York City loan plan to aid McGurk fitness fight

David  McGurk David McGurk

DAVID McGURK might have to go out on loan to force his way back into the York City first team.

Manager Gary Mills is considering sending the Minstermen stalwart out for a month to play some games with a view to the 30-year-old returning to Bootham Crescent and exerting pressure to reclaim a centre-back berth.

McGurk continued his return from a series of injuries, including throat and knee complaints, with 90 minutes in the behind-closed-doors 3-1 victory over Newcastle United reserves on Wednesday and Mills said: “He’s had a couple of games and we have to see a bit more from David now.

“He’s getting a little bit fitter. We have got three centre-halves there at this moment and (it might be about) whether it is time for him to go out for a month and get a lot of football. It’s not just this season but last as well where he has missed an awful lot of football and you need to be playing regularly to get that fitness back so that might be an option for us. We will see.”

Mills continued: “I have said, not just individually but to a few of them as a group, that they need to get out and play some football. There’s no point in Dave McGurk sitting on my bench not playing when he has been out for so long.

“It’s certainly an option. He knows that option and we will make a decision whether it is going to be the case.

“It’s important that we send him out for the right reasons – to get that sharpness back, and the fitness, and when he comes back he’s capable of getting back into the side.”

While McGurk continues his return, however, midfielder John McReady will be out until Christmas after requiring an operation following the dislocated shoulder he suffered in York’s 0-0 draw with Cheltenham at Bootham Crescent.

“We may be looking at Christmas before he is back,” the City chief admitted. “That’s a blow because he was coming along quite nicely for us. We are going to be without him for a while now.”

Mills is confident a repeat of the opening 35 minutes of Tuesday’s 2-0 defeat against Fleetwood Town, where his side were much the superior without finding the target, will hold them in good stead against Rotherham at Bootham Crescent tomorrow but, despite his delight with the performance, he hasn’t ruled out making changes for the visit of the Millers.

“I thought for 35 minutes we were the best we’ve been,” he reflected. “I take a lot of positives from that. I couldn’t knock my players. If there is a criticism, maybe it’s that we just lost our shape in the second half because we were a goal down and looking to get the equaliser and maybe there’s a little lesson there.

“My players can go and start like they did on Tuesday night against Rotherham and I will have no qualms.

“Let’s go and do the same again. Coming in at half-time it was ‘How the hell are we 1-0 down?’ but we were and that’s football.

“We move on and we get ready for Saturday. I’m still smiling and I want my players to continue to play like that.

Mills added: “I think you always have to look at it (changes). We have won one game in five or six so you have to sometimes look at it and say, ‘Can we change it to try to win a game?’ “Sometimes it is difficult when players are doing well but sometimes you have to make changes and give someone else an opportunity – a different dimension for us. There’s certainly no crisis here. I am enjoying the trip so far after ten games.

“There’s a long way to go and three points against Rotherham would put us back up there.”

Comments(11)

TheBurton says...
12:46pm Fri 5 Oct 12

Would be good to see TY back in the team as before he got injured he was one of our best players. A loan until Christmas would be our best option, preferably to a BSP team.

Egonseth says...
1:07pm Fri 5 Oct 12

Surely it would make more sense to play him the York City first team rather than the disaster-prone liabilities that are currently attempting to play there.

Dave 77 says...
1:16pm Fri 5 Oct 12

We could really do with Dave McGurk fit and playing like he did against Luton in those two playoff semi finals in 2010.

Eric Style says...
1:33pm Fri 5 Oct 12

Ty and Carlisle should be given a chance as a partnership

OLD - HEAD says...
2:21pm Fri 5 Oct 12

Obviously Dave McGurks injuries have been far more serious than we first thought. Reading between the lines of the Managers comments, I dont think we can expect a quick return to the York City first team for him. He will need to play in a highly competative league to try to regain full match fitness. That would probably mean a loan to a Blue Square Premier club at least. We can only hope that Dave will then get back to being the top player that we all know he is. Good luck to him, for he has always been a fans favourite at Bootham Crescent.

yorkviking says...
2:31pm Fri 5 Oct 12

OLD - HEAD wrote:
Obviously Dave McGurks injuries have been far more serious than we first thought. Reading between the lines of the Managers comments, I dont think we can expect a quick return to the York City first team for him. He will need to play in a highly competative league to try to regain full match fitness. That would probably mean a loan to a Blue Square Premier club at least. We can only hope that Dave will then get back to being the top player that we all know he is. Good luck to him, for he has always been a fans favourite at Bootham Crescent.
You're not reading between the lines there are you, you're reading the lines themselves as that is what mills said in the article.

alimount says...
2:38pm Fri 5 Oct 12

Send him to Luton, that's where he wanted to go wasn't it? Then when he comes back he can be grateful he had the option to get out of that hell-hole and didn't make the same foolish mistakes as those before him.

skilly says...
4:20pm Fri 5 Oct 12

Egonseth wrote:
Surely it would make more sense to play him the York City first team rather than the disaster-prone liabilities that are currently attempting to play there.
Well thats a constructive comment! All our centre halfs are liabilities now. Get real

joejamestom says...
5:29pm Fri 5 Oct 12

skilly wrote:
Egonseth wrote:
Surely it would make more sense to play him the York City first team rather than the disaster-prone liabilities that are currently attempting to play there.
Well thats a constructive comment! All our centre halfs are liabilities now. Get real
I can see the disappointment but cannot agree they are liabilities each one has good & bad elements to their game.
Its fairly obvious that Carlisle is a quality defender he reads the game well maybe a tad short on pace but is good in the air.
Doig is not bad all round just a bit short of pace ultimately. Ty is pretty solid when fit generally quick enough decent in the air defending just not likely to chip in with goals.
Smith scores the odd goal has his managers ear, but is error prone at times and has a poor working relationship with Ingham.
Danny P as we have all seen is a good player of the football hence he can be of use further up the field good header of the ball is epically fit too. For most of us we recall that under Foyle a good understanding & partnership formed between Ty & Danny P hence we conceded few goals just did not score a lot drew too many games.
With the current squad I could envisage Danny P & Carlisle as a partnership working out with Ty when back fit & Doig filing in as tiredness 7 injuries force changes. That leaves Smith to be improved & found a role but in GM we trust we have a decent team of footballers available Cmon City!!!

tomycfclad2 says...
9:27pm Fri 5 Oct 12

I've said and said TY and Carlisle as a partnership would be great!

Edsoni says...
11:16pm Fri 5 Oct 12

I think that, injuries permitting, Carlisle is likely a long run in the team through to January.
A returning McGurk might make the bench if Carlisle doesn't extend his contract but I'd be surprised if he returns anywhere near his peak which was probably a year before his injuries.
I hope he proves me wrong and challenges strongly but I think Mills will be looking elsewhere.
I just hope Carlisle signs on for longer.
In a couple of weeks time we should have a decent spine with Kerr's return. Just need someone who can win the midfield aerial ball. Last season Meredith,Parslow and at times Banjo meant that we won many of the battles despite the critics complaining about players out of position. (as if they're incapable of adapting)
Of course they were covering for the loss of Kerr so such an approach may not be necessary. Mills tactical approach is going to be fascinating to watch. We may get the first indications tomorrow but I don't think the jigsaw will be complete quite so soon. I don't think Potts is in the picture but Kearns might be.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree