News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


News coverage for York, Ryedale, East Yorkshire, Harrogate and Selby.

Popular topics: Community Stadium | Snow | Germany Beck | ftr | Queen's visit | Council tax


York to miss council's waste recycling target


YORK is to miss its recycling targets this year – and city leaders say it’s because the credit crunch has led to people buying fewer treats.

Figures on the city’s waste situation have shown that although the amount of rubbish residents recycle is rising, City of York Council’s benchmark for 2010/11 looks likely to be missed.

But the authority said the anticipated shortfall will not mean Government penalties because it is still expected to comfortably exceed national recycling levels.

The council set itself a target of 48 per cent of waste being recycled this year, with the rest going to landfill. But analysis of its performance for the first quarter of 2009/10, which went before its executive yesterday, forecasts this will be missed by four per cent.

Coun Ann Reid, executive member for neighbourhood services, said York had suffered similar recycling-rate snags as other cities, with much of it caused by belt-tightening amid the recession.

“The main reason for the dip was people’s buying habits changed when money was tight and they spent less on luxury items like bottles of wine and glossy magazines, meaning less glass and paper was recycled,” she said.

“Industry is also reducing the amount of packing it is using, with a good example of this being Easter eggs, meaning residents are seeing a reduction in their overall waste.

“Our recycling rates are calculated using the total weight of recyclable material collected, so fewer heavy items like glass means the rate goes down.

“However, the total amount of waste collected also fell, so while recycling rates dipped slightly, the amount of waste sent to landfill still dropped.

“Recycling rates are now on the rise again and the roll-out of kerbside recycling to properties which do not currently benefit from the service will help improve this further.”

But Coun Ken King, neighbourhood services spokesman for the council’s Labour group, said York should set its recycling sights higher.

“After reaching about 43 per cent of waste recycled in 2007, the figure stands at almost exactly the same today,” he said.

“As landfill tax has increased, recycling rates standing still means the council is having to pay more. This is not sustainable, both environmentally and financially, and the targets and the amounts recycled need to be higher.”

Comments(33)

pedalling paul says...
9:34am Wed 8 Sep 10

I'll drink a little less to that! But I've not cancelled my subscription to the Sunday Times Wine club.

Do the statistics include the many bikes that are "recycled" by Bike rescue....?

Fred the Shred says...
9:42am Wed 8 Sep 10

pedalling paul wrote:
I'll drink a little less to that! But I've not cancelled my subscription to the Sunday Times Wine club.

Do the statistics include the many bikes that are "recycled" by Bike rescue....?
Or the recycling of pithy comments.

King Edward says...
10:15am Wed 8 Sep 10

... not then because many residents are too lazy to seperate recycling and fill their black bin with it then? The number of overfilled bins I see every week that operatives struggle to get to the wagon and tipped in supports this. The council claims to have a policy of if the lid isn't down, we don't take it, perhaps they might start and enforce it. Followed up by looking at what people are filling it with and an advisory letter on reycling. Next start refusing to take their bin if it's full of recyclables. After all our council loves making up jobs for people, so there's one, albeit useful - bin inspector.

micky moodys hat says...
10:25am Wed 8 Sep 10

There is a chap who lives next door to my mum in poppleton who just throws all his rubbish in the landfill bin, he deos not recycle at all. she has challenged him about this and he just shrugs his shouldersd and laughs. Bin inspection is a bit "big brother" but in cases like this then I would offer advice and then issue fines

TooRelaxed says...
10:26am Wed 8 Sep 10

I've never read such codswallop in all my life!
Surely the object is to reduce waste in all its forms. Why on earth should we be buying more junk in order to up the recycling figures? Doesn't that defeat the object?
Who put Milo Minderbinder in charge? let's take his lead and bomb ourselves so we can profit from the rebuilding contracts.
I hope it's misleading reporting from the Press rather than idiotic leadership.

frank west says...
10:43am Wed 8 Sep 10

Is there any target or goal this council doesn't FAIL to achieve? They need to co-opt Wayne Rooney, he never fails to score, especially AWAY from home!!

charles dance says...
10:45am Wed 8 Sep 10

Maybe its that Ann Reid has not done a good enough job?

Ben Guela says...
11:04am Wed 8 Sep 10

If the council would not waste our money on those leaflets each month or so then they would not spend so foolishly.

EndofTether says...
11:06am Wed 8 Sep 10

Maybe it would help if they actually collected the recycling instead of deciding its too much for them to take in that trip. The number of weeks that they've left mine has made me start to throw it all in the black bin!

Beagleboy says...
11:21am Wed 8 Sep 10

I agree - last week an empty tin of mushy peas unfourtuntley got muddled up with the cardboard boxes and my super efficent binman decided not to take the entire load. A few hours later he was in the Pack Of Cards public house in his sweaty hi-vis jacket supping a pint of carling and building a horrible sweaty roll up.

AdmiralNN says...
11:25am Wed 8 Sep 10

EndofTether wrote:
Maybe it would help if they actually collected the recycling instead of deciding its too much for them to take in that trip. The number of weeks that they've left mine has made me start to throw it all in the black bin!
I always leave out extra cardboard that i cant fit in the box and they have always taken it away. I usually fold it up stamp on it a few times and leave it under the box or wedged between the box and the wall. Lots of people on my street do this and dont think there has been any problems.

m dee says...
11:53am Wed 8 Sep 10

The statement from Ann Reid borders on lunacy.
Firstly there will be a limit when residents have nothing else to recycle regardless of spending habit ,recessions ect,we have probably reached this now.
I have said this over and over, walk around town and look at all the tourist/business related waste going straight to landfill.
Standard litter bins with plastic bottles/cans often spilling out if they were changed to bins with separate sections for recycling they would pay for themselves over time with the money saved off landfill.
Tons of card board from the Market is collected daily straight into landfill collection vehicles again to divert this would be self financing through what is saved in landfill charges.
Same with many businesses they pay for the commercial waste bin so just fill it with everything they need to be offered more alternatives/better recycling facilities that will be cost affective for both themselves and the Council.

Intime says...
11:57am Wed 8 Sep 10

The shortfall is most likely because they now refuse to collect the multitude of plastic wrappers that that most groceries that we buy are packed in.

fate says...
12:19pm Wed 8 Sep 10

In April 2010 Stella Artois reduced the amount of glass used in (and presumably weight) of their bottles by 8%. So my recycling weight has certainly been reduced and by not doing anything different. I'll drink to that.
Surely the aim is to reduce all waste, including recycling. The less packaging etc will create less recycling.
Just out of curiosity, how much CO2 is created making recycling boxes, distributing them and collecting recycling waste? and are they made from recycled plastic?

EndofTether says...
12:25pm Wed 8 Sep 10

AdmiralNN wrote:
EndofTether wrote:
Maybe it would help if they actually collected the recycling instead of deciding its too much for them to take in that trip. The number of weeks that they've left mine has made me start to throw it all in the black bin!
I always leave out extra cardboard that i cant fit in the box and they have always taken it away. I usually fold it up stamp on it a few times and leave it under the box or wedged between the box and the wall. Lots of people on my street do this and dont think there has been any problems.
You clearly live on a lucky street! I think the problem is, I can recycle 95% of my household waste but I don't have any boxes (they keep getting nicked) so I seperate into see through bin liners (as requested) all washed, crushed and neatly piled! The cardboard is torn into little strips and kept together neatly and they still leave everything as its clearly too much hassle for them to take all of it!

Beagleboy says...
12:44pm Wed 8 Sep 10

Ann Reid - was that the woman who had all the traffic lights altered when it was her daughters wedding day?

moneyforwhat says...
1:06pm Wed 8 Sep 10

TooRelaxed wrote:
I've never read such codswallop in all my life! Surely the object is to reduce waste in all its forms. Why on earth should we be buying more junk in order to up the recycling figures? Doesn't that defeat the object? Who put Milo Minderbinder in charge? let's take his lead and bomb ourselves so we can profit from the rebuilding contracts. I hope it's misleading reporting from the Press rather than idiotic leadership.
well said..I couldn't get my head around the targets not being reached as people were buying less treats. I'm sure that many will agree that visits to the Hazel Court site are very upsetting for those of us who see uses in things. The amount of stuff which people throw away is a sin. So many perfectly saleable goods which could make their way to a charity shop and do someone a bit of good.

charles dance says...
1:25pm Wed 8 Sep 10

Beagleboy wrote:
Ann Reid - was that the woman who had all the traffic lights altered when it was her daughters wedding day?
Yeah it was. And it was her who tried to sweep it under the carpet when all the unecessary sat navs got nicked out of the bin wagons. What was the outcome of that anyway? Was it just more money for the taxpayer to foot the bill for??

frank west says...
1:27pm Wed 8 Sep 10

Beagleboy wrote:
Ann Reid - was that the woman who had all the traffic lights altered when it was her daughters wedding day?
Yes, the old regime had "Red Light Rod" we now have "Green Light Annie"

jumpersforgoalposts says...
1:46pm Wed 8 Sep 10

with less prison sentences and more 'community payback' sentences, surely this could be used to sort our refuse for us, a big recycling plant, a bunch of chavs, and an hour of payback to ton of refuse sorted should soon get the figures back on track.

frank west says...
1:52pm Wed 8 Sep 10

charles dance wrote:
Beagleboy wrote: Ann Reid - was that the woman who had all the traffic lights altered when it was her daughters wedding day?
Yeah it was. And it was her who tried to sweep it under the carpet when all the unecessary sat navs got nicked out of the bin wagons. What was the outcome of that anyway? Was it just more money for the taxpayer to foot the bill for??
One of her daughters used to be on the streets and sell "lucky heather" to gullible tourists.

Beagleboy says...
1:57pm Wed 8 Sep 10

she is absolute scum for that and nobody should listen to a word she says. stopping traffic lights for her daughters wedding? She should have faced criminal charges.

frank west says...
2:19pm Wed 8 Sep 10

Beagleboy wrote:
she is absolute scum for that and nobody should listen to a word she says. stopping traffic lights for her daughters wedding? She should have faced criminal charges.
If you need planning permission for anything give her a call. She is good at giving things the green light I am told.

Ignatius Lumpopo says...
3:34pm Wed 8 Sep 10

Beagleboy wrote:
Ann Reid - was that the woman who had all the traffic lights altered when it was her daughters wedding day?
Yes. She was thinking "green" even back then...

groble says...
3:48pm Wed 8 Sep 10

I still thik it's stupid that the council aren't doing anything to help businesses recycle. They already pay to have their rubbish taken which already includes the recyclables. The council are giving no incentives to them to recycle, and refusing to take the recycling of the ones that actually want to.

Henry Swanson says...
5:33pm Wed 8 Sep 10

Arent recycling targets set as a % of overall rubbish collected..... its not like they have a set aim of stuff to recycle is it???? Because who would set that and based on what?

pedalling paul says...
5:45pm Wed 8 Sep 10

Beagleboy wrote:
she is absolute scum for that and nobody should listen to a word she says. stopping traffic lights for her daughters wedding? She should have faced criminal charges.
Actually she saved Council tax payers a bob or two, as the tests would otherwise have had to be conducted with a separate vehicle journey.

Silver says...
8:39pm Wed 8 Sep 10

pedalling paul wrote:
Beagleboy wrote:
she is absolute scum for that and nobody should listen to a word she says. stopping traffic lights for her daughters wedding? She should have faced criminal charges.
Actually she saved Council tax payers a bob or two, as the tests would otherwise have had to be conducted with a separate vehicle journey.
Still others would call that Morally Corrupt. After all abuse of power and all that.

Biggles Breaks his Silence says...
9:45pm Wed 8 Sep 10

I think we need more bins to recycle...I mean 5 bins for a 1 bedroom flat is just not enough.

mickrick says...
8:19am Thu 9 Sep 10

Is ANNE Reid your auntie ped paul you seem to like sucking up to her. i agree with the others she should have been prosecuted

euroinforitnow says...
8:36am Thu 9 Sep 10

Folk buying fewer magazines and wine a cause for concern ? I didn't realise that the aim of buying goods was to keep up the council's quota for recycling. If fewer recyclable items are being bought I'd have thought that was quite a positive thing.

Aimson says...
10:13am Thu 9 Sep 10

Ann Reid's statement that the recession is causing people to buy less bottles of wine etc is ridiculous. If we apply her logic then less people - because of the recession - will be eating out and eating more meals at home - which would then mean we are creating more disposable rubbish!

Ann Reid the woman who stops the traffic for her daughter's wedding and now thinks recycling is suffering because people are drinking less! What a clown - Let us hope she is not recycled next time there are council elections and that this idiotic woman is taken as far away from governing this city as possible!

mystic_genius says...
12:57pm Mon 13 Sep 10

pedalling paul wrote:
Beagleboy wrote: she is absolute scum for that and nobody should listen to a word she says. stopping traffic lights for her daughters wedding? She should have faced criminal charges.
Actually she saved Council tax payers a bob or two, as the tests would otherwise have had to be conducted with a separate vehicle journey.
Just out of interest, what tests? Can we see the outcome of these tests? What were they designed to show? Is it merely a coincidence that the test route was the exact route (date and time) of her daughters wedding? Are there further tests being carried out? I hope you say the things you do tongue-in-cheek as most of the time you speak utter BS.


Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses