Prudence and growth

MANY people, especially in the Labour Party, seem to think we have a choice only of austerity or growth during these difficult times, but that is not so.

It is possible to have cutbacks, to implement austerity measures and to still have growth.

Germany did this at the time of reunification. The old DDR (East Germany ) was, in 1989/1990, in a desperately rundown condition.

German Chancellor Helmut Kohl decided the wealthy West Germans would have to make sacrifices to help the renewal of East Germany. West Germans accepted a wage freeze, no increase in living standards for 15 years, lower pension provision, fewer welfare benefits, fewer social security payments, fewer foreign holidays, less consumer spending, less state expenditure, fewer increases on infrastructure and an all-round tightening of belts.

This required discipline, efficiency, prudence and a firm belief that the end justified the means.

Look at the difference now.

Germany is the powerhouse of Europe, in surplus with the whole country benefiting from those years of damn hard work and struggle, Southern Europe, Ireland and the UK are to all intents and purposes bankrupt. Despite this, they refuse to live in the real world and expect something for nothing.

David Quarrie, Lynden Way, Holgate, York.

Comments(4)

YorkToff says...
12:18pm Mon 28 May 12

It is you who does not live in the real world.

Germany is a completely different case to that of the UK's.

They decided to take back East Germany and knew it would be hard but the huge benefits of massive farmland and other gains made it all worthwhile.

The financial crisis did not exist back then.

Germany has benefitted greatly from the Euro and exports to the UK and other EU nations.

They are very wealthy and do not have the huge housing mortgage market that the UK has.

£7 billion of the UKs wealth is tied up in property and mortgages. Germany does not have this liquidity problem.

Austerity is destroying the UKs ability to grow because it has been implemented in a time of continued recession, again Germany imposed their controls before the receions caused by the current financial crisis.

Should Germany and the worlds bankers insist on continued austerity to the poor EU nations it will destroy their economies which already have growing massive unemployment.

Enough is enough Mr Quarrie, surely right wing obsessives like you can see that.

YorkToff says...
12:25pm Mon 28 May 12

Should have been £7 TRILLION tied up in mortgages and personal housing.

Jezreel says...
2:40pm Mon 28 May 12

OK Mr Quarrie, you are an apologist for Germany ad nauseum. However readers are entitled to have your assessment of German policy between 1935 and 1945. Also how about joining the rest of us in a ringing condemnation of the holocaust ? It's not much to ask.

Buzz Light-year says...
10:15pm Mon 28 May 12

DQ is going through!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree