Match reports RSS Feed


Match report: York City 0, Wrexham 0

Paddy McLaughlin shoots for goal Paddy McLaughlin shoots for goal

REMEMBER, remember the fifth of November, 2011 – the day when York City may have discovered another plot to rocket back into the Football League.

Sceptics may argue Saturday’s goalless home draw with Blue Square Bet leaders Wrexham represented two points lost, a chance gone amiss to make home advantage count and cut the gap on the Dragons.

But the manner in which the Minstermen exacted parity and did not cede any more ground on the table-toppers underpinned an unyielding resilience that can bode as well as any goal-fest for the rest of the campaign.

And the fact that for the second league meeting this season City kept not one, but two clean sheets, as well as extracting four points from a maximum six in the brace of league battles with the men from the principality, demonstrates to all the Blue Square Bet Premier that Gary Mills’ charges are a force to be reckoned with.

For on a day when their much-feted front-line failed to spark, the intensity was on full measure to guarantee Wrexham would not breach the Bootham Crescent rearguard.

Timely interceptions and blocks were channelled right across the back four, and whenever Wrexham jostled through, goalkeeper Michael Ingham was at his most dramatically alert.

Midfielder Andre Boucaud, when not caressing and cajoling the ball to team-mates in the bid to manufacture an opening, also conjured stern defensive duty when needed.

And then there was Scott Kerr. The midfielder’s relentless exertions could have fuelled a power station.

From minute one to 95 – five minutes were signalled on the electronic board – Kerr wriggled through challenges in search of a goal, snapped into tackles that would have felled a redwood tree, and tidied up at the back with the cool and anticipation of Italy’s most famed stopper, Franco Baresi.

In a bizarre first half, the more sustained pressure was City’s, their heartening brand of pass and move with Kerr, Boucaud and Paddy McLaughlin to the fore as the team returned to that of the previous league outing from the much-changed line-up, which exited the FA Cup seven days earlier at Wrexham’s Racecourse Ground.

But once Ashley Chambers crashed to the deck under Mark Creighton’s challenge – England’s newest ‘C’-lion inexplicably cautioned for simulation by referee Peter Bankes when contact looked clear and there was no earthly reason to bite the turf as he was clean through on goal – Wrexham came the closest to scoring.

The Dragons broke with combustive speed through Adrian Cieslewicz and his cross was met by Jamie Tolley ten yards from goal. Ingham, heading towards his right, somehow thrust out a left hand to paw out the net-bound effort, Chris Smith hacking the ball away.

For all City’s pacey passing there was little penetration. Chambers ran right-back Curtis Obeng ragged, but virus-hit Matty Blair – soon subbed by Adriano Moké – and top-scorer Jason Walker were unusually subdued.

Wrexham goalkeeper Joslain Mayebi, in a shirt so day-glo it was a surprise City stewards did not threaten to eject him from the ground, was never extended before half-time.

Within eight minutes of the restart Mayebi was exercised three times by shots from Chambers, Walker and Jon Challinor, whose muscular raids down the right flank hinted at the hosts’ best way of fracturing Wrexham’s mean back-line.

Soon after that last attempt Ingham’s razor reflexes clawed away a point-blank header from player-manager Andy Morrell as the tightrope-taut tussle opened up.

There was a palpable sense that one goal would settle the clash and nerves jangled among both sets of supporters comprising Bootham Crescent’s biggest crowd of the season – indeed the largest since the play-off semi-final conquest of Luton Town in April 2010.

Boucaud’s outstretched leg thwarted substitute Danny Wright with an exquisite example of timing. Six inches the wrong way and Wrexham would have had a penalty, while a stinger from Moké, after he sashayed in from the right, was ushered into the Shippo by Mayebi.

There was still time for captain Smith to sweep away a cross close to the City goal-line while, with almost the last act and the home defence napping, Ingham reacted superbly to snatch a corner off Wright’s fringe.

So honours even in a nil-nil thriller, but it might yet be the point when City realised there is nothing – absolutely damn all – to fear between now and May.

Match facts

York City 0, Wrexham 0

York City: Michael Ingham 9, Jon Challinor 8, Chris Smith 8, Jamal Fyfield 8, James Meredith 8, Andre Boucaud 8, Scott Kerr 9, Paddy McLaughlin 7, Matty Blair 6, Jason Walker 6, Ashley Chambers 7.

Subs: Adriano Moké (for Blair 35) 7, Michael Potts (Boucaud 84).

Not used: David McGurk, Daniel Parslow, Jamie Reed.

Key: 10 – Faultless; 9 – Outstanding; 8 – Excellent; 7 – Good; 6 – Average; 5 – Below par; 4 – Poor; 3 – Dud; 2 – Hopeless; 1 – Retire.

City’s star man: Scott Kerr – total endeavour and enthusiasm to just shade goalkeeping ace Ingham.

Wrexham: Joslain Mayebi, Curtis Obeng, Mark Creighton, Nat Knight-Percival, Neil Ashton, Joe Clarke, Jamie Tolley (Lee Fowler 84), Jay Harris, Andy Morrell (Danny Wright 60), Mathias Pogba, Adrian Cieslewicz (Johnny Hunt 88). Subs not used: Chris Maxwell, Chris Westwood.

Booked: Chambers 67, Tolley 46, Wright 69.

Shots on target: City 4, Wrexham 4.

Shots off target: City 8, Wrexham 6.

Corners: City 8, Wrexham 7.

Offsides: City 4, Wrexham 1.

Fouls conceded: City 11, Wrexham 8.

Referee: Peter Bankes (Liverpool). Rating: Chambers’ caution apart, he was okay.

Attendance: 4,295 (615 away fans).

Moment of the match: Has to be Michael Ingham’s 17th-minute save to deny Jamie Tolley a certain goal. Such reflexes merit a return to the Northern Ireland number one spot.

Head to head - Ashley Chambers v Curtis Obeng

City’s newest call-up to the England ‘C’ team was always far too tricky for the Wrexham right-back.

He gave him a torrid time, particularly in the first half when Wrexham player-manager Andy Morrell finally convinced himself he might have to spend more time tracking back to protect the exposed defender.

However, Obeng was spared much further trouble during the bulk of the second half when Chambers swapped flanks with Adriano Moké.

Chambers twice zipped past Neil Ashton, but did not enjoy as much of the ball after the interval as City’s attacking momentum went awry.

Comments(13)

Zetkin says...
10:46am Mon 7 Nov 11

Mr Kelly's purple prose is one of life's under-rated pleasures ;o)

OLD - HEAD says...
11:08am Mon 7 Nov 11

A tight game against a useful side, just what we expected. Plenty of attractive passing football from City, sadly without that cutting edge which produces the goals. Wrexham are a difficult side to score against when Creighton is at the heart of their defence (remember that he did not enter the field until City were 3-0 up in the away league fixture). If the Manager had got any confidence in Jamie Reed, he would surely have introduced him in the second half. For when Jason Walker is kept out of the game, we need a bit of back-up from the bench but Reed and Henderson (who didnt even make the bench) have both struggled this season. This is where "Moneybags Fleetwood" have the advantage over us being able to call on Mango Vierra, Andy Langham, Jamie Vardy or Richard Brodie to spearhead their attack. There is still a long way to go, but with a bit of fine tuning in January, I feel confident that we can maintain our challenge.

Sir Alex says...
11:25am Mon 7 Nov 11

Tense game - a draw a fair result although I prefer our style of play for my £15. Shame Walker wasn't fully fit or I think we would have won.
I see Darlo are in trouble with talk of player salary reductions and poss administration. Have they got a commanding centreback we could make an offer to?

carterjason says...
11:34am Mon 7 Nov 11

Great game , City just needed a bit of luck in front of goal.
Ingham made 2 or 3 top class saves, some fantastic performances from the whole team.
Mill's has got the team playing a great attacking style of football and the players are responding and you can see the team spirit and the confidence growing.
I believe this season we are strong enough to push all the way to get promotion.

redwhiteblue says...
12:05pm Mon 7 Nov 11

It's good to sit back and read the various comments on how different individuals see the game, player performances. After my comments about Smith I have to say he didn't have a bad game - mistakes came from Fyfield, but he did put in vital tackles and got the final touch when we were under pressure. Sorry to see Blair depart early - set us back a little until Moke settle into the game plan. Jason off the pace for once but still a menace to their defence - as alway Creighton was strong, solid and commanding in their defence the only thing we lacked was the final ball - created chance but broke down in front of goal. Unusal because we been scoring goals. I agree with the comments on Reed's absence - if the manage had confidence in his approach/attitude to the game he would have introduced him - I think something is not right - we don't see him in training etc as Gary and Darron do - I'm glad he has to make the decisions. Why not try Henderson - do we need two defenders on the bench and not use either of them?
Not disappointed with the point - would have been nice to have taken all three, at the end of the day we would have settled for four from six against the leaders a few weeks ago.
We are playing some great football and we getting better with each game - the players are now gelling together.
Only problem, it's two weeks before we play Barrow - suffering withdrawal symptons already.

swh1963 says...
12:15pm Mon 7 Nov 11

It's a shame there seems to be a problem with Reed because he can set a game on fire when he's in the mood. I hope he and the manager can sort it out - he adds a lot to the squad.

3.10 TO IWELUMO says...
1:38pm Mon 7 Nov 11

Like this awful government York need a plan B if they want to get promoted this season.

I think the club should swallow there pride , dip into the till and bring Brodie in on loan until seasons end. But i wouldn't gamble on it happening or beat myself up if we can't afford it as long as our goal scoring doesn't dry up as the pitches get murkier.

Gryff Smith says...
1:57pm Mon 7 Nov 11

This is possibly the worst piece of journalism I have ever read. Can the press please concentrate on reporting the game?

Where is the considered analysis of whether Walker should have been subbed, given he struggled through the entire game? Or the probe into why Mills refuses to give Reedy a go, or play 2 up front from the start to give Walker someone to play off against the better teams in the division?

York are tremendous this season, no doubt, but there was a point on saturday when we could have nicked it. Keeping Walker on - and on his own when he was clearly still recovering from his time out - was the key decision for me. Great that I can feel a little disappointed that we didn't beat the league leaders, but when we are so good, I find Mills' tactics too cautious. It chips the confidence of what is otherwise a really great team - push them forward and win the game!

Dave Smith says...
2:03pm Mon 7 Nov 11

All very tight at the top, the analysis of games between sides currently sat in the top 10, shows that Fleetwood are the team to be feared but have played fewer games against top positioned sides, whilst Wrexham have played more games at home than away against these sides. Both Luton and York have scored most goals in these games with 17. Luton though have played six of their nine games at home.

Beware of Cambridge who have played 6 of the 7 fixtures away from home.

Our performances v Mansfield and Kidderminster could prove equally as pivotable.


points games pts per game
fleetwood 13 6 2.17
wrexham 15 9 1.67
york 13 8 1.63
kiddey 12 8 1.50
luton 13 9 1.44
gateshead14 10 1.40
cambridge 9 7 1.29
southport 11 9 1.22
mansfield 5 7 0.71
braintree 5 7 0.71

Things look rosey for City, up the reds.

I know I need to get out more often.

henleazeyorkie says...
6:19pm Mon 7 Nov 11

Dave Smith wrote:
All very tight at the top, the analysis of games between sides currently sat in the top 10, shows that Fleetwood are the team to be feared but have played fewer games against top positioned sides, whilst Wrexham have played more games at home than away against these sides. Both Luton and York have scored most goals in these games with 17. Luton though have played six of their nine games at home. Beware of Cambridge who have played 6 of the 7 fixtures away from home. Our performances v Mansfield and Kidderminster could prove equally as pivotable. points games pts per game fleetwood 13 6 2.17 wrexham 15 9 1.67 york 13 8 1.63 kiddey 12 8 1.50 luton 13 9 1.44 gateshead14 10 1.40 cambridge 9 7 1.29 southport 11 9 1.22 mansfield 5 7 0.71 braintree 5 7 0.71 Things look rosey for City, up the reds. I know I need to get out more often.
Not sure why you need to spend time avoiding getting out more often.

A quick look at the itv.stats.football site gives you all this in seconds plus more (as I'm sure others do)

Good point on Saturday? Sure, but nothing less than six from the next two will convince me we'll be auto promotion. Personally, my expectations are set at play offs

brahma says...
7:09pm Mon 7 Nov 11

Sir Alex wrote:
Tense game - a draw a fair result although I prefer our style of play for my £15. Shame Walker wasn't fully fit or I think we would have won.
I see Darlo are in trouble with talk of player salary reductions and poss administration. Have they got a commanding centreback we could make an offer to?
Graeme Lee would probably do a job but I'm not sure he's better than what we've got. Matt Kilgallon is one of numerous centre-backs at Sunderland and might be worth a borrow. York lad too.

Dave Smith says...
10:05pm Mon 7 Nov 11

Can't understand why we want any further centre backs when we have Dave McQurk who everyone recognises as the clubs best defender and Danny Parslow also an accomplished defender on the bench.

Sir Alex says...
9:47am Tue 8 Nov 11

For me its the balance between the centre halfs that is not quite right. Smith Parslow and McGurk are very similar. Think we'll still be top 3 with what we'ver got. :)

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree