Israel actions 'disproportionate'

Smoke rises after Israeli missile strikes hit the northern Gaza Strip (AP)

Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg has criticised Israel's bombardment of the Gaza Strip

First published in Sport © by

Israel's bombardment of the Gaza Strip in retaliation for militant rocket attacks on its territory amounts to a "deliberately disproportionate form of collective punishment", Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg has said.

Mr Clegg urged the Israeli government to stop military strikes on the densely-populated Palestinian enclave, where officials say the death toll from the 10-day battle has reached 222, with 1,670 injured. One Israeli civilian has also died in the conflict.

Israel and Gaza's Hamas leadership have agreed a five-hour United Nations-brokered humanitarian pause in the fighting, which began at 10am local time (8am UK time) to allow Palestinian families to restock on food, water and other necessities.

Speaking on LBC radio, Mr Clegg urged both sides to build on the ceasefire to prevent further deaths and a continuation of what he described as "unimaginable human suffering" in Gaza.

Prime Minister David Cameron has not condemned Israel's military action, while his official spokesman has said that the key to resolving the conflict is for Hamas to stop firing rockets into Israel.

Mr Cameron signed up to a European Union statement last night which called on both sides to "de-escalate the situation, to end the violence, to end the suffering of the civilian populations notably by allowing access to humanitarian assistance, and return to calm".

The EU "deeply deplores the loss of innocent lives and the high number of wounded civilians in the Gaza Strip as a result of Israeli military operations and is deeply concerned about the rapid and dramatic deterioration of the humanitarian situation," the statement said.

But the Deputy Prime Minister went much further by saying: "I have to say now that the Israeli response appears to be deliberately disproportionate. It is amounting now to a disproportionate form of collective punishment. It is leading to a humanitarian crisis in Gaza which is just unacceptable.

"I would really now call on the Israeli government to stop. They have made their point."

Mr Clegg added: "Regardless of which side you are on in this ancient bloody conflict, no-one can feel indifferent to the spectacle of this overcrowded, desperate sliver of land in Gaza, where so many thousands of people are suffering.

"I will always defend Israel's right to respond and to defend itself in the face of violence that aims to terrorise Israeli citizens. I have spoken out repeatedly about Israel's very legitimate demands that Hamas and others recognise Israel's right to exist, and to exist peacefully within its own borders and provide security to its own citizens."

He said: "It is not in the long run in Israel's own interest to see this festering humanitarian crisis get ever worse in Gaza because all it does in the long run is incubate the next generation of violent terrorists who want to harm Israel.

"Today we have a glimmer of hope that a five-hour ceasefire has been entered into by both sides and my plea to both sides is please build on that because further deaths and more violence begetting more violence is not in anybody's interests and is not going to help deliver the only way in which Israelis are going to be able to live in peace in the long run, which is a negotiated two-state peace settlement."

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:43pm Thu 17 Jul 14

welshmen says...

Shut up you stupid no mark....get your Green bandana on, take your kids to Gazza and Hamas HQ, they'll teach your kids age 5-10 how to kill Jews, and chant their hatred for them, and until that hatred is naturalised nothing will change, it's the same here with the Muslim hate Preachers, get rid of the haters....if you can't, and the Muslims let them Preach then the Religion needs to go, we don't want a Hamas Gazza in our Country....
Shut up you stupid no mark....get your Green bandana on, take your kids to Gazza and Hamas HQ, they'll teach your kids age 5-10 how to kill Jews, and chant their hatred for them, and until that hatred is naturalised nothing will change, it's the same here with the Muslim hate Preachers, get rid of the haters....if you can't, and the Muslims let them Preach then the Religion needs to go, we don't want a Hamas Gazza in our Country.... welshmen
  • Score: -5

11:42am Fri 18 Jul 14

DavidHaifa says...

After reading the comments made by Nick Clegg regarding the Gaza conflict, I am, as ever, amazed at how shallow and ill-informed our politicians are.

He accuses Israel of “collective punishment” and a “deliberate lack of proportionality”, virtually suggesting that Israel is murdering Palestinian civilians.

Is he not aware of the over 3,000 rockets and mortars deliberately fired by Hamas at civilian targets in Israel (perhaps Mr. Clegg thinks they were set off accidentally), causing over 5,000,000 Israelis to rush to air raid shelters, collective punishment if ever I’ve heard of it.?

Thankfully, the Israeli defense systems have kept the loss of life down to single figures. Perhaps Mr. Clegg would have preferred more Israeli deaths, so as to “even the balance”, and to permit him to shed yet more crocodile tears.

On reflection, Nick Clegg is probably not a bad person, but rather one who, as we would have said when I was a lad growing up in Nottingham, “opens his mouth and lets his stomach rumble”.

May I respectfully suggest that next time he takes a Rennie’s first.

Yours sincerely,

David Wiseman


Haifa
After reading the comments made by Nick Clegg regarding the Gaza conflict, I am, as ever, amazed at how shallow and ill-informed our politicians are. He accuses Israel of “collective punishment” and a “deliberate lack of proportionality”, virtually suggesting that Israel is murdering Palestinian civilians. Is he not aware of the over 3,000 rockets and mortars deliberately fired by Hamas at civilian targets in Israel (perhaps Mr. Clegg thinks they were set off accidentally), causing over 5,000,000 Israelis to rush to air raid shelters, collective punishment if ever I’ve heard of it.? Thankfully, the Israeli defense systems have kept the loss of life down to single figures. Perhaps Mr. Clegg would have preferred more Israeli deaths, so as to “even the balance”, and to permit him to shed yet more crocodile tears. On reflection, Nick Clegg is probably not a bad person, but rather one who, as we would have said when I was a lad growing up in Nottingham, “opens his mouth and lets his stomach rumble”. May I respectfully suggest that next time he takes a Rennie’s first. Yours sincerely, David Wiseman Haifa DavidHaifa
  • Score: -4
Post a comment

Remember you are personally responsible for what you post on this site and must abide by our site terms. Do not post anything that is false, abusive or malicious. If you wish to complain, please use the ‘report this post’ link.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree