York City's Clarke Carlisle calls for ban for Serbia

Clarke Carlisle Clarke Carlisle

Association chairman and York City defender Clarke Carlisle has backed calls for Serbia to receive a “significant” international ban after “utterly deplorable” scenes at England Under-21s’ game in Krusevac on Tuesday.

The FA has complained to UEFA after England players were subjected to racist and physical abuse at the end of the European Championship play-off second leg.

Serbian supporters, players and other officials appeared to get involved while England defender Danny Rose was sent off after the final whistle for reacting angrily to apparent racial abuse. Carlisle watched the chaos and violence unfold in the ESPN studio alongside former England midfielder Paul Ince, who called for Serbia to be kicked out of the next ten qualification campaigns for major tournaments.

And the 33-year-old Minsterman agreed a hefty punishment was the only answer.

“You should not have to experience those scenes in this day and age. It was utterly deplorable behaviour,” said Carlisle.

“It’s quite farcical. A guy is racially abused and then he gets punished for his reaction to that.

“We saw how the whole debacle progressed into punching, kicking. We saw photos of headbutts going on in the staff. But Danny Rose for kicking a ball away ends up getting himself sent off. This is just wrong.

“UEFA need to make a standpoint here and more importantly FIFA, I feel, because it was a FIFA qualification tournament.

“The message has to come from the top down that this behaviour will not be tolerated.”

England U21 manager Stuart Pearce had spoken before the game of his confidence that the issue of racism would not raise itself.

A match between the two countries at the 2007 Under-21 European Championship in Holland was marred when England defender Nedum Onuoha was racially abused. Serbia were fined £16,000 by UEFA.

Carlisle believes a lengthy ban would force Serbia to address the issue.

“It’s immaterial where it is, who the perpetrators are,” he said. “What’s material is that the governing bodies lay down extremely harsh sanctions so that they deter countries and people from acting in this way.

“You can draw parity with what happened to English football when we were kicked out of Europe for the violence (following the 1985 Heysel disaster) – that instigated a period of self-governance.

“I believe Serbia should be banned because it’s a repeat offence.

“Banning them for a start, from any tournament, would be progress but I think if it’s significant – if it’s a couple of tournaments – then that would cause that nation to address the issue.”

Comments(13)

Some old bloke says...
11:37am Thu 18 Oct 12

Well said Clarke but I have a feeling that FIFA will do nothing meaningful, which means the problem will continue in some of these eastern European countries.

Wilyorkuk1983 says...
11:54am Thu 18 Oct 12

Even worse still FIFA are investigating both clubs, I would not at all be surprised if the English FA get charged with not controlling their players or player conduct.

brahma says...
12:32pm Thu 18 Oct 12

For crying out loud, York Press! "Association chairman" you write without bothering to inform readers of which association he is chair.

ADAMCUTHBERT says...
12:45pm Thu 18 Oct 12

Hope he's as passionate about his performance on Saturday (if he gets the nod) as he his over this whole fiasco!

Need a win Saturday!

COYR

ian923 says...
1:05pm Thu 18 Oct 12

The scenes were disgraceful but as Eufa and Fifa are as soft as the proverbial I do not expect much to happen.Surely Danny Rose can appeal the red card.

uhtred says...
3:06pm Thu 18 Oct 12

Although I understnd why Rose was upset with the crowd, do not know what the pitch fracas was all about and why the Croat players were having a go at Rose, has anyone offered an explanation?

The Kaiser says...
3:46pm Thu 18 Oct 12

Clarke is spot on. And this piece hits the nail on the head http://magicspongers
.blogspot.co.uk/2012
/10/enough-is-enough
.html

swh1963 says...
6:26pm Thu 18 Oct 12

Sepp Blatter has indicated before that he does not think racism is a problem. Nothing will be done until Fifa is run by decent people.

KAT1965 says...
8:16pm Thu 18 Oct 12

Its not surprising when you consider that he was originally involved with a Swiss team called "Brown Shirts"!!!!!!

openallhours says...
9:59pm Thu 18 Oct 12

Racism is inexcusable, but after Clarke's last home performance (was 0 - 0 before his blunder), I hope he's as committed to doing his best for York as he is his media career.

swh1963 says...
10:11pm Thu 18 Oct 12

openallhours wrote:
Racism is inexcusable, but after Clarke's last home performance (was 0 - 0 before his blunder), I hope he's as committed to doing his best for York as he is his media career.
Cheap shot - so he has a role outside York City FC, get used to it. Like if he didn't he wouldn't have given a goal away in a tinpot competition? He's a good player and has played well for York so far. It's comments like yours that might make him go elsewhere. And what will that have achieved exactly?

Budgie says...
9:58am Fri 19 Oct 12

Well said Clarke. Presented himself well on TV and echoed what we all feel about racism.

walwynwasgod says...
10:19am Fri 19 Oct 12

Regarding Clarke Carlisle. We should stick to discussing York City issues on this page. Clarke is a very articulate young man, but unfortunately, UEFA/FIFA treat racism very lightly which is disgraceful (a slap on the wrist for Lazio yesterday). I can see the point that openallhours is trying to make. However, he cannot use the excuse that his role with the PFA is affecting his performance. Both he (Carlisle) and Doig have been shaky recently. I think because Clarke has a high profile through the media that certain people expect him to be more Clarke Kent than Carlisle ! The reallity is we have given him a chance when others haven't.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree