News RSS Feed


Cross-party support to make York a plastic-bag-free city

11:59am Friday 2nd May 2008

Comments (25)   Have your say »

By Mark Stead »

POLITICIANS from all parties are putting aside their traditional rivalries to back a common cause - thwarting the plague of plastic bags.

Members of the Liberal Democrat, Labour and Conservative groups in York have combined to raise the pressure on shops in an attempt to bring an end to the sight of discarded carrier bags blighting the city and harming the environment.

The next salvo in the campaign will be fired next week when York's two Conservative parliamentary candidates, Julian Sturdy and Susan Wade, and a team of young helpers launch a drive to encourage businesses to offer customers traditional baskets and shopping bags rather than the plastic variety.

Shoppers who hand over their carrier bags for recycling on Saturday, May 10, in Parliament Street will receive 1,000 free lightweight cotton bags in a swap which the Tories hope will make them shun the plastic option.

Meanwhile, a petition of more than 1,000 signatures collected by City of York Council's Labour group has been presented to Parliament by the city's MP, Hugh Bayley, calling for York to be made a plastic bag-free city.

"Heavy winds earlier in the spring saw an appalling number of plastic bags being blown from landfill sites and festooning trees and hedgerows in York," said Mr Sturdy.

"It really is time to do something about it and we felt that now is the time to make a stand in York. We hope to enlist the support of market traders, retailers and charity shops, many of whom have already begun the move away from plastic to more sustainable options for customers."

Labour's "Ban The Bag" petition has now been sent to the Government for a response and Coun Ruth Potter, the York party's shadow spokesperson for neighbourhood services who presented it to Mr Bayley, said: "The petition to ban or tax single-use plastic bags has really engaged people and surveys indicate the vast majority regard them as unnecessary.

"I'm really pleased York's MP has made this commitment, which demonstrates the seriousness with which he takes the issue of reducing environmental damage."

The council's ruling Liberal Democrat faction has also vowed to help combat the use of carrier bags. Executive member for neighbourhood services Andrew Waller said: "Since bringing in the smart jute Recycle for York' bag, the council has provided 5,000 of these. With all the other types of reusable bags being sold by shops across the city, tens of thousands of York residents will have bought them for regular use. I meet regularly with supermarket chains to express residents' concerns, not just restricted to plastic bags, but all the other packaging which customers end up with.

"Residents are very switched on to this and want to do more, and sorting out plastic bags is just part of the long-term solution."

Your Say YourPress

Brian, york says...
9:44pm Sat 3 May 08

Iam not convinced cyc is as commited to recycle as they claim,its all well and good talking to supermarkets and doing photo shoots,every thursday when I am in town I see a cyc bin wagon collecting black bin bags off shops, and large amounts of cardboard is just thrown in with the bags heading straight for lanfill,as this is already seperated it could easily be put into a vehicle for recycling ,does any councillors know why this is the case,

ennoch, York says...
8:32pm Sat 3 May 08

Sadly Mike C the traditional green grocer has gone the way of the dragon.

Originally the plastic bag was a form of advertising as well as the "We're so convenient, you don't need to remember a bag".
Consumers are charged for these bags, indirectly. As cynic said they are just a small part of the whole packaging problem. Why don't supermarkets invest some of the billion pounds profit into resolving the problem instead of building token wind poles?

Mike C, york says...
7:38pm Sat 3 May 08

lastword morris: you say PROVIDE the desired bag - why is that someone else's job? I (try to remember to) take bags with me, as was universally done before the introduction of the hated plastic carrier. I served in a greengrocery during decimalisation (just after medieval times for you youngsters), and everybody just had their own shopping bags, including the ingenious string bags you can't get any more.

John, says...
5:30pm Sat 3 May 08

Plastic carrier bags are easily reused for shopping , bin bags, dog waste etc.The main problem is the City Council's inability to collect and recycle other plastics packaging ; film,food containers, bubble wrap and foam polystyrene ( only plastic bottles are recycled) .All this has to go into land fill as the CYC either cannot separate or find a market for this waste.These light weight are easily dispersed over the landscape surrounding the tips.There needs to be more technical input into this problem and less Party Politics !

lastword morris, Haxby Rd says...
11:21am Sat 3 May 08

ennoch wrote:
The sneers and dirty looks from cashiers have already started in some supermarkets! Please don't make me out as a leper because your billion pound profit busting bosses have'nt provided me with a free eco alternative!
yeah.....PROVIDE the desired bag for us to use, people use what is available and provided...

lastword morris, Haxby Rd says...
11:18am Sat 3 May 08

Terry Raspberry wrote:
How about a plastic-Terry free city??
no....I could not bear it

Bryter, YO62 says...
8:12am Sat 3 May 08

the creation of plastic bags actually has been battling global warming

Plastic bags have been reducing solar activity? How so?

Zaphrentites, York says...
8:14pm Fri 2 May 08

Cynic wrote:
ennoch wrote: The sneers and dirty looks from cashiers have already started in some supermarkets! Please don't make me out as a leper because your billion pound profit busting bosses have'nt provided me with a free eco alternative!
And after all, plastic bags are only a small part of the problem. What about the vast amounts of excess packaging that everything comes in?
That would involve the Government treading on the toes of big business and manufacturers which would be a break from their traditional stream of dictat directed at the general public.

Brandon, York says...
7:50pm Fri 2 May 08

Bring it on, I hate the things. I have noticed it is the 'more mature' members of the population who seem to make the most effort re-using bags, good on them. But before the excuses start rolling in we have 3 young cildren and both have full time jobs and we still manage without plastic bags 99% of the time.

ChrisGS1982, York says...
6:31pm Fri 2 May 08

ennoch wrote:
The sneers and dirty looks from cashiers have already started in some supermarkets! Please don't make me out as a leper because your billion pound profit busting bosses have'nt provided me with a free eco alternative!
Iv have noticed that too.

Silver, York says...
6:23pm Fri 2 May 08

Why is everyone against plastic bags, they are created to stop creating waste, production of plastic bags is used when using oil to create other things the remains of the oil to create whatever product are used to create plastic bags so the creation of plastic bags actually has been battling global warming. Ok I agree people let them loose but couldn't we just be responsible and recycle them and not just let them fly around like mature adults? Or am I alone in thinking that we could have the authority asking us to behave like adults is too much?

Cynic, York says...
5:38pm Fri 2 May 08

ennoch wrote:
The sneers and dirty looks from cashiers have already started in some supermarkets! Please don't make me out as a leper because your billion pound profit busting bosses have'nt provided me with a free eco alternative!
And after all, plastic bags are only a small part of the problem. What about the vast amounts of excess packaging that everything comes in?

ennoch, York says...
4:59pm Fri 2 May 08

The sneers and dirty looks from cashiers have already started in some supermarkets!

Please don't make me out as a leper because your billion pound profit busting bosses have'nt provided me with a free eco alternative!

Mike C, york says...
4:32pm Fri 2 May 08

Being an old geezer, I can remember life before "free" plastic carrier bags. They are literally a blot on the landscape among other drawbacks, and having to buy a relatively few binbags is a small price to pay for stopping the torrent. Why are people so resistant to taking a bit of trouble? Carrier bags first, then let's follow the lead of places that have got to grips with one-trip plastic bottles. I experienced one of several methods in the US, where machines in supermarkets take in bottles, scan the barcodes, and give coins in return.

Yorkenstein, York says...
3:09pm Fri 2 May 08

andy2007 wrote:
Sorry, but no tree-hugger is going to tell me I cant use plastic carry bags. They make great bin liners. I think we just need to educate people to reuse them more.
agree. this just shifts the problem elsewhere - people will then buy plasic bags to line their bins, and no eco-cotton bag can replace that without you getting bin-juice on your feet.
true eco-warriors should be more inventive before banning. Give the people a better alternative to switch to.

Terry Raspberry, York says...
2:50pm Fri 2 May 08

How about a plastic-Terry free city??

GoodramgateTerrier, York says...
2:30pm Fri 2 May 08

SilverSurfer wrote:
What will the beggars and drunks wear on their feet to keep them dry if we get rid of palstic bags??
1,000 free lightweight cotton bags it would seem! Mind you, cool in the summer, warm in the winter, cotton is a very useful material...dont be surprised to see Karen Bulmer trying to swap her blanket for one now the warmer weather is here!

X, At Work says...
2:18pm Fri 2 May 08

instead of picking on us (the consumer) they should be picking on the people who make the bags in the first place.

If it was illegal to make bags that were not envoronmentaly friendly then they would be forced to make eco friendly bags and then we would use eco friendly bags.
Why the bags are still there we will use them.

SilverSurfer, Surfing says...
2:11pm Fri 2 May 08

What will the beggars and drunks wear on their feet to keep them dry if we get rid of palstic bags??

lastword morris, Haxby Rd says...
1:59pm Fri 2 May 08

the bags need to be 100 per cent recyclable...maybe a very small charge for them...

Mike Oxhuge, Have a look says...
1:10pm Fri 2 May 08

It doesn't matter to me anyway, I cannot afford to buy food anymore because of the increase in council tax. So I suppose they've stopped me using carrier bags anyway.

marc, says...
1:08pm Fri 2 May 08

The supermarkets and convenience stores used to charge for carrier bags up until the mid 80s.

Peter, york says...
12:43pm Fri 2 May 08

How about getting the supermarkets to bring back the trolleys that take plastic shopping boxes which were around a few years ago. We still have half a dozen boxes which we are now unable to use.

petethefeet, York says...
12:24pm Fri 2 May 08

If supermarkets charge 10p for each bag, people will soon learn to bring their own bags.

andy2007, york says...
12:21pm Fri 2 May 08

Sorry, but no tree-hugger is going to tell me I cant use plastic carry bags. They make great bin liners. I think we just need to educate people to reuse them more.

Your sayYourPress

Register for a FREE York Press account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in to continue.

Councillor Ruth Potter hands over the Ban The Bag petition to York MP Hugh Bayley Councillor Ruth Potter hands over the Ban The Bag petition to York MP Hugh Bayley

Hot Jobs

Your Local Services


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »