News RSS Feed


Did Romans give us HIV?

3:50pm Friday 5th September 2008

comment Comments (9)   Have your say »

By Mark Stead »

HEALTH experts have denied suggestions that people living in North Yorkshire could be more vulnerable to AIDS because of the region’s Roman heritage.

Research carried out in France and published in the latest edition of a renowned science journal says people living in lands conquered by the Roman army had less protection against HIV than those in countries which they never reached.

Their findings suggest a gene which can make people less susceptible to the killer virus is more commonly found in areas of Europe where the Roman Empire never reached.

According to study leader Dr Eric Faure, of Provence University, the gene in question lacks certain DNA elements, which means HIV cannot link to it so easily and makes the virus less likely to infect cells.

Speaking in the New Scientist, he said a study of 19,000 DNA samples from across Europe showed the gene was not as common in regions conquered by the Romans.

Although North Yorkshire was not specifically mentioned in the research, York and its surrounding areas have long prided itself on their well-documented links to the Roman Empire, which bring millions of pounds into the region’s economy every year.

But HIV specialist Dr Ian Fairley, a doctor in genitor-urinary medicine at York Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, said the study’s findings should not increase anybody’s fears about the chances of contracting the disease.

“This is interesting research, but genetic variability should make no difference to how people behave on a day-to-day basis with regard to HIV,” he said. “The single best way to prevent HIV infection is to practise safe sex and use condoms.

“If people are unsure of their HIV status or believe they might be HIV positive, they should be tested.

“A great deal of progress has been made in the drug treatments which are available for people with HIV, and if people are tested and found to be HIV positive, they can begin to benefit from these treatments as soon as possible.”

In his report, Dr Faure added that he believed the Romans had carried a disease which proved particularly deadly to people carrying the gene variant which can lengthen the odds of HIV occurring, reducing its chances of being carried on through generations of families.

York has a rich Roman history, having been founded as Eboracum in AD 71 and being made one of two capitals of Roman Britain.


Your Say YourPress

bob the builder, York says...
3:54pm Fri 5 Sep 08

.. so the French are having a go at the Italians and trying to draw us in then.....

Hieronymous, York says...
4:41pm Fri 5 Sep 08

A small problem here: most modern Europeans (including many Italians) are descended from Teutonic and Slavic peoples who flooded into the vacuum left by the collapsing Empire. In other words, most of us ARE the people from regions the "Roman Empire" never reached ... its just that we were elsewhere when they didn't reach us!

Seadog, York says...
5:43pm Fri 5 Sep 08

This story appears to be a rejoinder to an article not yet carried by this paper, which lends it the kind of "reverse logic" to which local organs are unfortunately prone. I'm reminded of the ingenious (if lazy) reporter who once rang the Vatican and asked if there was any truth in a rumour that the Pope was about to get married: of course this was denied, and so the following day's headline read VATICAN DENIES POPE TO WED!

I am also reminded of my all-time-favourite YP headline (of some years ago): ROMANS BUILT WALL IN WRONG PLACE!

As for Eboracum's "long prided ... links" well - yes - but no more so than those of Londinium; Aquae Sulis; Deva; Camulodunum; Calleva Atrebartum; Glevum; Venta Bulgarum etc etc etc

who2believe, York says...
5:44pm Fri 5 Sep 08

And another inconvenient truth, most Roman soldiers were not from Rome. They were from the whole known world and became Roman by serving in the army.
Also, as Africa seems to be the continent with the worst HIV problems it doesn't make sense. The Romans never went South of Egypt.

Seadog, York says...
6:08pm Fri 5 Sep 08

Quite right; Who2believe! That was the first thing my wife said when I drew her attention to the article.

the butler, cowichan Bay says...
6:08pm Fri 5 Sep 08

It would be of greater service to your readers to have a factual report,instead of wasting useful space with speculation...
try Normandy or Spain if you must speculate.

petethefeet, York says...
10:12pm Fri 5 Sep 08

jeeps. It's not about where the Romans went 'on-tour', it's about their genetic makeup. Northern lands conquered by Romans received an input of mediterranean genes. Most Roman Soldiers here were from Spain. Susecptibility to many diseases is very-much related to your genes.
Also, this is another demonstration of the 'political-correctne
ss' associated with HIV. The establishment continually likes to preach that we are all equally vulnerable. For lots of reasons, this is blatantly untrue. In the eighties and nineties, the few well-respected scientists who tried to advocate that resources be focused on high-risk groups, were villified. It seems that we still haven't got over this stance. Perhaps leeches will help?

King of the Gypsies, York says...
9:02am Sat 6 Sep 08

I though Aids came from HOMOS

Opinion8ed, Haxby says...
3:41pm Sat 6 Sep 08

who2believe wrote:
And another inconvenient truth, most Roman soldiers were not from Rome. They were from the whole known world and became Roman by serving in the army.Also, as Africa seems to be the continent with the worst HIV problems it doesn't make sense. The Romans never went South of Egypt.
Africa currently has huge AIDS problems because of poor contraception education, and religious beliefs. These are two very different issues to that raised in the article.

Your sayYourPress

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE York Press account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?

Sponsored Links


Your Local Services


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »