Health over speed

WHAT a cockeyed no-brainer. Who needs 20 minutes or so lopped off a train journey going to or from wherever? Especially at the mind-boggling price it’s going to cost.

If given the choice of a streamline railway service or a streamline NHS, I know what the majority of us would welcome most.

God forbid, but if a crowded fast tracker, because of its ill-planned idiotic speed, became derailed, I know, without having gone to university, which service would be of the greater value.

Ken Holmes, Cliffe Common, Selby.

Comments(5)

ColdAsChristmas says...
3:10pm Mon 11 Feb 13

We don't need it Ken but improve what we have with more British made rolling stock.
HS2 is just 'keeping up with the Jones'

You mention the NHS but unfortunately successive governments have tried to run it like a business and you know what targets have done to health care. (Same thing with this CO2 renewable business, that appears unstoppable until lots of influential folks undertake brain surgery to correct their problem)

So, you can get to London 20 minutes faster at an unaffordable cost.
Who pays? Are we all in it together?

Paul Meoff says...
9:06pm Mon 11 Feb 13

Bring back the stagecoach. We are local people. We don't want any of that newfangled progress around here.

ColdAsChristmas says...
12:27am Tue 12 Feb 13

Since when was wasting money we haven't even got, progress, Paul?

old_geezer says...
7:03pm Tue 12 Feb 13

It's as much about capacity and reliability as journey time, e.g. allowing the East and West Coast Main Lines to be used for more freight and stopping passenger services.

That said, I would prefer the money spent on upgrading the existing network nationwide, plus links like Cambridge-Oxford.

Magicman! says...
1:35am Thu 14 Feb 13

Errrrmmmm, where exactly does it say that over the next 20 years there will be no money spent on upgrading existing infastructure and rolling stock??

We've recently had Holgate Junction expanded to 4 track to improve approach speeds and capacity around York, there's the Hitchin flyover being built, and there's several other schemes that will take place along the ECML to improve capacity.
If you go to the NRM you will see that carriage builders Eversholt have a mockup of a current Intercity 225 carriage in various different layouts - the electric rolling stock that is currently used by East Coast will be refurbished to this proposed standard over the next 2-3 years whilst the Class 91 locomotives will either receive a complete overhaul or will be replaced (both will result in faster trains and better reliability); the Intercity 125's are going to be replaced by Intercity Express trains, which will make their debut in 2018 as I recall; Transpennine Express will have a 4th fast train per hour between York and Manchester from next spring (this going on to Liverpool and will be about 30 minutes faster than the current Liverpool service), whilst the TP route will be electrified by 2018 and will as a result of this receive brand new (and longer) trains....
All the above IS happening, and is happening irrespective of HS2.
Anybody saying there won't be investment in other routes whilst HS2 is being built is just using this remark to get people to join their true cause: to not get the line built anywhere near their homes/buisnesses.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree