Sir Neil Mckay defends axing of children’s heart unit in Leeds

THE man behind the decision to move children’s heart surgery services from Leeds to Newcastle has insisted it was the right decision.

Sir Neil Mckay defended the controversial move yesterday in front of a regional health scrutiny committee in Leeds, made up of council members from throughout Yorkshire.

Despite a 600,000 signature petition against the loss of services at Leeds General Infirmary, Sir Neil said there was always going to be disappointment and that the consultation and decision process had been fair.

He said: “Many people believe that our processes have been flawed. The Court of Appeal said our consultation process was not flawed.”

The Leeds unit serves a population of 14 million people within a two-hour drive time and campaigners argue that if surgery is moved, patients will have to travel to Newcastle, Liverpool or Birmingham.

Comments(5)

Zetkin says...
8:33am Wed 25 Jul 12

One assumes Sir Neil doesn't have a young family member whose life will be at risk thanks to the driving time to the nearest heart unit being doubled.

Keep slashing your budgets, and you'll be a peer before you know it.

NoMorePlease says...
11:08am Wed 25 Jul 12

So much has been said about this emotive subject. What I fail to grasp from an economic or geographic point of view is why both Leicester and Leeds are being chopped

Digeorge says...
1:32pm Wed 25 Jul 12

Called 'quality' issues.

I am sure that Sir Neil McKay having being former Chief Executive of Leeds Teaching Hospitals Trust would have found this issue difficult but realises the importance of making a decision and actually understands the issues of sick children.

I am sure that he would resided over a number of complaints' processes from parents who have lost children whose children should have been operated in Newcastle during his Chief Executive post. However, it would have been nice to have had a proper apology over it all.

I could list the operations including transplantation that can not be done and it just doesn't end there.

big boy york says...
6:21pm Wed 25 Jul 12

this is playing with peoples lives, what would the chances be of a family losing a child whilst on route to newcastle/liverpool taking sir neil mckay to court for causing the death of there child

NoMorePlease says...
10:42pm Wed 25 Jul 12

big boy york wrote:
this is playing with peoples lives, what would the chances be of a family losing a child whilst on route to newcastle/liverpool taking sir neil mckay to court for causing the death of there child
That is just a stupid comment

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree