News RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


Incinerator joy for residents

JUBILANT residents have welcomed the withdrawal of controversial plans for an £18 million waste incinerator on the edge of a village near York.

BCB Environmental Management Ltd was hoping to transform a former Second World War aircraft hangar, at Marston Business Park, near Tockwith, into a waste facility that would produce energy by processing 60,000 tonnes of waste material a year.

Its plans met with fierce opposition from local residents, who feared potential problems with smells, health and increased traffic.

Now, following negotiations with the Environment Agency, BCB Environmental has decided to withdraw its application for planning permission – sparking relief among residents.

Coun John Savage, who represents Tockwith on Harrogate Borough Council and North Yorkshire County Council, said: “There has been jubilation in the Tockwith area since the announcement was made and I am very pleased too.

“If the waste incinerator went ahead, I think it would have been pretty terrible for the residents.

“BCB wanted a thermal plant to burn waste chemicals and nobody really knows what would have been discharged into the atmosphere.

“I had grave concerns for the health and safety of residents and I also think it would have looked completely out of place in the Vale of York – it would have looked like Blackpool Tower.”

But the jubilation of local residents could be short-lived because BCB managing director, Phil Boardman, said today that he intended to resubmit a revised application.

He said: “We have withdrawn our planning application while we review technology options that will enable us to deliver the scheme with minimal environmental impact. This will require a new application. “We remain convinced that energy from waste is the sensible, environmentally-responsible way to generate sustainable electricity and reduce the volume of waste that is sent to landfill.”

When operating, the plant would have generated an estimated ten megawatts of electricity through its combination of gasification and oxidation to destroy waste and recover its energy.

The company would have used the energy it needed to run the plant and the excess would have been sold to the National Grid.

Comments(2)

Michael Ryan says...
11:28am Wed 15 Oct 08

I hope readers of this article will start to think about the fact that infant deaths occur at a higher rate in electoral wards that are exposed to industrial PM2.5 emissions from incinerators and other sources.

Here's a map showing high infant death rates in wards around the Bernard Road incinerator which is in Darnall ward, Sheffield. The red-coloured ward immediately downwind of Darnall ward, with SW wind, is Rotherham West.:

http://www.ukhr.org/
incineration/sheffie
ldincinerator.pdf

Studies around incinerators in Japan and Italy have also found high infant mortality rates:

J Epidemiol. 2004 May;14(3):83-93.

Risk of adverse reproductive outcomes associated with proximity to municipal solid waste incinerators with high dioxin emission levels in Japan.
Tango T, Fujita T, Tanihata T, Minowa M, Doi Y, Kato N, Kunikane S, Uchiyama I, Tanaka M, Uehata T.
Department of Technology Assessment and Biostatistics, National Institute of Public Health, Wako, Saitama, Japan.

Epidemiology:Volume 18(5) SupplSeptember 2007p S125
Infant Mortality in 27 Italian Municipalities With Solid Waste Incinerators (1981-2001)

Bianchi, F; Minichilli, F; Pierini, A; Linzalone, N; Rial, M
CNR National Research Council, Institute of Clinical Physiology, Epidemiology Unit, Pisa, Italy.


The 1st sentence of the conclusion of the above Japanese study states:

"Our study shows a peak-decline in risk with distance from the municipal solid waste incinerators for infant deaths and infant deaths with all congenital malformations combined."

More information at www.ukhr.org

Kind regards,

Michael Ryan,
Shrewsbury


PC Environment says...
1:11pm Wed 15 Oct 08

If any of the "jubilant residents" are reading this, can you now take down the signs that have been up on the metal airfield fence on Rudgate (plus any others elsewhere) before they get lost in the bushes and become yet more rural litter.

Ta.

click2find

Most popular