Figures show revenue increase from council parking charges

COUNCILS across North Yorkshire have benefited from a big leap in revenue from parking charges, according to research by the Institute of Advanced Motorists (IAM).

But the figures, which the IAM says are calculated using data from the Department for Communities and Local Government, have been branded incorrect or misleading by many of the local authorities.

The IAM said the amount collected by Ryedale District Council more than doubled to £458,000 last year from £202,000 the previous year; City of York Council’s income rose from £4.15 million to £4.47 million; North Yorkshire County Council’s increased from nothing the previous year to £2.16 million last year and Selby District Council’s went up from £85,000 to £147,000.

But Selby council claimed the raw figures were ‘somewhat misleading’, saying total revenue from car parking rose very little from £298,000 in 2010/11 to £301,000 last year.

“The difference in the IAM figures appears to relate to a change in the way the accounts are recorded, with a different valuation for the car parking assets,” said a spokesman. “This is not because we believe the value of the land to be different; this is just a different way of recording the data, and does not relate to any material change in income or expenditure.”

A North Yorkshire spokesman said it was advising the institute that its figures for the county were incorrect.

He said: “The total surplus from parking charges for North Yorkshire was £1,988,327 for 2010/11 and £2,061,288 for 2011/12 – an increase of approximately £72,000 in the overall surplus because of the increased parking charges introduced in Harrogate as a means of improving traffic management in the town.”

Ryedale council said while the figures were correct, they were misleading. “Ryedale’s charges have not shot up, nor are we seeing massive increases in people using the car parks,” said a spokesman.

“The increase in figures is mainly down to an accounting adjustment, no cash involved, following a revaluation of the car parks.”

City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget, this was not the only source of funding used to develop improved transport schemes, including safety, and the authority successfully bid for and received £4.6 million funding from the Department for Transport’s Local Sustainable Transport Fund last year.

It said the council became the first ever local authority to join forces with the IAM last year on a scheme to offer young drivers a free assessment to improve their confidence and awareness on York’s roads.

Comments (7)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:22am Thu 10 Jan 13

roskoboskovic says...

is this meant to be a good thing.if you want to attract tourists and shoppers it s not a good idea to publicise how much they are being fleeced.hurry up with that monks cross development.FTN. F*** The Newts.
is this meant to be a good thing.if you want to attract tourists and shoppers it s not a good idea to publicise how much they are being fleeced.hurry up with that monks cross development.FTN. F*** The Newts. roskoboskovic
  • Score: 0

12:08pm Thu 10 Jan 13

YorkShrimper says...

"City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget"

Isn't this illegal? I didn't think that car parking revenues could be used fund other services?
"City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget" Isn't this illegal? I didn't think that car parking revenues could be used fund other services? YorkShrimper
  • Score: 0

7:13pm Thu 10 Jan 13

Paul Meoff says...

YorkShrimper wrote:
"City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget"

Isn't this illegal? I didn't think that car parking revenues could be used fund other services?
Curious. What are they supposed to do with the money - build more car parks and clog the roads even more? Less car parks and more Park and Ride makes more sense.
[quote][p][bold]YorkShrimper[/bold] wrote: "City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget" Isn't this illegal? I didn't think that car parking revenues could be used fund other services?[/p][/quote]Curious. What are they supposed to do with the money - build more car parks and clog the roads even more? Less car parks and more Park and Ride makes more sense. Paul Meoff
  • Score: 0

12:01am Fri 11 Jan 13

bob the builder says...

The best place to park for free in York is on the double yellow lines outside the PO sorting office on Leeman Road - no-one has had a ticket in 18 years.
The best place to park for free in York is on the double yellow lines outside the PO sorting office on Leeman Road - no-one has had a ticket in 18 years. bob the builder
  • Score: 0

12:11am Fri 11 Jan 13

inthesticks says...

YorkShrimper wrote:
"City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget"

Isn't this illegal? I didn't think that car parking revenues could be used fund other services?
Just wondering what you thought they did with 4 million quid - Share it amongst the Traffic Wardens? Sorry for the sarcasm, I`m just bemused by the question.
[quote][p][bold]YorkShrimper[/bold] wrote: "City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget" Isn't this illegal? I didn't think that car parking revenues could be used fund other services?[/p][/quote]Just wondering what you thought they did with 4 million quid - Share it amongst the Traffic Wardens? Sorry for the sarcasm, I`m just bemused by the question. inthesticks
  • Score: 0

12:39pm Fri 11 Jan 13

RooBeck says...

inthesticks wrote:
YorkShrimper wrote:
"City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget"

Isn't this illegal? I didn't think that car parking revenues could be used fund other services?
Just wondering what you thought they did with 4 million quid - Share it amongst the Traffic Wardens? Sorry for the sarcasm, I`m just bemused by the question.
Just for a change - how about re-investment in support of motorists? Like filling-in the massive amount of potholes on all our roads, the presence of which contradicts all of the talk by various agencies over road-safety. If there is any change, make their car-parks more secure with additional lighting and pay for regular patrols by private security firms? Also, provide financial grants for road-safety training initiatives, especially those connected to younger drivers.
[quote][p][bold]inthesticks[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]YorkShrimper[/bold] wrote: "City of York Council said while revenue from parking fees was put back into the overall council budget" Isn't this illegal? I didn't think that car parking revenues could be used fund other services?[/p][/quote]Just wondering what you thought they did with 4 million quid - Share it amongst the Traffic Wardens? Sorry for the sarcasm, I`m just bemused by the question.[/p][/quote]Just for a change - how about re-investment in support of motorists? Like filling-in the massive amount of potholes on all our roads, the presence of which contradicts all of the talk by various agencies over road-safety. If there is any change, make their car-parks more secure with additional lighting and pay for regular patrols by private security firms? Also, provide financial grants for road-safety training initiatives, especially those connected to younger drivers. RooBeck
  • Score: 0

12:41pm Fri 11 Jan 13

YorkShrimper says...

Was asking the question as to where the surplus revenues go. It's illegal to use car park revenue surplus to fund general council services, but I think it's ok to use it within improving traffic infrastructure. You never really know with York council what they are doing with funds.
Was asking the question as to where the surplus revenues go. It's illegal to use car park revenue surplus to fund general council services, but I think it's ok to use it within improving traffic infrastructure. You never really know with York council what they are doing with funds. YorkShrimper
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree