York City 0, Cheltenham 0 (From York Press)
Get in touch: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting YORK to 80360 or send an email»
Match report: York City 0, Cheltenham 0
11:02am Monday 24th September 2012 in Sport
By Dave Flett, Sports reporter
GARY Mills has equalled his longest run without a victory as York City manager.
The fact that sequence stretches to just four matches, though, illustrates the standards the former European Cup winner has set during close to two years at the Bootham Crescent helm.
To put it into some form of context, Mills’ former Nottingham Forest team-mate Martin O’Neill has now gone 12 games since his last triumph in charge of Sunderland.
A 0-0 home draw against last season’s League Two play-off finalists Cheltenham Town also represented an improvement for the Minstermen, who had been beaten on all four of their previous meetings with the Robins at their North Yorkshire base.
Nevertheless, for a man who classes himself as a winner, Mills will be disappointed with the current series of results, which also includes draws with Chesterfield and Exeter, prior to last week’s defeat to Burton.
A point apiece, in terms of general play and chances created, was probably the right reward for both teams on Saturday although the hosts were left to reflect on the irony of a first League Two clean sheet being achieved on the same day that they failed to score for only the second time in 27 fixtures.
In fact, the Minstermen looked less threatening in the final third of the pitch than at any other stage this term with Ashley Chambers , in particular, doing the best of his work a long way from the visitors’ goal and penalty box.
Devising a method to break down opponents more effectively at a home ground where just two wins have been managed from the last nine fixtures might just hold the key to Mills’ team fulfilling their manager’s ambitions for this campaign.
Prior to Saturday’s contest, the City boss had called on his team to win more second balls than in the 3-1 midweek defeat at Burton and, as if taking that challenge as a personal affront, combative midfielder Jonathan Smith crashed into an early tackle that might have seen his name taken on another day.
On nine minutes, a patient spell of passing, unmatched at any other point in the game, ended with Jason Walker laying the ball off to Paddy McLaughlin, who released Michael Coulson through the right channel.
But Coulson’s drive from a narrow angle was kept out at his near post by Cheltenham ’keeper Scott Brown.
Moments later, though, Michael Ingham produced a smart reflex save after he had a split second to react when Shaun Harrad’s header changed the flight of Chris Zebrowski’s left-wing shot.
Jamal Fyfield then produced a brilliant block as a following-up Russ Penn looked certain to net.
At the other end, Coulson’s dangerous cross into the six-yard box was only cleared as far as McLaughlin on the edge of the penalty area but he lifted a right-footed effort over Brown’s bar.
Walker then tried his luck twice from distance.
With his first attempt, the City striker turned swiftly after receiving a Chris Doig ball to feet and forced Brown into a strong parry from 20 yards.
Then, from further out, he showed admirable confidence to control Lanre Oyebanjo ’s throw with his thigh before hitting a full volley that Brown gathered.
Chris Smith , though, rescued his team on 38 minutes with a terrific sliding tackle on the edge of the penalty box after Jermaine McGlashan had spun inside Fyfield and set off on a rapid charge towards Ingham’s goal.
In first-half stoppage time, Oyebanjo’s blushes were spared when he headed against the bar in front of an empty goal before play was brought back for an earlier foul.
Alan Bennett then booted an edge-of-the-box attempt out of the ground with the last kick of the half.
City reshuffled at the break with Chris Smith replaced due to a hamstring twinge by Lee Bullock as Dan Parslow moved to centre-back.
McLaughlin drove the hosts forward at the start of the second half but his finishing was uncharacteristically wayward, shooting wide on 53 minutes from 15 yards and then firing over the David Longhurst Stand when, had Coulson picked up his head during a promising break, he might have been better advised to pass to Bullock, who had sprinted unopposed into the visitors’ penalty box.
On the hour, McLaughlin then released Jonathan Smith for a clear run on goal but his heavy touch saw the ball roll to Brown.
Oyebanjo also had a 20-yard drive deflected narrowly wide before providing the right-wing free-kick that saw Bullock stab a close-range shot straight at Brown.
Cheltenham’s best opening followed shortly afterwards when McGlashan burst past Fyfield before delivering a low cross that Kaid Mohammed sidefooted against the crossbar from eight yards out with his first touch after replacing Harrad.
Mohammed also headed over after a free-kick from Marlon Pack, who went on to miss the target twice himself with long-range drives late on.
On 90 minutes, Bullock could not divert a diving header on target from Chambers’ cross and, in stoppage-time, hopeful penalty shouts were rejected after the latter stood on the ball and fell to the ground in the box.
The subsequent final whistle signalled only a second goal-less stalemate for City in 43 fixtures.
Mills’ last four-match run without a win, meanwhile, came when last season’s FA Cup exit at the hands of Wrexham was followed by three successive draws.
Match facts
Michael Ingham 7
Displayed remarkable reflexes once more to deny Harrad and did what was required of him otherwise.
Lanre Oyebanjo 7
STAR MAN – strong defensively and also chose the right moments to attack when possible.
Chris Smith 7
Aggressive and unflappable at the back prior to the hamstring problem that saw him substituted at the break.
Chris Doig 7
Grew into the match the longer it went on and formed a solid and dependable second-half partnership with Parslow.
Jamal Fyfield 7
Stuck to his task against a difficult adversary in McGlashan and kept his discipline.
Dan Parslow 7
Made a comfortable transition back to centre-half where he helped team earn first clean sheet.
Jonathan Smith 6
Crashed into his early tackles but could not make most of chance created by McLaughlin.
Paddy McLaughlin 7
Always looked to join in attacks and, while shooting was a little rushed at times, he picked out some good passes
Michael Coulson 6
Started well but not as prominent in a second half when City needed attacking inspiration.
Jason Walker 7
Switched play with confidence, shielded ball expertly and won his team countless free-kicks.
Ashley Chambers 6
Grafted hard for the team but his presence was needed further up the pitch to unsettle the visitors' defence.
Subs: Lee Bullock 7 – steady (for C Smith, 46), John McReady (for J Smith, 64, Matty Blair (for McReady, 75). Not used: Paul Musselwhite , Oli Johnson, Jon Challinor, Charlie Taylor.
Cheltenham
cott Brown, Sido Jombati, Alan Bennett, Steve Elliott, Billy Jones, Marlon Pack, Darren Carter (Sam Deering, 78), Jermaine McGlashan (Jeff Goulding, 89), Russell Penn, Chris Zebrowski, Shaun Harrad (Kaid Mohammed, 73). Subs not used: Keith Lowe, Harry Hooman, Darryl Duffy, Connor Roberts.
Star man: Alan Bennett – marshalled his back-line well.
Referee: Scott Mathieson (Stockport) Rating: 6/10 A little on the lenient side in the first half.
Booked: Jombati 51, Fyfield 82, McLaughlin 86.
Sent off: None.
Attendance: 3,477 (196 away fans).
Shots on target: City 4, Cheltenham 5.
Shots off target: City 6, Cheltenham 7.
Corners: City 5, Cheltenham 1.
Fouls conceded: City 16, Cheltenham 12.
Offsides: City 0, Cheltenham 3.
Comments(15)
Southern Exile
says...
1:55pm Mon 24 Sep 12
yorkiemike
says...
2:41pm Mon 24 Sep 12
I do think GM has to find a way to start with Matty Blair.Not easy but maybe Walker, Coulson or Chambers need to start on the bench for a while.
Mid table not bad and we`ve only lost two games.Teams near the top have lost two games as well.
Apart from Wycombe and 2nd half at Burton we`ve shown we can match teams so far.
andy jamo
says...
3:46pm Mon 24 Sep 12
Southern Exile
says...
4:07pm Mon 24 Sep 12
lifelong
says...
6:27pm Mon 24 Sep 12
YorkCityLuke
says...
6:34pm Mon 24 Sep 12
lifelong wrote:Can't agree with your first point - I thought Fyfield stood out too - but your point about corners is spot on in my opinion. The actual corner-taking seems to have improved since last year, as fewer of the balls are simply being caught by the keeper, but as you said, too many are fielded straight out by the defense. Our lot are too short to make use of high corners. I was actually hoping we'd start making use of short corners towards the end of the game on saturday too.
Mills singled Fyfield out for special mention but apart from a brilliant goal saving block he struggled to contain attacks down the right. The gaps left by Meredith and Gibson are still causes for concern. We are also struggling to establish a platform in midfield, an area where we were so dominant last year. I appreciate we have stepped up a league in class and I just hope that when Scott Kerr is available he will be the difference, City are no longer a threat at corners and am I alone in wishing for more imagination in wanting to see a development of short corners to introduce more variety. We just don't have the height. I don't want to be too critical however because I would have taken 10 points from a start of 8 games which only includes a couple of defeats, the opening game of which included a deflection and a speculative punt from 35 yds!
joejamestom
says...
8:43pm Mon 24 Sep 12
YorkCityLuke wrote:Very much agree with your points about corners in some of our games where we have won many corners getting down the sides have been a waste of time as they so rarely result in goals.
lifelong wrote:Can't agree with your first point - I thought Fyfield stood out too - but your point about corners is spot on in my opinion. The actual corner-taking seems to have improved since last year, as fewer of the balls are simply being caught by the keeper, but as you said, too many are fielded straight out by the defense. Our lot are too short to make use of high corners. I was actually hoping we'd start making use of short corners towards the end of the game on saturday too.
Mills singled Fyfield out for special mention but apart from a brilliant goal saving block he struggled to contain attacks down the right. The gaps left by Meredith and Gibson are still causes for concern. We are also struggling to establish a platform in midfield, an area where we were so dominant last year. I appreciate we have stepped up a league in class and I just hope that when Scott Kerr is available he will be the difference, City are no longer a threat at corners and am I alone in wishing for more imagination in wanting to see a development of short corners to introduce more variety. We just don't have the height. I don't want to be too critical however because I would have taken 10 points from a start of 8 games which only includes a couple of defeats, the opening game of which included a deflection and a speculative punt from 35 yds!
With a team hardly bursting with giants the lack of variety surely must make our opponents very happy indeed.
Concerning Fyfield I thought he did as well as any of our defenders could against McGlashan who was their MOTM for me & possibly the best player on the park.
The first half was very competitive with neither side having the upper hand.
Though they did seem a shade sharper in front of goal. For the second half we seemed clearly to have the upper hand just lacking that little sharpness in front of goal to kill off Cheltnham, a big point possibly not, two points lost after playing so well in the second half but at least a clean sheet which in the end we need as we have looked unimpressive defending.
Work in progress for GM & co lets try Dan P + Carlisle as a CB combo at some point as when Scott Kerr comes back we will improve in mid field.
Cmon City!! we played some great stuff at times on Sat keep on playing as we did in the second half the results will come.
openallhours
says...
9:54pm Mon 24 Sep 12
himsworthsleftfoot
says...
10:11pm Mon 24 Sep 12
yorkiemike wrote:Would agree with the Blair point - his continued absence from the starting lineup seems strange. Anyone know if anything has gone on behind the scenes?
Yes,no need to panic.Disappointing not to win but a draw was fair.
I do think GM has to find a way to start with Matty Blair.Not easy but maybe Walker, Coulson or Chambers need to start on the bench for a while.
Mid table not bad and we`ve only lost two games.Teams near the top have lost two games as well.
Apart from Wycombe and 2nd half at Burton we`ve shown we can match teams so far.
uhtred
says...
9:32am Tue 25 Sep 12
No slight on Chambers but a bit of squad rotation necessary as they are both very good players who play in simialr roles. Blair cannot fill the Walker role and Coulson has different skills to Blair and Chambers. Agree with the philosophy of not changing a winning team but we are not such a team at the moment.
skilly
says...
12:07pm Tue 25 Sep 12
himsworthsleftfoot wrote:I don't think its strange Blair has not started. Looking for reasons behind the scenes does my head in! The front 3 of Walker, Coulson & Chambers have done really well and that is backed up with the goals made and scored by these 3. Blair was not fit at the beginning of the season after picking up an injury and so far he hasn't set the game alight when coming on as a sub (including his complete air-shot on saturday). His time will come and I am sure he will grab it. Its good that the team has kept him on the bench so far, very healthy competition. GM knows what he is doing.
yorkiemike wrote: Yes,no need to panic.Disappointing not to win but a draw was fair. I do think GM has to find a way to start with Matty Blair.Not easy but maybe Walker, Coulson or Chambers need to start on the bench for a while. Mid table not bad and we`ve only lost two games.Teams near the top have lost two games as well. Apart from Wycombe and 2nd half at Burton we`ve shown we can match teams so far.Would agree with the Blair point - his continued absence from the starting lineup seems strange. Anyone know if anything has gone on behind the scenes?
Realfootballfan1
says...
5:42pm Tue 25 Sep 12
YorkCityLuke
says...
6:33pm Tue 25 Sep 12
Realfootballfan1 wrote:Interesting idea, he's certainly tall enough to be useful with set pieces. Fairly good return of goals too, but he's getting on a little bit. From browsing his wikipedia page, he also seems to have failed to make an impression at previous clubs at our level.
As a point of debate, Anthony Elding has put in a transfer request at Grimsby, now he may be worth a gamble. I remember him as one of the better centre forwards in the BSP last season, one of those that gets in where it hurts and has a good turn of pace. He would also be a good foil for walker, and could maybe be the answer up front for set pieces.
skilly
says...
6:43pm Tue 25 Sep 12
YorkCityLuke wrote:Grimsby fans don't want him, his form has been poor, we don't want him either
Realfootballfan1 wrote: As a point of debate, Anthony Elding has put in a transfer request at Grimsby, now he may be worth a gamble. I remember him as one of the better centre forwards in the BSP last season, one of those that gets in where it hurts and has a good turn of pace. He would also be a good foil for walker, and could maybe be the answer up front for set pieces.Interesting idea, he's certainly tall enough to be useful with set pieces. Fairly good return of goals too, but he's getting on a little bit. From browsing his wikipedia page, he also seems to have failed to make an impression at previous clubs at our level.

YorkCityLuke says...
12:32pm Mon 24 Sep 12
Result on the whole was pretty good though, we were playing the play-off runners up from last year and managed to keep a clean sheet, a couple of wins and we'll be back in the play-offs.