Letters RSS Feed


You can e-mail your letters to letters@thepress.co.uk

We welcome letters on all topics but please keep them to 200 words at most; shorter letters are most likely to be included. The editor reserves the right to edit letters.

If you wish the letter to appear in The Press you must include your full postal address and a daytime telephone number.


Two thousand years of immigration


It is obvious that Alistair McDonald’s letter (Evasive act, March 6) was not only politically motivated – perhaps he should have stated which political party he supports – but demonstrated a lack of knowledge of the British Isles.

Migration started here when the islands were part of the European continent. During the past 2,000 years there have been the Romans and those who came with them, the Danes, Saxons, Normans and many others.

As a result of persecution, for religious and political views, there followed the Huguenots and French royalists.

The changing of Royal households brought more immigration – the House of Orange from the Netherlands and the Windsors from Germany.

Many stayed after the Second World War, including Hungarians, Poles and Italians, while Commonwealth residents were asked to come here to work in the hospitals and on public transport due to the shortage of workers needed to run the country.

More recently, our taste for different foods has expanded the restaurant trade and the numbers who work in it As for the argument over other European Union residents moving to the UK, it's a flawed one.

How many British people live and work across Europe? Millions. If you say that these people cannot live there all those UK passport holders living abroad could be sent home.

I have a brilliant Polish dentist, as do many in the city. Does Mr McDonald really want these people not to be here? Immigration has made this country a better place.

We all have immigrants in our family history, including my great-grandfather who came from Eire, while another family member came from the Low Countries in the 16th century.

I would urge Mr McDonald to take a look back a few generations into his own family history – he may get quite a shock.

Coun Tracey Simpson-Laing, Salisbury Road, York.


Comments(10)

ak7274 says...
2:06pm Fri 12 Mar 10

Once again Sideshow Bob is being disingenous. I would suggest that although Mr Mcdonald is a raving bigot and his letter unwise, I do however, as the great grandson of a Potato famine immigrant think the problem that shows itself now is not indeed the fact we have migration, but the mass migration the Labour government said would not happen when Poland acceeded to the European Union.
We as a nation should be proud of our history and the ever changing picture of Britain as a modern and changing society, but at the total expense of the indigenous population. Go on, some pratt ask how far back we should go to justify indigenous. She probably has a Polish dentist because the ones trained at our expense go private at the first chance of making a buck. Another Labour success.

sheps lad says...
3:00pm Fri 12 Mar 10

How far back should we go to justify indigenous?
"A. Pratt.

Alucard says...
4:06pm Fri 12 Mar 10

Can they use a fork properly

ak7274 says...
4:50pm Fri 12 Mar 10

I did of course mean "not at the total expense of the indigenous population"

Jam tomorrow says...
9:17pm Fri 12 Mar 10

I am against any more immigration into Britain for the single reason of overpopulation.
We are running out of power, water, roads, food, housing, medical resources, wildlife and now fresh air and it is all to do with overpopulation and no politician will talk about it.
(Well one will but I don't really want to vote for them.)

petethefeet says...
11:16pm Fri 12 Mar 10

Jam tomorrow wrote:
I am against any more immigration into Britain for the single reason of overpopulation. We are running out of power, water, roads, food, housing, medical resources, wildlife and now fresh air and it is all to do with overpopulation and no politician will talk about it. (Well one will but I don't really want to vote for them.)
Tracey. This is bang on. We need a population decline in the UK. Everywhere, resources and services are under stress.

SensibleSimon says...
8:34am Sat 13 Mar 10

I think both sides of the immigration debate are flawed. You can't say all immigrants are good or bad. Some are good, some are bad. Some indigenous people are good, some are bad. The problem is not different people, and where they are from. The only problems stem from bad people. Like politicians!

Cold_as_Christmas says...
3:12am Sun 14 Mar 10

Too many people in the UK & far too many in and around York + we are turning into a foreign country and the multiculturalism imposed on us means that there is little or no British Culture for immigrants to integrate into.
Like the carbon con, sky high cost of energy and Council Tax, none of our politicians will properly address these issues. Just spin, spin & more spin with a bit of propaganda thrown in is all you will get!

KarenWhite1978 says...
4:13pm Sun 14 Mar 10

Cold_as_Christmas wrote:
Too many people in the UK & far too many in and around York + we are turning into a foreign country and the multiculturalism imposed on us means that there is little or no British Culture for immigrants to integrate into. Like the carbon con, sky high cost of energy and Council Tax, none of our politicians will properly address these issues. Just spin, spin & more spin with a bit of propaganda thrown in is all you will get!
IQs in York remain desperately low, it seems.

ak7274 says...
6:42pm Sun 14 Mar 10

Karen why don't you justify your insult with a balanced argument? Or is your IQ similar to your shoe size too?
Cold as christmas is expressing a view taken by a whole load of the population and even though you just call him down, his views are more valid than yours by insulting him. I know he doesn't need defending ,but you need to be a little more lucid.
Sorry if I butted in. Oh and I disagree with him on many issues too.


Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses