News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


News coverage for York, Ryedale, East Yorkshire, Harrogate and Selby.

Popular topics: Community Stadium | Snow | Germany Beck | ftr | Queen's visit | Council tax


Medical records from York Hospital found in street


CONFIDENTIAL information about seriously-ill patients at York Hospital has been found on a pavement nearly two miles from the hospital.

The document, which was discovered by a member of the public, gave details of 19 patients who were being treated on the hospital’s acute medical unit, including their names, ages and medical history.

One patient, whose name and bed number is given, is listed as having HIV and syphilis.

Paul Ward, deputy chief executive of the Terrence Higgins Trust, a charity that campaigns on behalf of people with HIV and AIDS, said the breach of confidentiality was “totally unacceptable”.

He said: “For anyone with HIV who is facing stigma, having personal information about their health being inadvertently made public is very worrying.

“We recognise that when you run a complex organisation like a hospital, getting it right all the time can be quite difficult.

“However, people place their trust and faith in hospitals. They trust staff to treat everything they tell them confidentially and if there has been a failing we ask York Hospital to redouble its efforts to make sure it is able to ensure full confidentiality in the future.”

The find was made by a local resident, who discovered the document lying on a pavement at the junction between Hilda Street and Granville Terrace, in the Lawrence Street area of York.

The 19 patients affected by the confidentiality breach were predominantly elderly, but the youngest patient was 27.

They were suffering from a range of serious illnesses, including breast cancer, Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease and multiple sclerosis.

Handwritten notes gave details of personal information about their nursing care.

Mike Proctor, deputy chief executive of York Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, apologised and said a full investigation had been launched. He said: “We take the protection of all patient information very seriously and we apologise to any of our patients and their families who may have been caused distress by this potential breach of their confidentiality.

“We are making contact with the patients who have information contained within this document, to apologise, to reassure them, and to hear their concerns.

“Our policies and processes regarding staff responsibilities for such information are very clear, and we are appalled that details of this nature have been found outside the hospital.

“The trust began investigating this as a serious untoward incident as soon as it was brought to our attention and based on the outcome of this investigation we will take appropriate action. Personal accountabilities and responsibilities have been reinforced with all staff following this incident.”

City of York councillor Sandy Fraser, who sits on York Hospital’s board of governors, said he expected the matter to be discussed at the next meeting of the governing body.

He said: “Any breach of patient confidentiality is serious and regrettable.”

Comments(20)

moose says...
12:24pm Fri 20 Mar 09

why did the person who found them give all the personal information the papers contained to The Press?

There's no need to make a bad situation worse - by all means make The Press aware of the incident, but don't actually give them the details!

invisibleman says...
12:29pm Fri 20 Mar 09

Hope they weren't mine, my medical records say I smoke

iknowwheretheyare says...
12:35pm Fri 20 Mar 09

I work at the hospital and i to cannot understand why the person that found the information gave it to the press,what would of been so wrong with taking to the hospital instead.
All this could of been easily avoided with just a small ounce of common sense!!

ariesgirl says...
1:17pm Fri 20 Mar 09

I am proud to say that I am a Staff Nurse at York hospital and although I do understand the implications and seriousness of the situation I find it unbelieveble that the member of public who found the sheet of paper containing personal details of patients chose to take it to the local rag!!! what possible benefit could be achieved from this, £££££ I expect!
We work very hard as healthcare professionals with little thanks, nor do we expect it, we quite often work through our breaks and stretch ourselves to the limit to ensure our patients recieve the best available care and now through this a nurse, healthcare assistant or other member of staff is going to be diciplined over a human error. After all we are only human!!

wildthing says...
1:33pm Fri 20 Mar 09

we quite often work through our breaks and stretch ourselves to the limit


That is because there are too many organ grinders and not enough monkeys.


Confused Again says...
2:29pm Fri 20 Mar 09

One of two things will happen at the hospital now.
1. A junior member of staff who lost the files will be dragged over the coals and then sacked.
OR
2. A senior member of staff who lost the files will apologise and the hospital will acept the apology. No further action will result.

Peguinboy1 says...
2:33pm Fri 20 Mar 09

I have to say that I agree with everyone here. Ok, so a mistake has been made and actions need to be taken to make sure that sensitive information doesn't get lost again, but why does the person who found it need to try to create such a big fuss?
The poor person who dropped it probably spent a long shift doing a job that very few of us could do, and for what? Only to have an innocent mistake banded around in the local media.
I think that some people might need to grow up a little bit and remember who they, and their loved ones, depend on when they need help.

Free speech says...
3:06pm Fri 20 Mar 09

iknowwheretheyare wrote:
I work at the hospital and i to cannot understand why the person that found the information gave it to the press,what would of been so wrong with taking to the hospital instead. All this could of been easily avoided with just a small ounce of common sense!!
Whoever took the records in question to The Press did a good job of alerting the public to the incompetence of some people at York District Hospital. Why try to protect incompetence?

Mike Proctor, deputy chief executive of York Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, apologised and said a full investigation had been launched. He said: “We take the protection of all patient information very seriously and we apologise to any of our patients and their families who may have been caused distress by this potential breach of their confidentiality.

As for Proctor-apologies just don't do it! This serious breach of security and privacy simply should NOT have happened! End of.

moose says...
3:17pm Fri 20 Mar 09

I am not complaining that the person who found the files alerted The Press, what does disturb me is that they actually thought it appropriate to give The Press the actual files with people's names in.

Just give it back to the hospital THEN tell The Press

iknowwheretheyare says...
3:38pm Fri 20 Mar 09

moose wrote:
I am not complaining that the person who found the files alerted The Press, what does disturb me is that they actually thought it appropriate to give The Press the actual files with people's names in. Just give it back to the hospital THEN tell The Press
The person that found it wasn't just anybody!
A lawyer apparently!

Peguinboy1 says...
3:59pm Fri 20 Mar 09

Free speech, South-west quadrant says...
3:06pm Fri 20 Mar 09
Whoever took the records in question to The Press did a good job of alerting the public to the incompetence of some people at York District Hospital. Why try to protect incompetence?

I think the point is that there are ways and means of solving the problem. How does giving personal records to a local paper solve the situation: if anything it only makes it potentially more damaging as there are more people who have access to records they shouldn't do.

TheTruthHurts says...
4:05pm Fri 20 Mar 09

Peguinboy1 wrote:
Free speech, South-west quadrant says... 3:06pm Fri 20 Mar 09 Whoever took the records in question to The Press did a good job of alerting the public to the incompetence of some people at York District Hospital. Why try to protect incompetence? I think the point is that there are ways and means of solving the problem. How does giving personal records to a local paper solve the situation: if anything it only makes it potentially more damaging as there are more people who have access to records they shouldn't do.
Well it was a good job it went to the press then, someone else could have plastered it all over the internet.

I think that we should know about these things, if it had just been handed in to the hospital then it would just have been forgotten,

Having a long /bad day or whatever is no excuse for incompetence! its a good job whoever dropped it wasnt carrying a kidney or a heart.

sun seeker's says...
4:57pm Fri 20 Mar 09

iknowwheretheyare wrote:
moose wrote: I am not complaining that the person who found the files alerted The Press, what does disturb me is that they actually thought it appropriate to give The Press the actual files with people's names in. Just give it back to the hospital THEN tell The Press
The person that found it wasn't just anybody! A lawyer apparently!
looks like he may have a new client then!

Mullarkian says...
5:27pm Fri 20 Mar 09

If the person has HIV and syphyllis, they are a danger to public health, the public need to know.

Soothsayer2.0 says...
5:43pm Fri 20 Mar 09

Great. Now everyone can read about my third testicle.

tealady731 says...
6:57pm Fri 20 Mar 09

how do we know that a member of york hospital staff dropped the files? why would staff take the files away from the hospital in the 1st place?
just possible it was some scroat that nicked them from the ward and threw then in the street, any1 thought of that?

kim the swim says...
8:33pm Fri 20 Mar 09

Soothsayer2.0 wrote:
Great. Now everyone can read about my third testicle.
ha ha

York1900 says...
10:40pm Fri 20 Mar 09

Mullarkian wrote:
If the person has HIV and syphyllis, they are a danger to public health, the public need to know.
They are no danger to public health if they are receiving treatment for the condition and HIV can only be passed on by swooping bodily fluids

Syphilis can be passed on during the primary or secondary stages through:

Oral, vaginal or anal sex.
Skin contact with any sores or rashes.

From a mother to unborn child.

It is not usually infectious when there are no symptoms.




Top Banana says...
1:56am Sat 21 Mar 09

If the person who gave all the details to the press is a lawyer, then what on earth were they thinking divulging all that information?
Surely they are incompetent and unprofessional in doing so?

SecurityMan says...
12:30pm Sat 21 Mar 09

I used to do the Medical Record Run around a year ago, and people should realise that it's actually Security Guards who get the records and the company is Group Response (who also have the security for the hospital). These guards are made to work around 347 hours a month and most of the time are tired and wirhdrawn. Alot of people think it's members of the trust that get the records, or someone who works for the NHS, but IT'S NOT! I was never checked by York Hospital and they went on the assumption I had an up-to-date CRB check.. What if I hadn't?
I remember a time last year when a patient actually died in A+E because the Security Guard got the WRONG notes and as a result, the NHS staff could not treat him!

So, in other words, if you want it done right, stop employing Security Guards to do a job that requires a bit of common sense!


Inquiry after patients’ details were found in the street Inquiry after patients’ details were found in the street

Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses