the brains of York City’s players as they contemplate their first defeat of pre-season – a 2-0 reverse to Oldham Athletic.

If you defend poorly in the Football League, you are likely to be punished severely.

Michael Ingham didn’t have too much to do as the Latics visited Bootham Crescent, but he twice picked the ball out of his net in two first half minutes as the visitors demonstrated the ruthlessness which is required to succeed back in the big time.

York had actually started the brighter but it was two poor lapses of concentration in defence which led to both goals and which should give the Minstermen’s back four pause for thought.

James Tarkowski’s header was bad enough – a firm effort from eight yards after he was left completely unmarked from Youssouf M’Changama’s corner on 23 minutes.

But manager Gary Mills was just as disappointed with the second less than a minute later, a straight ball right through the heart of the back four allowing Daniel Taylor to find Robbie Simpson inside the box.

The forward swept his shot away from a helpless Ingham into the bottom left-hand corner.

Doubly disappointing because it followed a promising opening 20 minutes, where City fashioned a couple of half-chances against their League One opponents.

Striker Jason Walker could have given them the lead on six minutes but, although his spectacular volley from Jon Challinor’s cross left Oldham ’keeper Dean Bouzanis a spectator, defender Connor Brown managed to get the slightest of touches to deflect it behind.

And Matty Blair , presented before the game with his The Press Player of the Year Award for his heroics during York’s Wembley double-winning season, scuffed a shot after an incisive move involving Walker and Paddy McLaughlin shortly afterwards.

Once they had their quick-fire lead, Oldham were happy to play possession football and it was York who were left pondering their next course of action at the break.

Their response was to try to play more positively, and further up the pitch, Walker moving down the left before finding Coulson, who retained possession despite a strong challenge and passed to McLaughlin – only for the former Newcastle reserves’ captain to smash the ball high over the bar after cutting inside.

Mills brought on Ashley Chambers for his first piece of pre-season action and, alongside Jamie Reed , also introduced trialist Dominic Knowles into the fray.

The latter pair combined almost immediately as Reed bustled forward and Knowles hit a shot from a tight angle which was easily saved by Bouzanis.

Oldham’s play stalled a little when boss Paul Dickov introduced eight substitutes, en masse, midway through the second half but Tarkowski remained on the pitch and served further warning of his potency when a snapshot from 16 yards flew just wide of Ingham’s goal.

Knowles’ lively cameo was almost crowned with 12 minutes remaining when his header was blocked on the line and, from a subsequent corner, Chris Doig had an effort blocked.

York’s later work was better.

Reed executed a smart turn just inside the box and forced substitute Oldham ’keeper Liam Jacob to beat away a curling shot which had looked to be on its way into the left-hand corner.

And, almost immediately, Chambers shot narrowly wide after working an opportunity on the edge of the box.

But City were unable to follow Oldham’s lessons in finishing and, on the back of two slack goals conceded at Pickering in midweek, York will be glad these defensive blunders are being committed in pre-season.

In the League campaign, they won’t be so fortunate.

City: Ingham, Challinor, Doig, Smith (Parslow 66), Blanchett (Fyfield 54), McReady (Chambers 54), Bullock, McLaughlin (Potts 72), Coulson (Platt 73), Walker (Knowles 61), Blair (Reed 61). Subs (not used): Musselwhite, Henderson.

Attendance: 1,335 (209 from Oldham).

Comments(9)

ian923 says...
11:36am Mon 23 Jul 12

Firstly, the pitch looked magnificent and is a credit to the ground staff.Oldham chased the ball down when not in possession and players had less time than in the Conference. The pace was quicker and some of the marking was poor or non-existent.We started well but never looked like matching oldham and didn't display the threat oldham did when attacking.We didn't take advantage of any set plays either.Bullock was my man of the match , not giving the ball away and producing some incisive passes which were not further developed.Ingham had no chance with either of the goals.Having said all that Oldham were a good test and defensive lessons have to be learned as there will be more forwards with genuine pace in the games to come.McCready looked good as did Knowles in his cameo appearance and Jonathan Smith should be a good influence as I'm sure he 'll get a regular starting place.
Scott Kerr will be like a new signing also when he returns.There is genuine promise in the squad and I look forward to the Donny game and League fixtures.

OLD - HEAD says...
11:37am Mon 23 Jul 12

This was a comfortable win for a decent Oldham Athletic team. City have to take note of the lessons learned from this friendly. This actual friendly match result, like the three previous wins over lower-level opponents, mean absolutely nothing. Over the fifty plus years I have been watching York City I have often seen us win all of our friendly games and still have a poor season, and of course vice-versa losing friendlies and then having a decent season. Friendlies are just to build up fitness and understanding, nothing more. I will personally be satisfied just to see City establish themselves in League 2 next season, I am certainly not getting carried away with all this promotion hype.

#TheRealObama says...
1:02pm Mon 23 Jul 12

OLD - HEAD wrote:
This was a comfortable win for a decent Oldham Athletic team. City have to take note of the lessons learned from this friendly. This actual friendly match result, like the three previous wins over lower-level opponents, mean absolutely nothing. Over the fifty plus years I have been watching York City I have often seen us win all of our friendly games and still have a poor season, and of course vice-versa losing friendlies and then having a decent season. Friendlies are just to build up fitness and understanding, nothing more. I will personally be satisfied just to see City establish themselves in League 2 next season, I am certainly not getting carried away with all this promotion hype.
never a truer word spoken.. people need to be realistic.

tips says...
2:25pm Mon 23 Jul 12

I think most supporters would be quite happy to survive comfortably next season but at the same time let's be positive and go all out for promotion .
If we can keep up the momentum anything is possible

duffy says...
8:39pm Mon 23 Jul 12

tips wrote:
I think most supporters would be quite happy to survive comfortably next season but at the same time let's be positive and go all out for promotion .
If we can keep up the momentum anything is possible
I just think some posters need to be realistic. Clubs like Fleetwood, Rotherham, Northampton, Southend, Bristol Rovers have way bigger budgets than us, I would guess we are bottom half budget wise and don't have a tremendous amount of league experience in the squad especially defensively. I'm all for hoping for the best but when Mills talks of finishing top I'm struggling to see it. I think a midtable finish would be very respectable.

carterjason says...
9:38pm Mon 23 Jul 12

Predict finish in top half of table, York fans must remember even in the conference their were bigger clubs with more spending power.
Last season was a tremendous achievement , Gary Mills is doing a great job and has built- up excellant backroom staff to assist him.

oldmanvecrayke says...
9:55pm Mon 23 Jul 12

Duffy, do you not think GM can forge these players , irrespective of league experience into a good quality league 2 side????

duffy says...
10:46pm Mon 23 Jul 12

oldmanvecrayke wrote:
Duffy, do you not think GM can forge these players , irrespective of league experience into a good quality league 2 side????
I think he probably can, but I don't think that's going to happen overnight. Players like Blair, Chambers, Fyfield, Paddy, McReady, Oyebanjo are going to need time and patience and I think given a season of league football will blossom. I also think if they and Mills stay season after next Mills will have a better idea of those others in the squad that maybe are a bit of a risk. He has been very faithfull to most of last seasons regulars and there has to be question marks on whether the likes of Fyfield, Challinor, Smith, Parslow, McGurk can make the step up. In conclusion if we finish midtable next season and manage to retain the key players I think the real push will come the season after.

oldmanvecrayke says...
10:38am Tue 24 Jul 12

I do agree with you Duffy, although I have been swept along with the massive momentum of our success. You know aswell as I do that we 've never had a massive budget here and so the only way for us to forge a successful side , is to develop the mixture we have into a quality side, similar to how GMs former manager the great Brian Clough did. . Its not often managers last any length of time at one club, but I genuinely believe our man likes and wants to be here , so the longer he remains here obviously determines how far we go!!!!
All said and done, I still think we play proper football , better than we have for many a long while and long may that continue under Mr Mills.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree