News RSS Feed


Parents warned over teenage boozing


Parents who have a "laissez-faire" attitude to their children's drinking are putting them at risk, the chief medical officer has warned.

Sir Liam Donaldson said people who allow their teenagers to drink alcohol with their friends could be storing up problems while middle-class families who dilute their children's wine may also be misguided.

Parents should avoid exposing youngsters to "alcohol-fuelled environments" or family events where drinking is the central activity, he went on.

Yet parents could show their children that if alcohol is drunk at home it is consumed in a "positive" setting such as a family meal.

Your Vote

Do you think under-15s should have an "alcohol free" childhood?

Yes:
Blue bar used for ballot results 51%

No:
Yellow bar used for ballot results 48%

Undecided:
Purple bar used for ballot results 1%


Sir Liam, who has announced his intention to step down as chief medical officer for England, said one of the risk factors for children drinking was parents having a "laissez-faire approach to a child drinking or getting drunk".

The idea that if you "somehow wean children on to alcohol at an early age they won't have any problems in later life, they will be sensible, is not supported by evidence," he added. In fact, studies have shown the opposite - that those who begin drinking early are more likely to binge drink in their teenage years and develop alcohol-related problems later in life.

"The more they get a taste for it, the more likely they are to be heavy drinking adults or binge drinkers later in childhood," Sir Liam said. "It's a bit of a middle-class obsession - the idea of taking out the wine bottle and diluting it. There's not a great problem to that as such but to extrapolate from that sort of situation that alcohol in general is a good thing just does not work. It's not supported by evidence."

Sir Liam was speaking as he published a report which suggests parents support the idea that under-15s should have an "alcohol free" childhood.

Between the ages of 15 and 17, if youngsters drink at all then they should do so infrequently and certainly on no more than one day a week, Sir Liam recommended. He said there was a need to challenge the stereotype of "the drunk as a hero" and pointed to self-confessed alcoholic footballers Paul Gascoigne and George Best.

In January, the Department for Children, Schools and Families will launch a campaign regarding the dangers of drinking among children and young people.


Your Say YourPress

Rosieposie, york says...
10:31am Thu 17 Dec 09

I agree, I have been horrified when my daughter, from the age of 11, told me that at her friends houses/parties parents provided alchohol in the form of alcopops...why on earth do they do that. At 16 my daughter has the occasional glass of wine with a meal. I have no doubt that with her friends they may try alcohol but I have seen no evidence as yet. Alcohol is a poison, teenagers are still developing and the long term effects of achohol are well known. Incidently I didn't drink until I was 21 and I wish I had never started...too many hangovers and a taste for a good red are not good for me.
Alcohol has become too cheap.

BL2, York says...
11:46am Thu 17 Dec 09

Personally everyone growing with me had tried alcohol early. even before the age of 10 we were allowed to try the occasional sip of someone's drink, or have a small Xmas spirits drink as we grow up. I've seen no harm in it at all - it was just another part of everyone's life. You didn't to overindulge to enjoy it and still don't.

addynuff, york says...
11:51am Thu 17 Dec 09

i thought this lunatic had left the job.donaldson wont be happy until all smoking,drinking,dan
gerous sports etc are outlawed then we can all live a long and dreary life.please go, and get off your nannying soapbox.

Smiler, York says...
12:16pm Thu 17 Dec 09

addynuff wrote:
i thought this lunatic had left the job.donaldson wont be happy until all smoking,drinking,dan gerous sports etc are outlawed then we can all live a long and dreary life.please go, and get off your nannying soapbox.
I agree completely.

I was one that at 14 was drinking in a pub in town, the bar staff/landlord/door staff all knew we were under age. and wouldn't serve us if we looked even a little merry. His argument was that he could keep an eye on us, where if we did it in the museum gardens, nobody would be there supervising.

Get-a-grip, says...
12:17pm Thu 17 Dec 09

Thankfully Liam Donaldson is retiring in May 2010. He parrots the hangups and obsessions of any pressure group he comes into contact with, but I don't remember him saying anything when New Labour were pulling down the licensing laws and legislating for the 24 hour drinking which has caused so much damage and created a generation of young binge drinkers.

Viper_7, Whixley says...
12:21pm Thu 17 Dec 09

It was only last week that "children" who didn't have a drink were more likely to binge dringe when they were legally allowed to get their hands on it compared to those who drank in moderation.

Get read for this Friday, will be drunks all over our streets as it's the last Friday before Christmas. guarentee pubs/clubs will be turning a blind eye and serving those who are clearly intoxicated.

Get out and police the laws already in place rather than coming up with new parent advice which contradicts the last peice of advice.

tonezzzznoddedoff, york says...
1:27pm Thu 17 Dec 09

The biggest problem is ALCOPOPS kids love them , they should never have been allowed you wont see any real ale or guiness drinking kids its all the bright fizzy stuff.

MissConstrood, YORK says...
1:32pm Thu 17 Dec 09

Its the same as most things - deny them totally and an obsession to get them emerges. Plus, moderation is the key to most of the things that are bad for us. I have two kids, they were allowed access to alcohol in moderation as i was as a child. When there was a hangover problem, usually later discovered it was a neighbour buying drink for my daughter, when i had refused for good reason myself!

Mullarkian, York says...
4:37pm Thu 17 Dec 09

The more I hear the pontifications of Donaldson I come to the conclusion that he is merely a government puppet just spouting the latest 'pc' tripe that his masters require.
Wasn't he the guy that said tens of thousands would die of swine flu, which is now looking no worse than bird or any other flu.

oldgoat, York says...
5:37pm Thu 17 Dec 09

Mullarkian wrote:
The more I hear the pontifications of Donaldson I come to the conclusion that he is merely a government puppet just spouting the latest 'pc' tripe that his masters require.
Wasn't he the guy that said tens of thousands would die of swine flu, which is now looking no worse than bird or any other flu.
Yeah. 65,000 was the quoted figure, and now we learn that a significant percentage of kids have had Swine Flu without even knowing it.
Best ignoring this one. Most parents know better than him anyway!

the butler, cowichan Bay says...
6:31pm Thu 17 Dec 09

Now what would parents and discipline have to do with this article?
A true disconnect it seems.

Taken for a Mug, York says...
9:00pm Thu 17 Dec 09

Alcohol should be the least of his worries, he's the one that rubber stamped the use of the swine flu vaccine which contains mercury.

Will this be storing up problems for the thousands of kids and pregnant women that will eventually be receiving it?

Taken for a Mug, York says...
9:09pm Thu 17 Dec 09

http://tpuc.org/cont
ent/swine-flu-vaccin
e-information-advoca
tor

Henry Swanson, York says...
10:50am Fri 18 Dec 09

I was allowed to drink with meals at home from an early age.... im talking about ten yaers old a watered down glass of wine with meals etc.... it meant I had no issues with alcochol, didnt need to go out and get smashed on a field as I knew what it tasted like it held no taboo.... its what I'll do with my children, i think it helps promote a healthy attitude towards it

Comments are closed on this article.

Parents warned that a relaxed attitude to their children's drinking is putting them at risk Parents warned that a relaxed attitude to their children's drinking is putting them at risk

Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »