Letters RSS Feed


Badger cull to break the cycle of infection

BARBARA BOYCE (Letters, August 23) highlights an emotive issue and that is the devastation being caused by bovine TB. Last year more than 32,000 cattle were needlessly slaughtered as a result of this terrible disease.

Yorkshire and the north east remain largely TB free and there is no evidence of the disease in our wildlife. We want to keep it that way, and support Government proposals to tackle TB head on in areas where it is rife.

We believe this must involve tackling the increasingly diseased badger population in hotspot areas – essentially to break the cycle of infection.

The package of measures being considered by the Government is exactly that – a wide range of measures that includes all the suggestions made by Ms Boyce, such as increased levels of cattle testing, improved farm bio-security and stricter controls on cattle movements.

Sadly, this alone will not halt the spread of TB and the latest evidence suggests a targeted cull of badgers in hotspot areas would make an important contribution to the fight against this disease.

Ms Boyce also refers to the role of vaccination, but this is likely to be at least five years away.

Barney Kay, Regional director, NFU North East, Tadcaster Road, York.

Comments(6)

Matt_S says...
4:31pm Mon 29 Aug 11

"Last year more than 32,000 cattle were needlessly slaughtered as a result of this terrible disease."

Whereas only 2.2 million were needlessly slaughtered as a result of human greed.

I find it incredible that we are now looking to slaughter wildlife because they may infect animals that were going to be slaughtered anyway.

How about cutting out consumption of the latter, thus making the former unnecessary?

Overproof says...
5:10pm Mon 29 Aug 11

Except, according to the scientists, a Badger cull will have no effect of the rates of Bovine TB.

It is poor farming practices that encourage the spread of this infection, not the Badgers.

CHISSY1 says...
6:55pm Mon 29 Aug 11

Overproof wrote:
Except, according to the scientists, a Badger cull will have no effect of the rates of Bovine TB.

It is poor farming practices that encourage the spread of this infection, not the Badgers.
You must be a farmer to come out with a statement like that.

Big Bad Wolf says...
3:40pm Tue 30 Aug 11

CHISSY1 wrote:
Overproof wrote: Except, according to the scientists, a Badger cull will have no effect of the rates of Bovine TB. It is poor farming practices that encourage the spread of this infection, not the Badgers.
You must be a farmer to come out with a statement like that.
Quite the oppersit I would have thought.... If Overproof were indeed a farmer he would not be pointing out the shortfall in farming practices.

carl19692 says...
4:35pm Tue 30 Aug 11

I dont believe culling Badgers will have the desired effect and plenty of other people agree:

http://twitdoc.com/u
pload/lisagsd/anti-b
adgercull-leaflet.pd
f

Intensive farming and maize diets for cattle dont seem to be helping!

CHISSY1 says...
7:00pm Tue 30 Aug 11

Big Bad Wolf wrote:
CHISSY1 wrote:
Overproof wrote: Except, according to the scientists, a Badger cull will have no effect of the rates of Bovine TB. It is poor farming practices that encourage the spread of this infection, not the Badgers.
You must be a farmer to come out with a statement like that.
Quite the oppersit I would have thought.... If Overproof were indeed a farmer he would not be pointing out the shortfall in farming practices.
"Indeed" i was being sarcastic.

click2find

Most popular


About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree