Extinction lesson from past

I READ Kate Lock’s article on the possible demise of the polar bears with interest. (The Press September 21.) Kate also writes “Scientists....are using words like planetary catastrophe...uncharted territory.”

However, Earth may have been here before and well before humans.

The first dinosaurs evolved in the Triassic, some 250 million years, ago. However, during the Permian era, 252 million years ago, a mass extinction occurred, both on land and at sea. Life on Earth took ten million years to recover.

A theory is the positive feedbacks, like methane release that Kate mentions, led to polar ice melt and in turn led to failure of the ocean circulation known as the global conveyor.

That led to extinction of life in the oceans which became more like a stagnant pond on a large scale as the mixing currents failed, and extinction on land, as hydrogen sulphide gas from the stagnant “pond” changed the composition of the atmosphere and made land life struggle to survive.

A message from the past?

Chris Clayton, Hempland Drive, York

Comments(2)

ColdAsChristmas says...
3:29pm Tue 25 Sep 12

What you have described Chris is natural climatic change, something not a single one of us can do a thing about.
At a time when the Earth was an ice ball, thought to be caused by a weak Sun, CO2 levels were up to 330,000 parts per million, a long way from the tiny 395 PPM of recent times. When you consider that man made CO2 represents a meagre 16 PPM you come to realise how pathetic and unnecessary these CO2 reduction schemes really are.
As for Polar Bears, how on earth did they adapt and survive the Medieval warm period to be at record recorded numbers today? Adapt may be the answer to Kate's problem rather than environmental taxing that makes it ever more difficult for marginalised people to keep warm from all this freezing heat!
You talk of 'Polar ice melt,' you mean Summer ice melt. But, Antarctic ice is increasing, so we are only talking about the North Pole.
Climate, like weather is chaotic and no computer model can tell you anything other than what went before. The North Pole ice sits on sea water and is subject to a multitude of forces including Ocean currents, thermal expansion, dense air pressure, Zero Sun for 3 months in winter and 24/ 7 sun for a few months.
Unlike the South Pole that rarely gets a mention these days from warming alarmists, due to it's maritime climate the North Pole is actually on Average 10c Warmer than the average on Greenland, hence the reason why the Greenland ice shelf remains in tact and growing. (Check out Glacier girl and the lost P38 aircraft lost in a July ice storm in South East Greenland)
A recent article in the Press also wrongly stated that the North West Passage had been closed for 800,000 years until recently. Not true, as it is well documented that the Chinese sailed this route in 1421. This takes us back to those poor cuddly Polar Bears so that will do regards unzipping the hype and propaganda for now. I need to turn my heating on!

PinzaC55 says...
10:02pm Thu 27 Sep 12

I am old enough to remember "New Ice Age", "Save The Whale", Ban The Bomb", "CJD will kill 250,000 a year", "Foot and Mouth", "Y2K", "Mobile Phones cause cancer" , "Salmonella in eggs" etc. These were supposed to be apocalyptic but none of them were, and in the case of CJD the maximum number of people who died in the UK per annum was 28.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree