Sorted RSS Feed


York woman ‘barred from buses’

Helen Barrow, who uses buses to get to voluntary jobs in York. Picture: David Harrison Helen Barrow, who uses buses to get to voluntary jobs in York. Picture: David Harrison

A WHEELCHAIR user says she is being stopped from travelling on buses in York because drivers are refusing to use the ramps on the grounds of health and safety.

Helen Barrow, 30, of Eastfield Crescent, Badger Hill, has dystonia, a chronic neurological condition that causes painful spasms and muscle contractions.

Miss Barrow, who is due to get married in two months, has an electric wheelchair, but has to travel several miles from her home to Brunswick Organic Nursery in Bishopthorpe, the Priory Centre and Age Concern, where she works as a volunteer.

But drivers of the bendy buses are refusing her entry on the grounds of health and safety, because they say the ramps are too heavy and they need a hook to lift them safely, which they have not yet been provided with.

She says the only alternative is for her to try to jump the gap in her wheelchair – not a practical option as its top speed is only 4mph.

In fact, it is only due to the kindness of other passengers that she has not been left stranded at bus stops.

She said: “Facing the world as a recent wheelchair user isn’t easy, and it takes time to build confidence. The general difficulty of getting on and off buses and trains has taken some getting used to, but using public transport has previously enabled me to gain some independence back.

“However, being repeatedly refused access to a bus while everyone else in the queue jostles by you because a hook is needed to lift a ramp down each time leaves me more demoralised, embarrassed and invisible, hampering my getting home, getting to work or meeting friends.”

She said First in York had previously assured her that drivers would now be able to use the ramp, but despite these assurances she said they were still refusing her entry.

But following the intervention of The Press, First promised there would be no problem in the future and, as of first thing today, all buses would be fitted with the necessary hooks. David Philips, service delivery director for First in York, said: “We acknowledge the fact that Helen Barrow has encountered recent problems with our Park&Ride service and have apologised directly for the inconvenience this has caused.

“The issues raised related to concerns over the health and safety of our drivers with regard to lowering the ramps on our articulated vehicles to enable wheelchair access.

“However, this issue has now been resolved and we will be contacting Helen Barrow in person to assure her and all customers that our park and ride services are fully accessible to wheelchair users.”

Comments(9)

marc says...
4:01pm Fri 3 Apr 09

Typical First york, more like it would delay the service too much.

suggie says...
4:05pm Fri 3 Apr 09

Agreed! They just can't be bothered to get out of their seats and help someone. Most of them are ignorant, miserable s0ds anyway!

petethefeet says...
4:28pm Fri 3 Apr 09

Bit of a sensationalist headline. Having said that, some picky issue needed unjamming and, in this case, Helen was right in coming to the Press and embarrassing First York.

topumpire1 says...
4:52pm Fri 3 Apr 09

All FY want is PROFIT, & all drivers want is their pay at the end of the day, what they & FY should be doing is SERVING the city & their customers - HELPING them whenever & wherever possible. It is no good having these kneeling buses if the gap is too great for wheelchairs! but why has no one "invented" the automatic (rammed?) ramop/ extension, then drivers ccould just flick a switch! - too easy?

chillout says...
5:33pm Fri 3 Apr 09

suggie wrote:
Agreed! They just can't be bothered to get out of their seats and help someone. Most of them are ignorant, miserable s0ds anyway!
no, most of arent miserable sods. i have made many friends thru helping several wheelchair users in the york/acomb area. i can be bothered - all the time !!!!

chillout says...
5:39pm Fri 3 Apr 09

marc wrote:
Typical First york, more like it would delay the service too much.
no, the 8 service is a good service, it wouldnt delay it at all. even if it did delay it a tad it would have been worth it. :-)

RebeccaOfSunnyBrook says...
6:43pm Fri 3 Apr 09

If the bus is defective then it ought to be returned to the depot.
.
It is unfair to only let people walk on the bus when some people need to ride onto the bus.
.
Hitler did this sort of thing and it is why Britain fought the second world war.
.
Shame !

hebwearmouth says...
9:24pm Sat 4 Apr 09

Hello

I thought commenters may be interested to know that I once again attempted to board a route 8 First Park & Ride, and although I was allowed to board it was grudgingly and the driver was complaining that the buses were in fact NOT yet equipped with the hooks (despite the Service Delivery Director's statement in this article) and that a driver has been injured lifting such a ramp.
While I do appreciate the driver's predicament, he was both surly and quite rude and I was in no uncertain terms made to understand that we were putting him out of his way. If the buses aren't suitable for reasons of health and safety, then perhaps this means they shouldn't be operating these routes rather than making myself and I presume others in a similar situation feel even more awkward for needing assistance than we already do. I only attempted this bus due to assurances from First that (once again) this issue had been resolved.

Helen Barrow

hebwearmouth says...
10:25pm Mon 6 Apr 09

After the rude and arrogant diver with still no hook on Saturday, this morning i eventually was able to use the number 8 bendy bus as the driver used the hook to pull the ramp down. I hope this continues and the bendy bus becomes accessible to us all.

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree