Match report: York City 2, Mansfield Town 2

Matty Blair  bundles in York City’s first goal Matty Blair bundles in York City’s first goal

STUTTERING York City have gone three games without a home win for the first time under Gary Mills.

Following on from the 2-2 FA Trophy draw with Solihull Moors and the 3-2 Blue Square Bet Premier defeat to Kidderminster at Bootham Crescent, Mills’ men needed a stoppage-time equaliser from Jamal Fyfield to share the spoils against Mansfield Town yesterday.

Just as against Solihull, when Jon Challinor pounced at the death, Fyfield’s deft finish spoke volumes for City’s character but the Minstermen will be annoyed to have ushered in the new year by conceding an early goal – a habit that dogged their progress at the tail end of 2011.

Matt Green’s 14th-minute strike meant the Minstermen have conceded in the opening quarter of an hour in four of their last five matches.

When Aman Verma then doubled the visitors’ advantage on 72 minutes with his side’s second and last shot on target, City looked on the brink of registering back-to-back league defeats in front of their own fans.

But, while the Minstermen are developing a reputation for unlikely comebacks, Mansfield’s tendency to throw away leads is well established in 2011/12.

Matty Blair’s 77th-minute goal and Fyfield’s late strike meant the Stags have now drawn eight games from a winning position.

Earlier, the hosts had started with defensive stalwarts David McGurk and Dan Parslow as centre-half partners in a back four for the first time in a league match this season but still fell behind to the first chance of the afternoon.

Liam Henderson, who had just been switched from centre forward to the right flank, failed to track overlapping full back Kieron Freeman.

The on-loan Nottingham Forest left-back then raced on to Lindon Meikle’s pass and his low cross was turned in from five yards by Green.

City’s first opportunity of the match, meanwhile, fell to Henderson on 20 minutes after Paddy McLaughlin’s pass ricocheted favourably to him in the penalty box.

But the off-balance former Watford striker’s shot was at a comfortable height for Stags ’keeper Alan Marriott to tip over.

James Meredith should have then claimed only his second goal in three seasons as a City player but guided the ball past Marriott’s left-hand post from ten yards with only the Mansfield ’keeper to beat.

At the other end, Anthony Howell’s 15-yard effort flashed narrowly wide after Meredith had stopped Green in his tracks.

The injury-plagued McGurk then departed the action with a calf problem with Mills sending on the dropped Fyfield as a replacement.

As the first half drew to a close, Marriott made a routine near-post save from Blair, who was then inches away from converting a Parslow header at the far post following Scott Kerr’s free-kick.

After the interval, McLaughlin’s edge-of-the-box effort failed to unduly trouble Marriott, Parslow headed wide from an Andre Boucaud free-kick and Jamie Reed got his bearings wrong 12 yards from goal after a pass from fellow substitute Danny Pilkington.

Paul Cox’s men were more clinical on the counter attack, however, when Reed lost possession on the edge of the visitors’ 18-yard box.

With City outnumbered at the back, Green’s clever backheel found Verma and he fired powerfully past Michael Ingham from 15 yards despite Parslow’s valiant attempt at a last-ditch tackle.

The Minstermen were back in the game, though, five minutes later when Blair bundled the ball over the line from three yards after Meredith had raided down the left and delivered a dangerous low cross.

On 84 minutes, Blair was crowded out after a purposeful run into the Stags’ penalty box only for the ball to loop into the air and fall to Reed eight yards from goal.

But an alert Marriott charged off his line and, leaping into the air, spread himself well to ultimately keep out Reed’s volley with his left heel.

The one-time Lincoln ’keeper could only watch City’s equaliser float over his head and under the crossbar, however, during the first minute of added-on time.

Fyfield found himself in an excellent position after Parslow had won a header in the visitors’ penalty box and displayed immaculate composure to chip Marriott from eight yards with the outside of his left boot.

Match report

York City 2 (Blair 77; Fyfield 90), Mansfield Town 2 (Green 14; Verma 72)

York City: Michael Ingham 6, Lanre Oyebanjo 6, David McGurk 6, Daniel Parslow 8, James Meredith 6, Andre Boucaud 6, Scott Kerr 7, Paddy McLaughlin 6, Ashley Chambers 5, Liam Henderson 5, Matty Blair 6.

Subs: Jamal Fyfield 7 (for McGurk, 32), Jamie Reed 6 (for Henderson, 55), Danny Pilkington 6 (for Chambers, 66). Not used: Moké, Challinor.

Key: 10 – Faultless; 9 – Outstanding; 8 – Excellent; 7 – Good; 6 – Average; 5 – Below par; 4 – Poor; 3 – Dud; 2 – Hopeless; 1 – Retire.

Star man: Parslow – committed as ever. Never gave up, epitomised by his assist for Fyfield’s equaliser.

Mansfield: Alan Marriott, Luke O’Neill, Martin Riley, Ritchie Sutton, Kieron Freeman, Gary Roberts (Lee Stevenson, 90), Adam Murray, Anthony Howell (Aman Verma, 46), Ross Dyer, Matt Green (Jon Worthington, 88), Lindon Meikle. Subs not used: Louis Briscoe, Shane Redmond.

Booked: Howell 45, O’Neill 52, Freeman 63, Roberts 79, Marriott 90.

Shots on target: City 6, Stags 2.

Shots off target: City 4, Stags 3.

Corners: City 5, Stags 0.

Fouls conceded: City 15, Stags 21.

Offsides: City 3, Stags 0.

Referee: Declan Ford (Lincoln) – made the kind of baffling decisions that have become the norm recently.

Attendance: 4,284 (498 away fans).

Miss of the match: Meredith should have at least hit the target with his first-half chance.

Shot of the match: Verma’s effort rocketed past Ingham.

Comments(23)

coolyman4 says...
10:26am Mon 2 Jan 12

Were you watching the same game as everyone else? Parslow 8 McLaughlin 6 Kerr 7

What a crock of s@*!. McLaughlin and Kerr were streets above everyone else. Who was marking Green for their 1st goal? That would be Parslow who was as committed as ever.

The Press hasnt a clue week after week

duffy says...
10:35am Mon 2 Jan 12

Ashikodi has signed a permanent deal. Frankly staggering.

OLD - HEAD says...
11:17am Mon 2 Jan 12

duffy wrote:
Ashikodi has signed a permanent deal. Frankly staggering.
I am also shocked after reading this. We must have given our word to Kettering when they let us have him on loan, that we would sign him permanently in January.

ian923 says...
11:58am Mon 2 Jan 12

Strengthening our play off position is now a must and if as posted Ashikodi has signed a permanent deal it does not fill me with confidence.Matty Blair seems to be our only goal threat at the moment as Hendo and Reedy are not cutting it.Chambers is out of form and Walker still out.I don't know why things have gone wrong lately but our fast flowing football has disappeared altogether, as has our accurate passing.Dave McGurk is normally one of our stalwarts so hope his injury is not serious.I think Fleetwood will pip Wrexham for top spot at the end of the season and I'd rather play Wrexham than Fleetwood if we can stay in the play offs.There has to be a big improvement in our play to achieve this.Come on City

YCFC115 says...
12:34pm Mon 2 Jan 12

duffy wrote:
Ashikodi has signed a permanent deal. Frankly staggering.
No way, he is simply dreadful and can't even get a place on the bench on what is a bunch of inept strikers (besides Walker)- shocking!

Phil, Leeds says...
12:36pm Mon 2 Jan 12

coolyman4 wrote:
Were you watching the same game as everyone else? Parslow 8 McLaughlin 6 Kerr 7

What a crock of s@*!. McLaughlin and Kerr were streets above everyone else. Who was marking Green for their 1st goal? That would be Parslow who was as committed as ever.

The Press hasnt a clue week after week
Considering Parslow has hardly been given a game this season and we have no reserve side where players can get match fit, I thought he had a decent game and can only improve by having more games. He was left completely exposed marking both their centre forwards for the second goal. And his aerial ability, he's the only player in the team who can consistently win headers, created that late equaliser. I for one hope he is now given an extended run at centre back, he was last season's player of the year for heaven's sake. The same comment about match practice applies also to Jamie Reed who is a natural goalscorer and he too should be given an extended run when he will score plenty of goals.

Phil, Leeds says...
12:50pm Mon 2 Jan 12

YCFC115 wrote:
duffy wrote:
Ashikodi has signed a permanent deal. Frankly staggering.
No way, he is simply dreadful and can't even get a place on the bench on what is a bunch of inept strikers (besides Walker)- shocking!
Obviously his contract offer is a reward for his superb performances thus far. Being serious I guess he's no where near full fitness and Mills is banking on seeing a different player when/if he gets to that point. But I'd still have him behind both Walker and Reed. If we are going to get another striker in on loan I would like to see Mills trying to get a young reserve striker in from a Premier/Championship level club.

joejamestom says...
12:53pm Mon 2 Jan 12

ian923 wrote:
Strengthening our play off position is now a must and if as posted Ashikodi has signed a permanent deal it does not fill me with confidence.Matty Blair seems to be our only goal threat at the moment as Hendo and Reedy are not cutting it.Chambers is out of form and Walker still out.I don't know why things have gone wrong lately but our fast flowing football has disappeared altogether, as has our accurate passing.Dave McGurk is normally one of our stalwarts so hope his injury is not serious.I think Fleetwood will pip Wrexham for top spot at the end of the season and I'd rather play Wrexham than Fleetwood if we can stay in the play offs.There has to be a big improvement in our play to achieve this.Come on City
The other conference sides have worked us out so we are unlikely to get the same opportunities given referees who will not rein in physically combative sides. Without Walker to attract opposition players making space for others we are going to have to work hard if we insist on conceding early avoidable goals.
With Moses signed I cannot see a striker coming in (hope GMs eye for a player means he is a gem as we will need additional presence up front) if as is stated elsewhere Mcdermott has signed for Telford then there is room for a loanee just cannot see a decent conference player being available.
A right back/mid field player or CB might just help the balance who to lose as we clearly cannot offer games to all the CBs. Ian foresees Fleetwood going up with hopefully Wrexham losing their way a bit I can see Grimsby coming good, Luton as always & Kiddy provided they can keep their players in January important we stay in touch now until Walker is back & in form & we should look to get Reed + Hendo game sharp in the meantime in a formation with 2 up front with Moses on the bench.
But you know what I am being entertained, I do have faith in GM & these are a good set of players capable of beating any side on a good day is this our year? Possibly but it could be the final part of the transition to a fully chosen GM squad & if they went out for a night out good on them as long as no one did a Gash & Co now back to business Coe on City!!!

johnbyrneshair says...
1:10pm Mon 2 Jan 12

Well said joe jamestom, I agree with everything you wrote. Teams are now closing city down much quicker, with 2 or 3 players surrounding our playmakers who are harried into making mistakes. Mansfield looked physically stronger than us and won most 50/50 challenges in the air. I still feel we are going to Wembley one way or another this season.

duffy says...
1:17pm Mon 2 Jan 12

As above teams have worked us out now and deny us the space we need. We push forward so much our defenders are left way too far up the pitch if we lose posession. The heavier pitches have also effected our passing game which was always going to happen. I can't see another forward coming in now short of Reed leaving which leaves us with an unfit Walker and Ashikodi and Reed not match fit alongside Henderson. We missed out big time on Miller in my view and I can see Grimsby actually passing us at some stage. It's going to be a very tough winter with another tricky game at Lincoln next.

YorkCityLuke says...
1:44pm Mon 2 Jan 12

Parslow was excellent! Their goals happened because the rest of the defense were constantly being drawn out of position, Parslow was the last man on several occasions - definitely the best performance on the day in my opinion (closely followed by Kerr and Pilkington when he was brought on). Entertaining game and not the end of the world to draw, despite what people have been saying I did not think Mansfield looked 'average', but actually fairly decent when attacking - we do need to start getting a few wins again though.

OLD - HEAD says...
1:46pm Mon 2 Jan 12

I have to agree that we dont want any more panic signings, we have had enough of them in the past. Lets hope that the Manager can add two or three experienced signings to steady the ship. Quite a few chasing clubs will be strengthening their squads hoping to break into that top five. City are going to have a right fight on their hands to keep hold of a play-off spot. Grimsby, Gateshead and Cambridge all have ambitions to get back into the league. Not forgetting of course our recent opponents Mansfield Town. Remember their Chairman has already stated that once their ground is secured, then he will pump in two million quid to strengthen the playing squad. People have seen the likes of Crawley and Fleetwood dominate the transfer market. So money really does talk in the Conference. Our realistic objective has to be to achieve promotion via the Play-Offs. AFC Wimbledon did it without spending mega-bucks, so they have to be our inspiration.

KNIGHTS4EVA says...
2:21pm Mon 2 Jan 12

Amazing we are still so high in league when you look at our pathetic forward line.If Mills doesnt bring in some quality the great early season will be wasted.

duffy says...
2:41pm Mon 2 Jan 12

So this draw is again not the end of the world? We have gone from a possible 2 points off top spot to a possible 16 points and even out of the top five if our opponents when their games in hand. That's because of all these wonderfull draws.

joejamestom says...
3:17pm Mon 2 Jan 12

KNIGHTS4EVA wrote:
Amazing we are still so high in league when you look at our pathetic forward line.If Mills doesnt bring in some quality the great early season will be wasted.
Harsh if you are counting the pacey Blair, quality costs & there are league clubs with good money to spend. But as always there are some quality players around if you have a good eye & GM does have that. Reedy will come good with game time partnered up with Hendo could create chances & of course Moses if trained & fit might give us options.
Important Walker comes back fully fit, guess that no one will take him for big money injured so its not such a negative. Chambers looks out of sorts currently we will have to be patient there is a methodology to Gms signings no lumbering tanks all players that should be capable of carrying the ball so to me the player most likely not to fit is Smith, given that the TY Parslow combo looks good & Fyfield has his good points. To me it looks like cover for RB LB unless Challinor can decide where his future lies quickly & given McDermott may have gone there is scope to get a body or two in if they are the right type to fit the vision.
I am just unsure that the full scope of players required to combat every team in the conference can be had on our budget. Best City team to watch for ages enjoy the ride!

Stage Duke says...
3:21pm Mon 2 Jan 12

One or two points I noticed not being a regular City watcher. Cant agree with Dave about the ref - thought the guy had a decent game and was interested to see him pull Kerr up for a free kick in the first half. The guy in the crowd behind me went ballistic saying Scott had got the ball, yes he did, but he took the Mansfield players standing leg first !! Get off the referees backs, it was apparent as the game went on and City fell 2-0 behind that cartain of the crowd felt it was down to the ref !! 6 for McLaughlin ? The guys work rate was superb and, IMO, he was up with Parslow.

Stage Duke says...
3:24pm Mon 2 Jan 12

Chambers looked like a player short on confidence and interest and Pilkington was a breath of fresh air when he came on.

YorkCityLuke says...
3:45pm Mon 2 Jan 12

duffy wrote:
So this draw is again not the end of the world? We have gone from a possible 2 points off top spot to a possible 16 points and even out of the top five if our opponents when their games in hand. That's because of all these wonderfull draws.
I think you just read what you want to read rather than what is written. Noone is saying that constantly drawing is 'wonderful', in fact almost everyone (including the manager) is saying that we need wins. But if you look at the game objectively, on its own and disregarding our hopes for the season, it was not THAT bad.

duffy says...
3:54pm Mon 2 Jan 12

YorkCityLuke wrote:
duffy wrote: So this draw is again not the end of the world? We have gone from a possible 2 points off top spot to a possible 16 points and even out of the top five if our opponents when their games in hand. That's because of all these wonderfull draws.
I think you just read what you want to read rather than what is written. Noone is saying that constantly drawing is 'wonderful', in fact almost everyone (including the manager) is saying that we need wins. But if you look at the game objectively, on its own and disregarding our hopes for the season, it was not THAT bad.
since when should we start " disregarding our hopes for the season" it was said by some these away draws we're fine if we won at home, that was never going to happen. You can't just look at each game in isolation and say not bad. It's amazing how many people who were having a dig at me a few weeks ago for pointing this out are now saying the same thing.

SamYCFC says...
4:43pm Mon 2 Jan 12

Dave i've read alot of your match reports over the last couple of seasons.

They are absolute garbage and show no reflection of the game.

Your marking system may not please everyone but now they are just becoming embarrassing and reading them has almost become surreal when you constantly award generous marks for players who aren’t playing well. Parslow 8 out of 10? Is he bribing you?

Why will York not get promoted? We not only accept, but openly embrace players of Danny Parslow's ability. Or lack of it. Why are we conceding so many silly goals? Because we have garbage centre backs like Smith and Parslow yet they continue to receive all the plaudits for good performances.

OLD - HEAD says...
5:16pm Mon 2 Jan 12

I was once sat in the Main Stand behind the sponsors of that particular game. A City official asked one of them to nominate a "Man-of-the-Match". To be honest the guy didnt even know any of the players names, but he chose one at random. Ever since that day I have never taken who wins it too seriously. To be perfectly honest I would have struggled to name somebody on yesterdays performance.

BorderReiver says...
6:22pm Mon 2 Jan 12

Football is a game of opinions - from where I was standing Danny P was worthy of an 8 and I think City may struggle on the heavier pitches. Mansfield were a strong, well organised outfit that took their chances and made City look lightweight. The number one spot is now clearly out of reach, but all is not lost and other teams will also suffer bad patches. We may not be winning at this time, but we aint losing too many either. Keep the faith, it could have been a lot worse yesterday if a very average ref had given Mansfield a stonewall penalty in the 1st half ! C'mon City !

Mike Warwick says...
7:10pm Mon 2 Jan 12

Mr Mills seems to think the squad is a good one, will only sign a better player. From Sunday's performance he may have to spend, right back a weak link. Seeing Mansfield score in a five pass move may be our way to the football league. So many double figure passing moves in our own half and then give the ball away. Other posters have it right we have been found out. Time to change the game plan or pay the price. We were again bossed in midfield another weakness that must be tackled. We were lucky to draw let's hope we can deliver at Salisbury with more direct football and goals.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree