Taxi driver blames ‘faulty heater’ for shattered windscreen but car manufacturer insists vehicle is not responsible

York taxi driver Bose Thomas peers through his shattered rear window York taxi driver Bose Thomas peers through his shattered rear window

A TAXI driver from York is in a row with a car manufacturer because he said the rear windscreen of his new Toyota shattered unexpectedly while he was carrying a customer.

Bose Thomas, from Clifton Green, blames a faulty rear windscreen heater for the shattered glass, though Toyota said it had no record of similar complaints in the UK about its Prius range of cars.

Mr Thomas, 38, who drives for 659 Cars, said the incident happened at 4.20am on Friday after his passenger had stopped to use a cash machine at the Tesco store at Askham Bar.

He said: “There was a big bang and the glass smashed. The customer was frightened and wondered what was happening. I got out and looked around and the area was completely empty.”

Mr Bose bought the Prius in December and said since then the car had suffered a smashed wing mirror and also a shattered side window after a passenger closed the door.

“On Friday morning the temperature had come down 10C in York,” he said. “Then the car got foggy inside and I switched on the heating system then two or three minutes later it (the window) exploded.”

He said the car dealer where he bought the vehicle had blamed it on a stone chip and told him to claim for repairs through his insurance company, which he has now done, though he is still in dispute with Toyota.

A spokesman from Toyota’s head office said: “We were very sorry to learn of the damage sustained to Mr Thomas’s car.

“We do not believe that a manufacturing defect was the cause of the breakage to the rear window glass which means that Mr Thomas’s car will be repaired under the terms of his car insurance policy.

“Every effort has been made to minimise the inconvenience caused to Mr Thomas as a result of this incident and ensure the vehicle is repaired as quickly as possible.”

Comments(16)

NoNewsIsGoodNews says...
9:15am Thu 9 Aug 12

Is this news worthy?

TONY THE TORCHE says...
9:35am Thu 9 Aug 12

Has anyone seen "curry and Chips"?

razor08 says...
10:35am Thu 9 Aug 12

Startling news in the Press 'Taxi has passenger'

Buzz Light-year says...
12:35pm Thu 9 Aug 12

As usual, it's never the taxi driver's fault.

again says...
12:47pm Thu 9 Aug 12

Good news about catching all those anti-social speeding motorists. More power to their elbow, I say..

Not sure why readers need to comment about a taxi driver's rear window, especially as no cyclists have been accused. Yet.

Viper_7 says...
3:29pm Thu 9 Aug 12

Whilst not with a Toyota, I've also have the rear window "explode" when turning on the rear demister.
Goes with a helluva bang.
All replaced for £50 under the glazing over.
Always tricky in this kinda of situation, as to wether it's a design/manufacturing defect or simply faulted. This kind of fault is not really "wear and tear" and should be guaranteed to last for 'x' amount of time. Just like with all electrical goods, under EU law manufactures must cover the cost if it faults within 10 years.
I would possibly argue the same with motoring manufacturers. These parts should be designed to be fit for purpose; if it faults, should be covered by the manufacturer.

chucky1977 says...
6:03pm Thu 9 Aug 12

I have to say that, although I do not find this story particularly news worthy, as a Prius driver myself for many years, I have never had any problems with my car or the garage.

luckyiceblue says...
7:13pm Thu 9 Aug 12

Why is this in the paper. I can not believe this gets a more prominant position than some more important stories in your paper.
Pathetic story that I do not want to read about thanks

luckyiceblue says...
7:15pm Thu 9 Aug 12

Quite clearly this fizzy2000 has issues
Oh and his friend above viper/mate

Frogmanz123 says...
7:16am Fri 10 Aug 12

Bl##dy shut my boot on luggage I did

Pete the Brickie says...
7:39am Fri 10 Aug 12



Then the car got foggy inside



Whilst the Prious is an intelligent, highly advanced hybrid car the blokes story falls apart here as it simply lacks the physical ability or language to make a person get inside it which is of course the stuff of Knight Rider.

To add to that "Foggy" is a fictional character from the long running TV series Last of the Summer Wine and the actor Brian Wildewho played the amiable buffoon is dead and could not have been involved in this mystery.

I did however watch an American programme involving four meddling kids and a talking great dane who might be able to offer Mr Thomas some help in solving it.

chainguide says...
9:39am Fri 10 Aug 12

Slow news day? or so i thought until i realised it's the same driver that forced my mate to pay for the wing mirror or he would have him arrested! all he did was shut the door and the wing mirror fell off,it looked like it had already been smashed but could'nt say either way.he phoned toyota and paid for it but was £75 cheaper than the driver had said when demanding to be paid directly! MOST IMPORTANTLY,the person who dealt with it was initially under the impression that the taxi driver was trying to claim the wing mirror under warranty so did'nt take payment there and then but called back later.

Pete the Brickie says...
3:45pm Fri 10 Aug 12

chainguide wrote:
Slow news day? or so i thought until i realised it's the same driver that forced my mate to pay for the wing mirror or he would have him arrested! all he did was shut the door and the wing mirror fell off,it looked like it had already been smashed but could'nt say either way.he phoned toyota and paid for it but was £75 cheaper than the driver had said when demanding to be paid directly! MOST IMPORTANTLY,the person who dealt with it was initially under the impression that the taxi driver was trying to claim the wing mirror under warranty so did'nt take payment there and then but called back later.
Your friend should have asked the driver for a receipt for his payment and the old mirror, then told the driver he was giving both to the provider of his all risks household insurance to prove payment, then advised him his insurer would be checking the mirror to prove how the damage was caused. I use this tactic with false small claims for damaged "Armani" clothing which this sort claim was caused by my workforce from time to time, it never fails they always back down.

In this case I'd check with the garage to see if they still have the damaged mirror and ask the police to look into it, they will be able to check how the damage was most likely caused and however it happened unless your friend deliberately smashed it the money was obtained from him by menaces which some might call blackmail and should be returned in my opinion.

matroom says...
2:26am Tue 14 Aug 12

Its bigger news that yorks finally got an asain taxi driver !!!

Gary Gilmores Eyes says...
8:45am Tue 14 Aug 12

The real backstory is the that most people believe the propaganda that the Toyota Prius is good for the environment!

My Toyota diesel does almost as many miles per gallon but has not got a leased battery inside that has expensive/exotic minerals mined with child and slave labour in 3rd world countries like Chad/CFA/Niger, then flown out of the country to be processed into an 'eco' battery to enabole some people to feel less guilty about driving a car.

Don't believe the hype

Parris Boyd says...
2:18pm Tue 14 Aug 12

Toyota will deny anything. Learned my lesson about 'em when the engine disintegrated in my MR2 Spyder. I've been blogging about the Recall King for quite some time at http://www.uc2.blogs
pot.com

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree