Report this comment
  • "What seems increasingly clear is that leading Councillors have no idea what to do with the Guildhall buildings and even less idea how they would pay for any remodelling.

    The report talks only of ”a centre for creative / digital businesses”. However we appear to be getting one of those at the Bonding Warehouse site anyway.

    Although the site, taken as a whole, does offer opportunities, anyone who has Google Earth will readily be able to see that access is a major problem with the only obvious “solution” being to demolish Lendal Cellars & the Post Office building (a rather well used facility).

    Having an architectural competition smacks of desperation (and a staggering insensitivity to cost issues – the £35,000 they will be giving to RIBA and as prizes is equal to the cost of keeping facilities like the Beckfield Lane recycling centre open).

    And at the end of the day all the Council will have will be a design plan. Still needing several millions in investment to bring it to a reality.

    “Blue sky” thinking often produces “red ink” expenditure levels. Unless there is a comprehensive planning brief written then a competition could produce an impractical solution dogged by raised expectation levels.

    The last competition of this sort organised by the Council resulted in the Parliament Street remodelling 25 years ago – fountain, cycle racks, splash palace and all.

    And no “Common Hall Lane” will not be opened up as a public access. The roof level is too low and it’s flooded for some of the year. … nor is a hotel on the site very likely now; the Judges Lodgings – which does have some car parking space – has struggled recently at a nearby location.

    The Council should retain the Guildhall as its democratic base and let out spare space there – and at its Station Rise HQ – on a commercial basis to help pay for maintenance costs."
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory

  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.


  • Enter the above word in the box below

Please be fair, courteous and respectful to the views of others so we can build a vibrant community in a safe online environment. You are personal liable for your comments and action will be taken against anyone who offends, ridicules or posts malicious and damaging views. If you wish to complain, please contact us.

Contest to find new role for The Guildhall in York

8:29am Tuesday 8th May 2012 in News Photograph of the Author By Richard Catton , richard.catton@thepress.co.uk

The Guildhall reflecting in the River Ouse The Guildhall reflecting in the River Ouse

THE world’s most innovative architects are to be invited to submit plans for a major redevelopment of York’s historic Guildhall.

City of York Council decided in December it wanted to limit its use of the Guildhall and instead turn the iconic river-front building over to the “benefit of the city and its residents”.

Now council chiefs will meet on Tuesday next week to consider launching the “Open Ideas” competition, which would be run by the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA), and is expected to attract national and international high-profile architects.

The cost of running the competition would be around £35,000, but the council said it hoped that by inviting ideas from architectural practices across the world, “the city would see the benefits that could be realised from a range of high quality and innovative options”.

Coun Julie Gunnell, cabinet member for Corporate Services, said: “The Guildhall and associated spaces are a significant part of York’s cultural and civic history and we want to ensure that it can continue to play a key role in the city in the future.

“Independent assessment of the site confirms that significant development and modernisation of elements of the complex will be necessary to make the most of the buildings and riverside area for the future.”

The winning bid would have to take into account the Guildhall’s Grade II listed council chamber and its Grade I riverside committee rooms.

A recent report on the cultural and historic significance of the building said that the bombing of the Guildhall during the Second World War and subsequent rebuilding meant it was not a ‘pristine medieval’ site but acknowledged that the complex was of ‘national significance’.

According to other key findings the “do nothing option” does not exist because of the future cost to the council and the need to secure use for the Guildhall and ensure there is no long-term deterioration in condition.

Local Businesses

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree