EVERY time I read reports of York Knights matches by Peter Martini, I wonder if we have been at the same game.

York Knights were a shambles at Dewsbury. They appeared too hyped up for the occasion and displayed the sort of unprofessional and ill-disciplined approach that has become almost a trademark.

To blame the referee was totally absurd. I would ask Peter Martini when did he last referee a game of rugby league?

For him to give any referee a rating is blatantly ludicrous, and a feature he might delete from his column. Referees, like players, have good games and bad ones.

I would appeal to Peter Martini to at least try to be a bit more objective in his analysis – as was (director of rugby) James Ratcliffe in his observations about the match.

Ed Johnson, Sandringham Street, York.