Jamie Inglis funding blow

Jamie Inglis and his sister, Poppy, wear bed pans as hats as they share a joke during a hospital visit. But Jamie’s father has criticised the NHS’s decision not to fund the next stage of his son’s treatment. Jamie Inglis and his sister, Poppy, wear bed pans as hats as they share a joke during a hospital visit. But Jamie’s father has criticised the NHS’s decision not to fund the next stage of his son’s treatment.

THE family of a courageous little boy due to have potentially life- saving cancer treatment in Germany have been refused any NHS funding.

Six-year-old Jamie Inglis has a 75 per cent chance of survival if he successfully goes through a clinical trial in Germany, Jamie’s oncologist at Leeds General Infirmary, a neuroblastoma expert, has told NHS North Yorkshire and York .

His cancer is so aggressive that treatment in the UK is inadequate and will only prolong his life for months.

But the health authority has told the family, who will have to raise £250,000 to pay for the treatment, that there is insufficient evidence to suggest it will work.

They have also been told that it is not considered financially economical to spend money on one child, the family said.

Jamie’s dad, John, said: “We feel let down by the system. This treatment is coming in next year on the NHS and has clearly been advocated by the NHS.

“The local hospitals have been amazing but do not have adequate means to help.”

Alison Moy, chief executive of the Neuroblastoma Alliance, said: “We know high-risk neuroblastoma is a difficult cancer to treat successfully, but at the moment, parents see a system that gives up on their children too soon, whilst there should still be hope. We are incredibly disappointed that Jamie’s treatment will not be funded by the NHS, but we will work as hard as possible to help Jamie’s family raise the funds they need to get Jamie to Germany for this treatment, which is showing extremely promising results.”

Jamie is due to go to Germany for the treatment on August 20. A fundraising campaign, which has now attracted national attention, has so far raised over £71,000.

The Lord Deramore’s Primary School pupil has recently completed weeks of radiotherapy to prepare him for the treatment and yesterday completed a five-day spell of chemotherapy. Dr David Geddes, medical director for NHS North Yorkshire and York said its individual funding panel considered whether to fund treatments not routinely commissioned. He said: “We have a responsibility to ensure that we provide the best possible healthcare for the largest number of patients within the limited resources available.

“Unfortunately, this means that we are not able to fund some specialist treatments for which there is limited clinical evidence to support their clinical effectiveness.”

To donate to Jamie’s appeal visit justgiving.com/jamiesappeal

•A Jazz For Jamie event at the Tramways Club in Mill Street earlier this week raised about £1,900.

The event was organised by Jamie’s friends and parents at Lord Deramore’s Primary School and featured music and the raffle of numerous donated prizes such as York City FC shirts, including Scott Kerr ’s shirt from the FA Trophy final at Wembley, Leeds rugby tickets, a family ticket to a Disney Live Mickey Mouse show and a signed shirt and magazine from gymnast Beth Tweddle.

Comments(7)

loopyluu says...
10:43am Sat 21 Jul 12

poor little lad the nhs need to stop paying for drug users and drunks to be admitted time after time and start funding things like this that could possibly save the life of more than 1 person!

violetblush says...
11:56am Sat 21 Jul 12

They wont fund it because there is no cure sadly. My neice had nb for 5 yrs. Its very sad...but there really is no 75% survival rate. All current drugs for treatment of stage 4 nb sadly dont cure. They give you a 5 yr event free survival if your lucky. Quality of lufe becomes paramount. But to claim a 75% cure rate is lies..ive never heard an oncoligist link those words to nb x

john647 says...
12:59pm Sat 21 Jul 12

Violet Blush I am sorry for your loss and well aware of the survival stats as we have been on this journey since 2009 so have a little experience and knowledge of the disease. I would just like to point out that there have been some major breakthroughs in the field of NB both in genetics and novel therapies in the last few years. Although it is accepted that many children do not make long term survival, some do and with the combination of multi- modal treatment therapies, many children now reach remission and may have event free survival for several years. Although your comments are very cynical regarding there being a cure it is widly accepted that this is a highly challenging disease, the HAPLO Stem cell transplant therapy for example may provide a curative approach,however it is early days and one must apply a cautious approach. Such therapies, however do provide families with hope and perhaps at least could promote their life for several years. The data from the HAPLO therapy was recently presented at the annual NB conf and has demonstrated that the results are highly encouraging against the dozens of other NB trials. The Germans are renown for being very cautious and conservative regarding medical studies so this speaks volumes. Our son achieved remission for 18 months and achieved remarkable things during that window. The 75% stated has to be kept in context and refers to a 2 year event free survival as the trial has only run for 2 years. We know of several children that have lived to adulthood, so perhaps despite your cynicism with our persistence and access to new therapies you never know. In the knowledge of such therapies as a parent it is our responsibility to grant our son that opportunity. If we are unsuccessful then at least we tried. In the meantime we have seen the pattern of children relapsing in the UK and without access to further therapies have progressed rapidly and sadly gained their angel wings.

violetblush says...
11:33am Mon 23 Jul 12

Hi I'm sorry if I appeared cynical...I looked at it as being real. To even contemplate a HAPLO transplant for a child having received previous stem cell transplants is blatantly cruel. The risks attached are as I'm sure you are aware...extremely horrific . I have been slightly untruthful, I'm actually a mum who stood in your shoes and merely wanted to offer my advice of...stop chasing the cure and live life and create memories. The sheer fact your PCT have denied funding proves (regardless) of what specialists have told you....the chance of survival is slim. The PCT do a good job but in funding relapse it becomes a minefield as despite Greifswald etc pioneering ahead with trials of RIST Etc...there still is no improvement in survival rates. Being able to look back and see him happy is paramount....if you persist down the CURE route you won't have that. And as for the 75% survival rate....that is not whatever way it's dressed up a cure rate. We don't get that at dx so we certainly aren't told it on relapse. I wish you success in whatever path you choose...but choose wisely....it will haunt you forever.

Birdni says...
2:58pm Tue 24 Jul 12

At a conference earlier this year there was a young man in his mid-20s who had relapsed neuroblastoma at the age of 3. He underwent an allogeneic transplant, relapsed again, and then underwent a HAPLO transplant. And here he was having joined the medical institution that successfully treated him all those years ago. Now maybe his was the extremely rare case, but it got me thinking this; what would have become of that child had his parents listened to the naysayers? All the best to the Inglis family. Keep believing.

claudia89 says...
7:34pm Tue 24 Jul 12

Knowing the wonderful parents of this child, i can tell anyone who has any doubt, that they have thoroughly researched the treatement they have opted to use with Jamie, they have consulted experts in this country and other and would never do anything that they thought wasnt in the interest of their wonderful and inspirational little boy. What these two parents need now is support, kindness, compassion and if people cant offer that then there is no positive outcome to their comments. Vicky and John know the risks of the complex treatment Jamie will recieve, but like many other parents will do anything to ensure that Jamie gets through this awful time. Were there are chances there are hope and thank goodness they appreciate that, and if treatment doesnt work (which all those supporting the Inglis family hope that it does) they will know that they did everything they could. Positive words are all that are required here. Love to all the Inglis! xxx

Yummy-yum says...
10:01pm Fri 27 Jul 12

As knowing this lovely family it
Annoys me when NHS will help those that drink n drugs! It's self inflicted stop helping them n help people that need it. Both children are a credit to Vicky and John i hope all
Best for all of them, keep
Smiling :) x

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree