More shops being turned into homes

SCHEMES which saw shops in York turned into flats and houses more than doubled last year - and more small business sites could be in line for changes.

Figures from City of York Council have shown 11 planning applications to convert retail premises into homes were approved by the authority during 2011/12, more than the combined total for the previous two years.

Some of the schemes involved part of the building remaining as a shop or available to be used for that purpose, while other sections of the site - often the first floor - became living accommodation, but others have seen the entire business become a house or flat.

In recent weeks, three new “change of use” applications have been submitted to the council, with business organisations saying the need for their owners to pay empty-building rates if a retail establishment closes could be contributing to the increased number of schemes.

Recent applications have been made for a vacant shop in Boroughbridge Road and a butcher’s business in York Street, Dunnington, to become houses, and a change of use from “retail” to “residential” at a newsagents shop on Bishopthorpe Road.

Permission for similar conversions is also being sought for shops in Burton Stone Lane, Haxby Road and Blossom Street.

The council approved four such applications in both 2008/09 and 2009/10 and five in 2010/11, but the total reached double figures last year.

Planning policy states applications which lead to the loss of a “local or village shop” can only be given the go-ahead if “a local need for the shopping facility no longer exists” or there are alternative businesses in the area.

Katie Stewart, the authority’s head of economic development, said: “Our figures for registered business-rated properties reflects our position as the third fastest-growing city in the UK and we have seen a fall in empty business premises since this time last year.

“We are committed to supporting the future of our city’s economy, and remaining competitive by adapting to market challenges and opportunities is key to any business’ survival.”

Simon Williams, regional chairman of the Federation of Small Businesses, said converting retail premises to houses was sometimes the “only option” for property owners who would otherwise have to make empty-building rate payments.

“We believe this system needs looking at as it is hitting individual traders and proving to be a big problem for some of them,” he said.

Comments(12)

ReginaldBiscuit says...
10:06am Fri 15 Jun 12

Big plus this but still a token gesture.

newscritic says...
10:28am Fri 15 Jun 12

ReginaldBiscuit wrote:
Big plus this but still a token gesture.
ONly partly because if all local shops and business closed down housing areas would become hard to live in as people would need to pop in cars to shop and do business rather than walk locally.

It is the whole way in which business is supported that needs looking at in particular business rates and wholesale buying.

again says...
10:50am Fri 15 Jun 12

In other countries, retail parks have units available to small shops as well as large ones. It seems to work and creates a more interesting environment than simply having a single store.

Wints71 says...
2:36pm Fri 15 Jun 12

Any one noticed woodheads the bakers is another business in town centre that has suddenly shut this week? Seeing the demise of the town centre after working in it for 20 years is very depressing!

meme says...
2:40pm Fri 15 Jun 12

This could be a part solution to the housing issue if only the council would grasnt planning without
1 Insisting on the loss of employment arguement
2 Stop charging per bed for educational/public open space/highways/bus stop contributions ie hidden taxes
3 Take a realistic view on affordable quotas
Then we may get somewhere

greenmonkey says...
2:50pm Fri 15 Jun 12

Its only going to get worse, especially if Monks cross goes ahead. What's the point in turning everything into housing if this leaves nowhere local to buy basic provisions? The requirements meme refer to is because there is a cost to provide local infrastructure and facilities and if there is no money from the government, it should come from the profits that developers make when bringing the extra housing into place.

meme says...
3:27pm Fri 15 Jun 12

green monkey

Great to pay taxes when money is made but it may have come to your attention hardly any homes are being built because this Council has squeezed the pips too hard and now developers are not building
I thought we paid central taxes to cover these things anyway?
Perhaps they just pay politicians wages and expenses claims

Even AndyD says...
5:24pm Fri 15 Jun 12

Been happening a long time - pubs, small shops etc are slowly disappearing. Acomb in particular is a sorry sight at the moment, with Front St full of betting shops, charity shops and little else. I was brought up round there and find it sad to see.

But what is the answer? People vote with their feet and wallets. Do you stop Tesco offering cheaper products than local stores or what? Its okay blaming the Council, or planning, or Tesco, or anything else. But at the end of the day, its use 'em or lose 'em. Choice is in our hands and as such, we take responsibility for the outcomes.

Frodo Baggins says...
6:03pm Fri 15 Jun 12

Even AndyD wrote:
Been happening a long time - pubs, small shops etc are slowly disappearing. Acomb in particular is a sorry sight at the moment, with Front St full of betting shops, charity shops and little else. I was brought up round there and find it sad to see.

But what is the answer? People vote with their feet and wallets. Do you stop Tesco offering cheaper products than local stores or what? Its okay blaming the Council, or planning, or Tesco, or anything else. But at the end of the day, its use 'em or lose 'em. Choice is in our hands and as such, we take responsibility for the outcomes.
You missed out that Front St has become full of chavs making it an unpleasant place to shop. I avoid it like the plague.

Rockmamma says...
6:57pm Fri 15 Jun 12

Frodo Baggins wrote:
Even AndyD wrote:
Been happening a long time - pubs, small shops etc are slowly disappearing. Acomb in particular is a sorry sight at the moment, with Front St full of betting shops, charity shops and little else. I was brought up round there and find it sad to see.

But what is the answer? People vote with their feet and wallets. Do you stop Tesco offering cheaper products than local stores or what? Its okay blaming the Council, or planning, or Tesco, or anything else. But at the end of the day, its use 'em or lose 'em. Choice is in our hands and as such, we take responsibility for the outcomes.
You missed out that Front St has become full of chavs making it an unpleasant place to shop. I avoid it like the plague.
Up until recently I also worked in Acomb and often found the the 'little old dears' to be far nastier and ruder than the teens. And the amount of shoplifting from the pensioners was unreal! xXx

arglemcgee says...
8:36pm Fri 15 Jun 12

Even AndyD wrote:
Been happening a long time - pubs, small shops etc are slowly disappearing. Acomb in particular is a sorry sight at the moment, with Front St full of betting shops, charity shops and little else. I was brought up round there and find it sad to see.

But what is the answer? People vote with their feet and wallets. Do you stop Tesco offering cheaper products than local stores or what? Its okay blaming the Council, or planning, or Tesco, or anything else. But at the end of the day, its use 'em or lose 'em. Choice is in our hands and as such, we take responsibility for the outcomes.
I suppose it's all what you notice. To me Front Street is full of banks, bakers and hairdressers. But seriously, there's also a greengrocer, Barnitt's, Boots, Farm Foods, Superdrug and quite a few other shops. Acomb has by far the most local shops of anywhere in York. But very true that it needs an aesthetic refresh. The new outdoor seating area of Thomas's helps a little.

3.8liter says...
4:10pm Sat 16 Jun 12

Rockmamma wrote:
Frodo Baggins wrote:
Even AndyD wrote:
Been happening a long time - pubs, small shops etc are slowly disappearing. Acomb in particular is a sorry sight at the moment, with Front St full of betting shops, charity shops and little else. I was brought up round there and find it sad to see.

But what is the answer? People vote with their feet and wallets. Do you stop Tesco offering cheaper products than local stores or what? Its okay blaming the Council, or planning, or Tesco, or anything else. But at the end of the day, its use 'em or lose 'em. Choice is in our hands and as such, we take responsibility for the outcomes.
You missed out that Front St has become full of chavs making it an unpleasant place to shop. I avoid it like the plague.
Up until recently I also worked in Acomb and often found the the 'little old dears' to be far nastier and ruder than the teens. And the amount of shoplifting from the pensioners was unreal! xXx
Yes, horrible place to go shopping Acomb! Even considering the free parking.
I also avoid it like the plague. I go to Clifton Moor or Monks's Cross.
Takes longer, costs more in petrol, but far less chavs and peasants. Well worth the extra costs.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree