Buildings are a blot on St Saviourgate

York Press: The view of St Saviourgate before Stonebow house was built to block the view The view of St Saviourgate before Stonebow house was built to block the view

MARK GLADWIN is right to decry unreasonable hatred of 60s buildings in York (Letters, December 5).

However, the two examples he celebrates, Hilary House and Stonebow House, combine to destroy one of York’s finest streets, St Saviourgate.

As succinctly put In Pevsner’s Buildings of England, “at one end is the disastrous Stonebow House and at the other the characterless Hilary House”. Hilary House is out of scale with the street and far too bland for such an important position.

Stonebow House hardly acknowledges St Saviourgate at all and presents a brutal and ugly backside to it.

The side to Stonebow is no better and shows its contempt for the pedestrian most obviously adjacent to the bus stops where the main offering is a leaking soil pipe surrounded by crude concrete.

The office block on top may be no worse than many others, but to the man or woman in the street that is completely irrelevant.

Nick Derbyshire, South Esplanade, York.

Comments (2)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

1:14pm Mon 9 Dec 13

Jonthan says...

Buy that man a pint.
Buy that man a pint. Jonthan

10:58pm Mon 9 Dec 13

Waspish1 says...

The picture above shows that this area could be converted into a wonderful open space..............n
ow waiting for someone to suggest it could be a bus station.
The picture above shows that this area could be converted into a wonderful open space..............n ow waiting for someone to suggest it could be a bus station. Waspish1

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree